ESPN Soccernet - Correspondents - Tottenham Hotspur
soccernet blog
Tottenham Hotspur
Posted by Colin McCullough on 09/28/2009

Robbie Keane has come in for some criticism in recent weeks - not least here - but he answered his critics in the best possible way on Saturday, with four goals at White Hart Lane. In fairness to the player, his most ineffective performances have been when he has been deployed on the left hand side of midfield, which is clearly not his natural position. Against Burnley, Niko Kranjcar started for once, played well and freed Keane up to do what he does best - score goals.

Although Keane’s inclusion looks, in hindsight, like a masterstroke on the part of the manager, it was hardly a surprise given that the Irishman has started every Premier League game this season. On this occasion, however, his position was under greater threat, following Peter Crouch’s impressive midweek hat-trick against Preston. After that Carling Cup win, Harry Redknapp showed that little progress had been made in solving the eternal conundrum of how to keep his strikers happy:

"All three scored at Preston and it’s a nice problem, and it’s better to have that problem than no strikers. I could play all three again. Crouchy would be disappointed if I left him out, but so would Robbie or Jermain."

Crouch himself had noted that "I would be disappointed to be on the bench against Burnley, because I want to play every game", but that turned out to be his fate - although he did get on for half an hour following a minor injury to Defoe. Whether or not Keane is, in turn, rewarded for a bagful of goals with a spot on the sub’s bench is an interesting prospect.

Spurs have now scored 17 times in seven league games, their best ever record in the Premiership. On the other hand, the clean sheet against Burnley was the first of the season, with ten goals conceded in the six previous Premier League fixtures. Burnley - like many teams who come up from the Championship - are focused on picking up the points they will need for survival at Turf Moor, and not only have been beaten in every away match this season, but have also failed to even find the net. Yet they had what looked like a good goal disallowed at the Lane and came close on a couple of other occasions. Their manager, Owen Coyle, was certainly correct in his assessment that the 5-0 score line was not an accurate reflection of the balance of play.

Harry Redknapp has, quite rightly, characterized 15 points from seven games as a "smashing start" and with Bolton, Portsmouth and Stoke to come, there is every expectation that that start will continue. By the time a more challenging encounter against that other team from North London rolls around, there is also the possibility that Luka Modric might be back in contention for a place in the starting line-up. The recent games against Man. Utd. and Chelsea betrayed the lack of his influence and footballing intelligence. Pending Modric’s return, his fellow Croatian Kranjcar will hopefully now stay in the side and thus at least maintain its balance - regardless of which two are playing in front of him.

Comments

Posted by DSDSPUR on 09/28/2009

Geting a bit bored of the 'striker selection headache' conundrum !! Look we all know there will never be a 100% fool-proof answer, as there is no 'apples for apples' comparison here.. As long as we keep scoring - who cares? But, I do totally agree we should play with 2 strikers and have a WINGer on the WING.. Also, Gomes to be no.1. Christmas is the time to sign a quality central midfielder with a defensive aspect to his game & Upson. Once contract expires, King needs to go on a pay as you play, 20k a game with a 10k win bonus, possibly same for woodgate if things don't improve.

Loving the football and the 15 points!
PS next 3 games will give us the absolute measure of how far we have come - few games into season, couple of injuries, couple of tricky bottom half fixtures. Can we hold it together? YES WE CAN CAN CAUSE WE ARE 'SUPER TOTTENHAM'...COYS

Posted by Mark on 09/28/2009

I agree, I too have wondered about Keane's inclusion in the team, and influence would be my only reason for being this way. I still believe Crouch with Defoe should be leading the attack. I hope that Robbie keeps this good form (of one game) going.
Good that Kranjcar got a start, would have loved to see Dos Santos there though (shame he's injured)...and hope the rumor of him going to Spain is just that...a rumor!!

If we get 6 points from the next 9, I'll be a happy man!!

COYS!!!

Posted by Golara on 09/28/2009

This is what Spurs have needed for a long time - serious competition for places in the side. For too long, the side has picked itself, which has allowed mediocre players to prosper with little motivation to perform. Now the players on the pitch know that if they don't produce, someone else is ready to come in and take their place. As well, the players are going to have to accept not being selected with grace, as the team's success has to come before individual accolades.

It is still a work in progress for Harry as he looks to add some more teeth in midfield to help Palacios and some more depth in central defence, where he has been most unlucky with the inordinate number of injuries. But the club are finally heading in the right direction, getting rid of Damien Comolli and the malfunctioning director of football-manager structure has allowed Harry and chairman Levy to get on with the business of running the club without the unecessary interference that plagued past managers.

Posted by Sebastien on 09/28/2009

Great article mate, 'Arry has quite the dilemma on his hands. Will be interesting to see how patient Crouch will be if he continues to see only the closing minutes of games.

Posted by Sev on 09/28/2009

COYS!
hot start to the season

lets pray that woody gets better - still no clean sheets this season! and dear lord pray for gomes to get back too. cudicini doesn't have the quality for spurs

Posted by Mikey C. on 09/29/2009

Great start to the season although it would have been nice to snatch a point from either Schmelski or Man U........I just hope and pray Luka is back by the time we play the scum.....he's our best player by a mile and he pulls all the strings. I think Jenas has played really well along with Bassong. Corluka is a RB, not a CB and we need Ledley in the middle to be at our best.

I really think we can take at least 6 points from our next 3 games, hopefully 7 or maybe even 9 if we play up to our ability. Keep em comin Arry!!

Posted by Yank1023 on 09/29/2009

Spurs fan from across the pond here. Admittedly, I am very partial to Robbie, but will someone please explain to me the infatuation with Peter Crouch. The last two games I was able to see in the States were Chelsea and Burnley, and even I could see that Keane looks much more at home as a striker than in the midfield. That being said, Crouch wasn't a shinig star against Chelsea. He's probably great to have around for cup competitions and the spot start here and there, but you are really willing to sacrifice the slick passing and runs made by Robbie in the last game for someone who has shown he can out-physical Championship sides. Sure, Crouch was an animal at Anfield years back, but wouldn't it be more fair to say that Keane's problem with form was being in the midfield and not on the field in general? I'm seriously curious as I get very little insight into this in the states. Thanks and go Spurs!

Posted by Keith on 09/29/2009

It should be Keane and Crouch as the first choice attack team. Keane is actually more accurate and clinical than defoe in scoring. Crouch has the height advantage and pose great problems to any defenders.

Posted by Al Willig on 09/29/2009

I'm not an "I told you so" kinda guy, so I'll just say "Nice match, Robbie"

Posted by Mark Ross on 09/29/2009

With all that is said ... We have a quality strikeforce. Harry is the manager and he knows exactly why he plays the combinations that he does. A couple of seasons ago we had Keano on fire up front with Mido and Defoe was left out. Defoe felt the pinch and showed it, but when he got his chance he took it and it was Keano's turn to sulk and warm the bench. My feeling is that Crouchy must start with Defoe. COYS!!!

  Post your comment
Name:
Email Address:
Comments:
characters left