ESPN Soccernet - Correspondents - Tottenham Hotspur
soccernet blog
Tottenham Hotspur
Posted by Colin McCullough on 05/19/2009

Every team has opponents against whom they always seem to get a result, whatever the circumstances. As far as Spurs are concerned, Man. City have filled that role in recent years, with ten victories for the north London club in the last eleven meetings. City have also been horrible away from Eastlands this season, having won just twice and picking up a meager eleven points in total.

Disappointing to report, then, that this was yet another close-run thing, with Spurs coming out on top thanks to a dubious penalty and a glaring late miss by Benjani. Before the game, it looked like Spurs were lining up in an attacking 4-3-3 formation, with Defoe, Pavlyuchenko and Keane up front. In practice, Keane was deployed on the left hand side of midfield, the position where he ended the game against Everton a week ago. A well-taken penalty aside, he put in yet another ineffective performance, admittedly in an unfamiliar role.

Why Harry Redknapp chose to utilize him in this manner is a mystery, and would suggest in the same way that he seems to view Bentley as unpickable, he regards Keane as undroppable. Whether this is to bolster Keane’s fragile confidence following his nightmare at Liverpool, or because the Irishman has been handed the captaincy, is open to question. If the latter is the case, then it is the bad end result of what was an initial poor decision. Keane’s commitment and workrate cannot be faulted, but at bottom he is an argumentative player, subject to dips in form that lead to his demeanor on the field being one of frustration rather than inspiration. Although less vocal with his teammates, Jonathan Woodgate seems like a much more obvious choice for captain but undoubtedly Spurs are now stuck with Keane in this role for the foreseeable future.

The poor second half showing following a dominating first half display is becoming something of a Spurs trademark, and suggests a couple of things. For all his achievements this season - and lifting the team from the relegation zone to the fringes of European qualification is a considerable achievement - tactics are not Harry’s strong suit. In addition to his own odd substitutions, he often seems unsure how to respond to changes made by his opposite number, as was the case when Mark Hughes introduced both Bojinov and Benjani on the hour. A more prosaic question might also be raised about the team’s fitness, given their propensity to fade. Perhaps the manager’s new temperance crusade will pay dividends in that regard.

Lying two points ahead of Spurs and with a home match remaining against Everton - who play in the FA Cup final less than a week later - Fulham would appear to be favorites for seventh place and the prize of qualification for the Europa League. Spurs might have ridden their luck in recent weeks but an eighth place finish represents a very successful conclusion to a season that started so badly. And whether it makes a difference to the final standings or not, Spurs - and Robbie Keane in particular - will be hoping to end on a high at Anfield.

Comments

Posted by kl on 05/21/2009

I have to agree. Redknapp is a good manager for lifting teams out of trouble, and perhaps for mid-table sides to push for Euro slots, he is certainly no world-class manager. The Man C game is not the 1st time we've seen him fail to employ proper tactics against an opponent who made a change in theirs.

Posted by JasonGreen on 05/21/2009

I say, if keane was good someday, he can be good today. recent bad performance now doesnt mean he can't come back from it. true?

Posted by dmz on 05/21/2009

i think keane is not clinical enough. wastes quite a few chances. no doubt he does get his 20 goals a season in all competitions if he's a 1st choice starter in every game, but Defoe would benefit more with a more physical Pavlyuchenko.
the problem with Spurs was that the football director, and not the manager was in charge of the transfer. this shouldnt be the case!
let the chef buy his pan!
that's why Spurs ended up selling Defoe and Keane, and then re-buying them shortly after! absurd!
i think that the club was in panic of relegation earlier in the season and so chose to buy back the strikers who are familiar with the club so that there's no risk of adaptation time. will they suffer in the long run cos of this flawed transfer policy?
only time will tell...

Posted by Warren Dayal on 05/21/2009

Spurs have done well to be where they are considering their start. Keane will bounce back.

Posted by Joe Dilon on 05/21/2009

Keane clearly is not in top form. With Spurs safe there was no need to have him sit. It is more important that he rebuilds his confidence and is ready to play next year. As for 7th place and Europe, we're much better off staying out of Europa and concentrating on the PL. Harry and Martin O'Neil said as much with the sides they put out in UEFA. Why care about playing in Europe if you're in such a hurry to get out?

Posted by Craig on 05/22/2009

You make a good point Joe that neither the players or the managers seem to happy about playing and Europe and creating a large fixture of games when they don't have the players to field a side. But, as a fan it is great to see your team play in Europe and compete on that big of stage. I think Europe right now is a little too much for Tottenham but, maybe in a few years!
COYS!!!

Posted by najib on 05/22/2009

Agreed. Harry is brilliant at galvanising players and helping teams avoid the drop. But he's quite daft at tactics and his substitutions at most times, ineffective. Harry's done well to rescue Spurs season, but to get into the Big Four, Spurs need another class of manager...Mourinho, Hiddink, Cruyf, Rijkaard.Sorry, cant recall any English ones.

Posted by Enorme Nuez on 05/22/2009

I agree with the points stated by all but as this is the last match of the season this is a moot point. For the Liverpool match we should field our strongest side and that means Keane should partner Pavlyuchenko upfront. Hopefully Lennon can play so we at least have a threat going forward as I see them going for blood after we stole the points in Harry's second match in charge.

Posted by harrybose on 05/22/2009

Harry is no world class Manager and has reached his peak. He is good at turning around Clubs facing relegation and a little more as in the case of Spurs and nothing more.

To break into the top four, you need better players and a better Manager, who should be English speaking and proven. Also the Manager shpuild be given a free hand to buy players of his choice.

Posted by Jimbo on 05/22/2009

I agree that he has been ineffective recently especially when it comes to scoring goals. Currently he's getting away with it by putting in a high energy and high workrate performance every game.

I just feel sorry for him because he enjoyed a near telepathic understanding with berbatov - with the knock downs and various flicks and one-twos between them a delight to watch.

Hopefully Harry has a plan on how to solve the Spurs striker puzzle. I think all four of them are quality (yes, even Bent) it's just up to the management and coaches to work out a system that will work for them.

Posted by JFoster on 05/23/2009

I have to disagree that Harry is incapable of leading Spurs to a top four finish. With the proper players and a deep enough bench...Harry has the leadership and the support of his players to do so. I look forward to seeing what Harry can do with Spurs and a full season.

Posted by Roy on 05/23/2009

Spurs did a wonderful job selling Keane to Liverpool for an outstanding price. The only mistake they've done, is bringing him back. Robbie Keane is not a natural finisher for a so-called 'striker' of a high profile. Look at his goals, most are tap-ins and penalties, although he does have some lucky breaks with wonderful goals. Otherwise, can he lay the ball off to others like how Crouchie and Drogba can? Or can he dribble past players? Let's not go too far, can he even bring the ball up without looking back and do a back-pass?

The answer is no. Liverpool was stupid to buy him, when the money could've gone to investing Barry or maybe even David Silva. This coming from a Liverpool/Spurs fan.

Posted by Daniel on 05/23/2009

i think that harry needs some time. the reason that there arent many english managers up at the top is because they arent given time. when they do well and move to a bigger club, their more likely to get fired in the first yr then last 2-3yrs. what i would say is that spurs should give him time and control of transfers. let him prove himself. from this we can judge and rate him.

Posted by grittyspur on 05/24/2009

Martin Jol used to play Keano on the left hand side all the time. I will never forget the day that we beat Chelsea at the Lane for the first time in ages. Keano dominated the left side on that day, and he was easily MOM.
As far as last Saturday goes-with Lennon out, 'Arry was playing Keano on the left, because he wanted to see what Modric was capapble of on the right wing, and give Defoe a run out with The Pav. So, the natural spot for our Captain was on the left for the afternoon. The result went our way, and it was a successful experiment. End of..as far as I'm concerned.
Finally- Spurs did not shop Keane to Liverpool. Keano decided to go 'oop norf' to join his mate Stevie Gerard, and he basically told the staff at Tottenham to 'deal with it'. Do you not remember the Levy's letter on the official website remonstrating his anger at Livepool 'tapping up' Keano. This was followed by a donation of monies by Liverpool to a charity picked out by Mr Levy. Memories are short around here!

Posted by Relegation on 05/24/2009

I have a vague memory of Spurs headed for the relegation zone before they got Keane back. Those who don't like him don't get the game. He works hard and makes things happen. And those who don't think he's a natural striker need a look on youtube. Keane's got skills.

Posted by Jeff on 05/25/2009

How do you know if Harry is any good at managing teams in to the top 4? Was it from his days at West Ham, Southampton or Portsmouth? One can only get better at something once they learn and have time to adapt in their environment. Stop being part of the remote control culture!!

Posted by Dato'Chin on 05/25/2009

Kean is still good n can improve with time, but give him a sense of security if u want the result.If u want 2 b champion buy and not sell good players.

Posted by Saint on 05/25/2009

Harry got Southampton relegated, and couldn't get us up the next season.

Posted by Herman on 05/26/2009

To Harry:

First XI (4-4-2 tactic)

GK - Gomes (Cudicini & Alnwick backup)
CB - Woodgate & King (Dawson & Corluka backup)
RB - Corluka (Hutton backup)
LB - NEW (Bale backup)
DM - Palacios (Zokora backup)
AM - Modric (Huddlestone backup)
RM - Lennon (Bentley backup)
LM - NEW (O'Hara backup)
ST - Keane, Defoe & Pavlyuchenko alternate

Buy:

Matthew Taylor (Bolton) as LB
Morten Gamst Pedersen (Blackburn) LM
Stewart Downing (Middlesbrough) LM

These left-sided players shall be our primary targets to balance our team. Sell the others whose name have not been mentioned in the above first XI to finance the buys. If we still have some money left, buy a solid CB, then a creative CM and finally a strong ST to strengthen the spine of our team.

Posted by Jo on 05/26/2009

Well Keane is an alright player, very similar to Dirk Kyut but less consistent and is slightly more skillful. He need games and Harry should always start him, on the left or as a central striker. What they truely need is a more consistent center back to partner Woodgate and a left back as bale isn't exactly solid. Also more height and physical presence in midfield is would definitely benefit them. Lennon, Modric, Bentley are good players on their day but can sometimes be ineffective and can be easily marked by top class full backs such as Evra, Cole, Bosingwa just to name a few. Don't need for a striker unless they sell a couple. I don't actually think Bent and Pavluchenko are really up to it. They're good but definitely not champions league material. You need top top class strikers like Torres, Drogba, Zlatan, Etoo and Benzema to challenge the for a top four. The standard set apart atm is too far and I don't see anyone challenging them in the near future.

Posted by dione on 05/27/2009

I was lucky enough to be at the Man City - Tottenham game and was struck by how absolutely useless Keane was - the Spurs fans around me, couldn't even watch him take the penalty, they assumed he would miss that too. Harry is great but he will try fans patience with picking Keane regardless of his form. Sit him down, some players respond great to that. cheers

  Post your comment
Name:
Email Address:
Comments:
characters left