ESPN Soccernet - Correspondents - Swansea City
soccernet blog
Swansea City
Posted by Max Hicks on 04/21/2012

With the season coming to a close, the Swans can afford to watch the relegation fight they were supposed to be involved in from the safe seats in the middle of the table.

As such, the Swans will be among the teams that might have an interest in cherry picking players from the relegated sides to bolster their own squad for next season.

The cannibalisation of the three weakest teams is a harsh reality of football and tough to take for the fans of those sides, but it gives everyone else a chance to speculate on which players they'd throw a lifeline to given the chance, and that's loads of fun.

Here's my list of one player per side (plus an alternative option) from the bottom six who I think could make an impact for the Swans.


WOLVES

Considering Wolves are the last place team, I had quite a hard time choosing just one player, because this side has a handful that could improve a mid-table Premier League side. Ultimately, I settled on Kevin Doyle. The forward has the right kind of work ethic to play in relief of Danny Graham for the Swans, and his solid all-around game means he'd fit in as a lone striker.

If not Doyle, then... I would pick Matt Jarvis, who would be an excellent addition on the wing. Doyle gets the nod for me only because the Swans are slightly better stocked on the wing than up front. There is also a case for Stephen Fletcher, who I rate as a fantastic classic centre forward (i.e. good in the air). However, I think the Swans pass-pass-pass-and-move game would be a poor fit for Fletcher, who might fare better in a more traditional two striker system (and he'd score 30 goals a season for Stoke).


BLACKBURN

After watching the Swans three nil victory over Blackburn last week, there is only one choice, and that is David Dunn, the only Blackburn player with any desire that day (except perhaps for Paul Robinson). He passes the character test hands down by virtue of that performance and his creative Jan Molby-esque midfield presence would look good on show at the Liberty.

If not Dunne, then.. Morten Gamst Pedersen. As one of the few players ever to 'score' directly from a throw in, he'd give the Swans long-throw specialism which is an extremely useful tool. He's also pretty decent in open play, too; probably one of the most underrated players in the Premier League.


BOLTON

Mark Davies. Davies would give the Swans another Joe Allen; a dynamic two-way midfielder, and who doesn't want as many of those as possible? Davies is especially impressive going forward and could either start alongside Allen or play in rotation with him in the Swans current system.

If not Davies, then.. Fabrice Muamba, assuming he manages to return to the game. Muamba is one of those all-action Viera types. The Swans don't really have one of those, relying instead on the deep-lying ball thievery of Leon Britton to run the midfield. Muamaba would give the Swans a different look to mix things up a bit against more physical opponents.


WIGAN

For me, the most talented player in Martinez' squad is Victor Moses. He's still a little raw, and still needs some development to reach his peak, but who better to coax that out of him than Brendan Rodgers? His trickery and guile on the wing or up front would be an asset to any side and he's just really exciting to watch.

If not Moses, then... Ali Al Habsi. The eccentric goalkeeper is almost unbeatable on his day, and he'd benefit from playing with the defensively astute Swans. Plus he'd give the side some height in net for those tricky away fixtures at Stoke.


QPR

Since he's been such a thorn in the Swans side, I'd take Jamie Mackie, if just to stop him scoring against us. Seriously though, Mackie is a decent forward with some skill and a tidy finish, and he's quite versatile. There are bigger names on the QPR squad, but they almost all come with baggage. Barton and Cisse, for example, are impact players, but the Swans are built on a team ethic and don't need distractions which might upset that.

If not Mackie, then... Adel Taarabt, with the qualifier that he learns to buckle down and do his defensive duty. His talent is unquestionable, but his application often leaves something to be desired. If Brendan Rodgers could develop his work ethic, he'd be more consistent, more complete and much more dangerous.


ASTON VILLA

The Swans have been thin at the back all season, and if Stephen Caulker can't return to the team, that need will become the priority. Ciaran Clark fits the bill for me. He can play at centre back and in midfield and has even done a few shifts at full back. He's young and only getting better, and given the chance could become a key piece of the Swans first team.

If not Clark, then... Stephen Ireland. Ireland is a decent midfielder with plenty of big league experience who would strengthen the Swans in the middle of the park.


Of course, I realise that real-world practicalities like transfer fees and wage expectations would probably rule out most of these transfers, but it's still fun to speculate. Let me know who you would take and why?


Follow ESPNsoccernetFC on Twitter

Comments

Posted by feygooner on 04/21/2012

Have you not seen Junior Hoillet play?

Ah, yes, Junior Hoillet. The reason I overlooked Hoillet was mostly because he was quiet in the game against Swansea the other week, whereas it was impossible to ignore Dunn. Hoillet would obviously be a good pick-up, but as with Matt Jarvis, I think the Swans have more depth out wide than elsewhere, which puts greater value on other positions. M

Posted by Josh on 04/21/2012

Considering you're speculating on picking from the bones of my club (and at that the only one who's at this point 100% doomed) it's a bit of an interesting read. I'd take Fletcher over Doyle, personally, but you're spot on about Jarvis-- he'll be a credit to whoever picks him up and he'll fit in anywhere.

That being said, I can see why you had a hard time picking a player from Wolves. It's a club where the whole is less than the sum of its parts, wrecked by bad board decisions. "Invest in the team? Nah, we can stay up with the players we have, let's build new stands and a new training ground!" Backfire. Back to square one.

Well, I do hope you get some of our best, because I've got a very large soft spot for the Swans and would love to watch Jarvo working the wings or Fletch burying the goals at the Liberty. Really wish you guys can avoid second season syndrome, Brendan Rogers is a genius and you're a credit to the league. Cheers!

Kind words indeed. The point you raised about new stands and training grounds is interesting; there seems to be a mixed feeling about where the Swans should invest. Most fans are keen to see a youth academy or state-of-the-art training facility first, whilst the board is talking about a 10,000 seat stadium expansion and Brendan Rogers wants the club to continue to invest in players. Obviously, there isn't the money to do everything all at once, and I think the choices the Swans make will be the significant factor in next seasons performance.

I feel bad for Wolves right now; I think the Mick McCarthy situation ended up being a farce, and I wonder if you think (as I do) that as bad as that five one drubbing to West Brom was, McCarthy would have kept the team competitive and not ended up as good as gone with three games left to play (no disrespect to Terry Connor, he's a Swans old boy after all)? M

Posted by Patrick on 04/22/2012

As one of Sir Alex's faithful, United will always be my club. However, it has been a pleasure to watch your boys play. I was thinking that Mohammed Diame from Wigan would fit really well at the Liberty. Your thoughts Max?

That's a good call. I think Diame would bring similar qualities to Muamaba. I like Diame's eye for a long pass, too. Although the Swans have picked themselves up recently, they have occasionally been guilty of not being particularly expansive with their passing (especially during the recent losing streak). Players like Diame help keep it interesting, plus he's a strong tackler.

On another note, I'm looking forward to the United v Swans match, especially with the title race so close. Hopefully it'll be another close one like the Liberty fixture. M

Posted by Kyle on 04/22/2012

Like you said if money was no worry I'd love to see David Hoilett, Gabriel Agbonlahor, Marc Albrighton or a number of the guys you selected. However, maybe i'm totally wrong, a player we could afford and I think if he's healthy could really help Swansea would be Grant Hanley. CB is the position that most worries me because I don't feel like we're gonna get Caulker back. Which is why if we could sign a guy you suggested I'd like Ciaran Clark.

Obv priority #1 is keeping Siggy, which I think we can but becomes more difficult every game, would you say cb is next in line? (and personally worries me most)

Yes, absolutely. I think the Swans defence overall is far too thin for comfort. Even with Caulker, guys like Monk and Tate are (with all due respect and a good deal of affection) not quite up to stepping in as long-term starters at this level should injury hit hard somewhere, and there are depth issues at full back as well as centre back.

Aside from injury, depth fosters competition for places. During the losing streak, Ash Williams was struggling, but without a solid alternative option he had to play, when a game or two out and the threat of losing a starting place might have helped him re-focus.

Hanley's not a bad suggestion. He's got some height, which is always handy at the back. I remember being less than impressed when the Swans deal for Ryan Bennett fell through, but he's been looking a little bit raw for Norwich, so that might not have been as big a loss as it first seemed. The Swans will need some help at centre back though, without a doubt.

As for Siggy, I still feel optimistic about him joining full time. Hoffenheim have said they want him back for next season, but they're not going to say any different if they want to get a decent fee for the player. It will probably take £6-£7 million at the least, which would represent some serious ambition since it's twice the Swans record transfer fee. Perhaps a structured deal, say 4 or 5 million plus a percentage of any future transfer might swing the deal? After all, Siggy is young, and bigger teams might prefer to wait it out, watch him progress at Swansea and see if he can deliver consistently at this level before making a move, at which point the transfer fee would be higher again, which is where Hoffenheim cash in if such a clause was included in any transfer. And for the bigger team, the £7-£12 million he might be worth as a proven talent in two or three seasons time is still a comfortable amount. This is all gross speculation though, obviously. Like practically all Swans fans, I'd just really like to see him join full time and stay as long as possible. M

Posted by Adrian on 04/22/2012

I know it's at the other end of the table, but I'd like to see an Arsenal young guy, like Myachi or Afobe get some Premier league time with a great team like Swansea.

That'd be great; with limited transfer funds I expect the Swans to bring in more loan players next year, since Caulker and Sigurdsson have done so well this term. We've also got McEachran from Chelsea who hasn't had much of a go since coming over, but might have a role to play if he comes back for a full season next year. I'm happy to see the Swans take whoever the big teams want to send our way! M

Posted by Patrick on 04/23/2012

Fergie said that we would be sending Fabio out on loan. I'd prefer to see him with a Prem side. I think he would fit perfectly in your style, but do you see him getting picked consistently over Taylor?

I heard some Swans fans discussing this possibility the other day. Taylor has been fantastic this season. I thought he might be a bit raw to start, but he seems to have gotten up to speed in the Premier League really quickly. He was Swansea's best player against Bolton, and I seriously doubt Rogers would want to slow his development by having him sit more often than not.

Having said that, and you'll be able to correct me if I'm wrong, but can't Fabio also play right back reasonably well? Because having someone come in who could cover either side would make loads of sense. Between them, Taylor, Rangel and Fabio would get enough games to keep everyone happy. I'd be very pleased to see him come over if that situation could be made to work. M

Posted by Simon on 04/25/2012

As a Utd fan who enjoys ur style of play, think you need some exp up top, to nouse out a goal when its tight - maybe a one-season deal for mickey Owen?! He wont get much (if any) time with us and he can still finish (when fit admittedly)

Now that's interesting. I'm a fan of the "ageing star player joins smaller team" scenario, though in the case of Owen we'd need United to pick up almost all his wage... M

Posted by Nabban on 04/25/2012

Well, I am a Man U man, but the Swans are a team close to my heart as well as I have some family ties there. Considering the possession Swansea tend to keep, I'd like to see a good striker there really, and who better to fill that role than the Yak? granted he may be tempted to go to a bigger club, I can't help but feel his finishing would give make swansea a much more potent threat.

Well, since he stuck four past the Swans in one game it's fair to say Brendan Rogers knows what he can do. I think Graham has done really well at Swansea, and though he hasn't always been clinical, his work ethic is fantastic and he always gets into the right areas. Having said that, adding another striker for variety and competition can't be a bad thing, and Yakubu's certainly been a solid scorer for Blackburn. M

Posted by kevinkgillette on 04/25/2012

Great comments! You mentioned the one player I'd love to see in a Swans uniform, and that's Victor Moses. He's hungry for a better side to perform with, and he's got some of the best foot skills in the BPL. Great to see Swansea staying firmly in the top flight; here's to Cardiff joining them from the Championship, putting two Welsh sides in with their English counterparts.

Yes, I've said before how I think the South Wales derby would be a great Premier League spectacle, since it's hard to think of many more competitively contested rivalries in British football. As for Moses, I guess we can hope, eh? M

  Post your comment
Name:
Email Address:
Comments:
characters left