ESPN Soccernet - Correspondents - Tottenham Hotspur
soccernet blog
Tottenham Hotspur
Posted by Colin McCullough on 12/01/2009

With that other team from north London losing at the weekend, a point against Aston Villa was enough to leave Spurs in third place. In fact, given the number of chances that the team created, a win looked the more likely result as the game wore on, with Harry Redknapp reflecting that:

"We dominated and I'm sure Martin (O'Neill) was happier to hear the final whistle than I was. There was only one team going to win it in the second half and it was just a case of getting the goal - once we equalised I was sure we were going to go on and win it ... We knew it would be tough, they are a good side and they've had some great results at Villa Park but it was one-way traffic in the second half. I was delighted with how we played, we pushed them back, played some great football and made all the chances."

Many of those chances resulted from another outstanding display by Niko Kranjcar, who was clearly the best player on the field. With Spurs pressing for a winner, it was, therefore, an astonishing decision by the manager to replace him with Robbie Keane with almost a quarter of an hour still remaining. Keane's contribution was, needless to say, zero. Redknapp had observed before the game that "Robbie always wants to play. Robbie would not want to be left too often for sure, so he'll be available, and we'll have to look at it."

Sure enough, Keane got on, as the manager continued with his policy of accommodating the Irishman whatever the cost. Redknapp would no doubt claim that he was making a positive move by introducing a third striker but the truth of the matter was plain to see - the game's most creative and influential player was taken off for one whose influence is, more often than not, negligible.

Thankfully, the team as a whole once again played well, a somewhat subdued Crouch and Defoe aside. Dawson was clearly energized by being given the captain's armband, and added to his customary 110% effort with a well-taken goal. One very pleasing aspect of the performance was that Spurs dominated a good Villa side despite the absence of the likes of Woodgate, King and Modric. Outside of the first team, the squad contains players of proven ability or exciting potential. Although one or two of them - most obviously Pavlyuchenko - may leave in January, it appears that there is little need for the manager to add to the existing personnel. The one exception may be a goalkeeper, to take the place of the injured Carlo Cudicini.

Before the transfer window opens, Spurs face Everton, Wolves, Man. City, Blackburn, Fulham and West Ham in the Premier League. On current form, there is every reason to suppose that the team will begin 2010 with their position in the top four consolidated.

Comments

Posted by dean on 12/01/2009

Totally agree. Harry is a little weak when it comes to Keane and Kranjar, Harry knows is a great professional and wont complain, but Harry definitely limited Tottenham to a point by taking Kranjar off.

Posted by mike on 12/01/2009

There is no reason why Peter Crouch should be starting in this line up. Sure he brings size, but we achieved better results with Robbie and Defoe upfront. Why change something that worked? Keep Niko on the left and bring Crouch on as a sub if needed.

Posted by JOHN ADAM on 12/01/2009

Since Kranjcar was having an excellent game, Redknapp made a mistake in substituting him for Keane. Who knows if Kranjcar would not have netted a precious goal during those last fifteen minutes? He was the linchpin of the midfield and looked threatening all along.You do not remove someone of that calibre who could have scored the much needed goal in such an important match.

Posted by wayne king on 12/01/2009

I can't agree that Kranjcar was MOTM, although I've been delighted by his form when he's played recently. I'm a Spurs fan but there was only one contender for MOTM for me and it was Carlos Cuellar. He was simply immense and without him in their side, Villa might have been massacred at home embarassingly.

A great game to watch and a testament to Harry and the lads that a draw felt disappointing for the performance they turned in come the final whistle. But I feel that was more down to Cuellar than any other player on the pitch. He was outstanding imo.

Posted by Oz on 12/01/2009

Thats some of the best material I have read in the last twenty years (especially the forecast for top four) lets hope the dreams become reality COYS

Posted by Mark Ross on 12/01/2009

Niko Kranjcar is undoubtably the find of the season. His deft touches, elusive running and eye for goal has given us the balance we needed on the left flank (with Aaron operating on the right). He proved again on the weekend that HR is "The Man" when dealing in a very difficult and expensive transfer market! So?? My question stands; when Luka M comes back, who will make way for him OR will it be a case of he'll get his chances when HR gives it to him leaving him to prove to the manager that he is worth a starting place in the current squad! I was one of those who hailed the return of Keane, but, under the current circumstances, does he warrant a starting place? My answer is simple. NO! Go Spurs !!!!

Posted by jh on 12/01/2009

i feel that harry made a wrong choice to subsitute niko with robbie. i guess is that he actually thought we need robbie before the equaliser. niko is a fantastic piece of bargain and if he keeps this form, he might have a chance to retain position in the midfield berth with luka, wilson and aaron ..

Posted by Gary Stewart on 12/01/2009

You all wouldn't be bashing Keane if Huddlestone would have played him late in the second half instead of shooting through a group of players. HR was right in resting Kranjcar don't we play United today?

Posted by Zwelo on 12/02/2009

By far the best perfomance by Spurs in a couple of years. Given that Villa are a good side. we did poorly against Man. Utd, Chelsea and Arsenal. The perfomance against Villa makes me believe that we are legitimate. most important is that we are deep now. I look at the bench and see Bale, Pavlychenko, Bentley, Jenas, Woodgate etc Those arew good players. Harry has to find a way to keep them at the Lane for us to challenge for top honours. Go spurs

Posted by A Yank on 12/02/2009

It is getting tiring, but I have been literally saying for weeks that Kranjcar is a starter and Keane needs to go. I think that 'Arry is the only one at this point who doesn't understand that.

With the funds we get from selling Pav (and hopefully Keane, although I doubt it) we should look for a solid young third striker to back up Defoe and Crouch. It wouldn't be a post from me unless I also gave my weekly call to sell Jenas too. Wouldn't mind seeing King gone before he can no longer walk and they should get rid of Bentley too.

All those players should give us a solid chunk of money to play around with and add a bit of depth in middle of the park and also pick up a backup keeper that we suddenly need after Cudicini went all daredevil.

Posted by jack on 12/02/2009

@ gary stewart well that didn't happen and keane would have probably missed anyway and also niko is cup tied.totally agree with the article.

Posted by Roger NZ on 12/02/2009

'Spurs will not finish in top four unless Harry finds two experienced players who will make the team mentally tougher.
The performance at Old Trafford last night shows they are "too soft" and lack consistency.
Kranjcar was superb at Villa. Robbie Keane now lacks pace to penetrate but does work well with Defoe.
Jenas ,Huddlestone and Palacios must be mentally stronger and boss games like Lampard,Scholes and Giggs.
I have supported 'Spurs for 58 years and feel this team could go all the way with more steeliness.

Posted by Raj on 12/02/2009

Niko is a gun but it will be interesting when luka is back into the fold to see where he will slot in. Maybe a case of playing just Defoe up front flanked by kranjcar and Modric?

Crouch can be a good 'off the bench' player and add a different dimension to the game to make the opposition defense worry about something else. Plus I think that the prescence of Crouch makes Spurs believe they can start playing a long ball game, which somewhat nullifies Defoe's other great trait, running at defenders, as he will then only get through balls or knock ons from the big man.

Robbie as much as he is one of the my favourite players, will need to up the ante if he is to justifiably get game time, let alone start.

Posted by kl on 12/02/2009

I have almost maintained the same thing: Harry is not good when it comes to turning games around in-game.

Instead of selling Pavlyuchenko, Harry should be selling Keane. Or both. Or if selling is not an option, then don't use him in games or in moments that are crucial. Keane is off-form right now, and he needs time to get his touch. Crouch and Defoe are the better starters for now.

Posted by daniel25 on 12/02/2009

Spurs failed to beat MU again but Harry believes Spurs capable of reaching CL. Can this actualize? Guys, think for a moment. I strongly believe Spurs need to bring in quality players to strengthen the defence. Current batch unable to cope attacking football. The rest looks good except Keane. I don't think he can bring success to the team. Harry should start Defoe, Pav, Niko, Modric & Crouch to maintain the good run & work harder against the Big 4. Let see what happens against Everton this weekend.

Posted by jerome on 12/02/2009

i think robbie keane is rubbish and boring...krancjar will always be the better play maker harry only plays keane cuz of reputation otherwise why would he make an illogical substitution...just sell ledley king as well he is another waste

Posted by lmarsh on 12/02/2009

Finally an insightful article about Spurs. Redknapp's worst game of the season as a manager was against Sunderland where Spurs were awful and all because he felt the need to play Keane. Once Kranjcar came on for the last 15 minutes it was a different ball game!

Keane abandoned Tottenham when we needed him and Redknapp need not feel any sense of loyalty to a player that clearly at the moment is not good enough to make our best XI.

Posted by Magic Man on 12/02/2009

When Modric comes back 'Arry should consider playing him as a supporting striker. Crouch's touch is criminal and Keane just looks lost and out of form. Modric has the creativity and attacking flair to combine with defoe and provide that link that is sometimes missing between midfield and Defoe. Krancjar was so influential in the Villa game his poise on the ball purpose are awesome right now, certainly he is more valuable that Crouch or Keane atm.

Posted by spurs fan on 12/03/2009

4-4-1-1 > ekotto, bassong, dawson, corluka / kranjcar, polacios, huddlestone, lennon / modric / defoe

sell pav

Posted by Murtaza on 12/03/2009

Kranjar is a great player, and he fits well with Tottenham, however he did look tired and the only other striking option was Roman P, who is about to get shipped off anyway. Harry was left with no options but to play Keane there. More importantly with games coming thick and fast for Tottenham, there is no other left winger available and Keane has been shouldering that burden because he is a team player and can fill that gap atleast till Modric comes back.

Posted by Maandip Gill on 12/05/2009

Whatever said and done, we're currently sitting 3rd in the table! We wouldn't be there if the boss doesn't know what's he doing.. Lets not try and be smarter than HR.. Go spurs!!

Posted by anonomys on 12/06/2009

harry needs to put in giovani dos santos

  Post your comment
Name:
Email Address:
Comments:
characters left