ESPN Soccernet - Correspondents - Tottenham Hotspur
soccernet blog
Tottenham Hotspur
Posted by Colin McCullough on 09/15/2009

All good things must come to an end. And it was no surprise that the winning run ended against Man. Utd., a team that Spurs haven’t beaten in the league since 2001. For all of the early media misgivings about the post-Ronaldo United following the blip at Burnley, this is still a side that have lost just one of their last 13 Premier League games. Their victory at White Hart Lane was well-deserved

Having signed Niko Kranjcar as seemingly a direct replacement for the injured Luka Modric, the manager then elected to leave the Croatian on the bench on Saturday, instead giving a first league start to Peter Crouch and moving Robbie Keane back into the midfield. Crouch was excellent, particularly in the first half, winning everything in the air and displaying an assured first touch.

Keane, by contrast, was totally anonymous. When eventually replaced by Kranjcar, it was hard to remember that he had even been on the pitch. If his continual selection results from the fact that he is captain, then Harry Redknapp has made an error of judgment in handing him that role. The latest rumor is that Celtic will move for Keane in January, with Scott Brown coming the other way. All things considered, this looks like it would be good for the Irishman, perhaps giving him a chance to rejuvenate a career that may be in danger of fizzling out at Spurs. (Quite how Brown would cope with the gap in class between the EPL and the SPL is a whole other question.)

Keane’s inclusion on the left hand side of midfield was certainly a contributing factor in the defeat, as was a poor performance from Wilson Palacios. A long trip on international duty may partially explain why the Honduran was so out of sorts and when he was taken off, there was more than a suspicion that the decision was made for fear that he might be sent off. United themselves then lost Scholes to a red card, with Ferguson hilariously opining that "he’s been sent off because his name is Paul Scholes". A more probable reason for his dismissal was a series of two-footed lunges, the first of which could easily have been a straight red. The jocular remarks about Scholes’ inability to tackle are really wearing thin. What should be remarked on is his propensity to clatter opponents long after the ball is no longer there to be won.

Despite this first defeat, there are still plenty of reasons for optimism. It was hardly a mauling, with Spurs still well in the game and still creating chances at 2-1 down. Defoe and Crouch are in sparkling form, and Palacios will return to his best. Spurs are still in the top four and, looking longer term, will have two hugely influential players in Modric and Woodgate coming back into the side.

In the short term, the team now faces another stern test against Chelsea. The league leaders squeaked a win at the Britannia Stadium at the weekend, and if Spurs can match Stoke’s application and add a dash of quality, there is no reason why what is still a good start cannot continue.

Comments

Posted by Ashley Collie on 09/15/2009

Footie's a game of inches, Jenas' screamer fingertipped away, Crouchie's header off the bar, both at 1-2 I believe, could've changed the game. . .we're not there yet, but here's hoping we will be. The excitement and genuine buzz even at a local Hollywood pub (Cat & Fiddle) before the game and after that cracker of a first goal was palpable. . .COYS! Ashley

Posted by peter on 09/15/2009

Finally, an intelligent and incisive sports article written by the media.
Thank you!

Posted by Glenn Hutton on 09/15/2009

Good, well balanced article!

Posted by Sean on 09/15/2009

In regard to Paul Schloles: I said after the match that 10 man United won fair and square, something I don't say often. But here we see Fergie in action - he has made a career out of this. In every Spurs/united game I have seen in recent years he has managed to get away with 4 or 5 yellow card offences (and only 2 make a red), without even getting 1 yellow. So, excluding anything else in the game on Saturday, if his second yellow was a bit harsh (IF), then surely it only redresses the balance a touch. But Fergie is goingon-and-on just about that in isolation (Fergie - you won the game FFS), will the sole purpose (IMHO) of putting anxiety into refs so they will not book Scholes in the future - end of!
Krankjar, Dos Santos or even Bentley/Lennon combo. would have been better than Keane on Saturday - but that's hindsight. Why was O'Hara loaned? I find that more of a concern!
What disappointed me was the mentality - but it is just one result against the Champions, things will improve.

Posted by Addy Olubajo on 09/15/2009

Totally agree with your write up Colin. The other thing that went wrong was scoring that early goal and not able to score the killer second when we had the chances.

Keane, can play in that role against the lesser teams but when it comes to the top teams it will never work and Harry, has also admitted he will not be using that formation again. It will be interesting to see the line up against Chelsea. I personally will opt for either Santos or Krancar. As long as our arch rivals continue to falter, it's all good.

Posted by YIDOED on 09/15/2009

I totally agree about keane, he was terrible, I think the biggest mistake was (other than resigning him) was to give him the captains armband, it gives him a place in the team when he does not deserve it. I for one hope we do a swop deal with Scott Brown in the new year, he would be brilliant alongside Winston. I would also like Pav given a chance, as he has the ability to play the passing game which we love. COYS

Posted by nick the yid on 09/15/2009

please please harry, drop keane please, he left us exposed on the left on saturday, please play a midfielder where a midfielder should play and get the bottle to drop keane, he has done nothing since coming back and we have a bench full of players who are willing to fight for a spot

Posted by nick the yid on 09/15/2009

please please harry, drop keane please, he left us exposed on the left on saturday, please play a midfielder where a midfielder should play and get the bottle to drop keane, he has done nothing since coming back and we have a bench full of players who are willing to fight for a spot

Posted by jones on 09/15/2009

I could not beilive that keane was given the arm band when he just pissed off 6 months ago. it did not work out so if he does return it should be as a squad player. Kranjcar or Dos Santos should bde playing on the left in fact GIO shoud always be in the squad to come on on the left or right when lennon is tired the boy is very good but Harry won't give him a chance just like Pav what a shame

Posted by Armen Megerdoomian on 09/15/2009

Modric should be captain and please, please offer him a lifetime contract soon. He was missed. I think Bently should get another chance as everyone knows he can play. As do Pav and Dos Santos. Surely after that Mexico game there was room for one of him. Not sure Huddlestone should be playing full games either.
Our passing was poor against United and we should no longer accept losses against the old top 4 with the team we have.

Posted by Patrick on 09/15/2009

My views of Keano in general are not as harsh as some here, but I was flabbergasted that 'Arry started him on the left wing. Didn't we see from his 6 month joke at Anfield that he does not prefer to play out wide on the left, nor is he effective from there at all. Slotted behind the two forwards would've been much better. But then again, I think putting GIO on the wing would have been a better choice all together. His recent form for Mexico has been electrifying. I was a bit upset that after the opening brace, a cracker at that, we sat back on our heels too much in our own third. Too much time and way too much space was given to United. Loose balls in the back were met with hesitation and timid approach instead of aggressive hard tackles and confident clearances. LEt's get a result at the bridge. COYS!!!

Posted by Anthony on 09/15/2009

Well written article. We missed Modric badly, and i still don't understand why Dos Santos is not even on the bench, we could use his creativity on the left side

Posted by Cavan on 09/16/2009

I think this game was a result of poor timing. With Modric out and Palacios suffering from jet lag this was hardly the undefeated spurs team from prior matches. I think Harry was to blame for starting Keane wide instead of an actual winger, he just has a different mentality which is why he seemed restrained rather than comfortable. Lets hope they are more cohesive and prepared against Chelsea.

Posted by Al Willig on 09/17/2009

All this Keane bashing?! I just don't get it. Give the man some time to regain his form after a season in which he didn't get much action. On top of that, he's playing out of position. He's still quality and he will come around.

Posted by Mark on 09/18/2009

A well written article!! I think since Keane has returned from Anfield, he has not been the same. He obviously has influence in the dressing room and can motivate, but this is not enough. Dos Santos needs to be in the team, and although I didn't see the Mexico game, the write up on Gio was very good. Harry has an aversion to playing him, which I hope will be fixed this weekend. I think he will play Krankjar (solely cos he signed him).
Come on Harry, give the other lads a go, Keane's not in form!
A result at the Bridge is coming!
COYS

  Post your comment
Name:
Email Address:
Comments:
characters left