ESPN Soccernet - Soccernet Comments
soccernet blog
Soccernet Home Soccernet Home
Soccernet  Home Blogs Home
RSS feed
Soccernet Comments
Posted by Jon Carter on 03/15/2010

Phil Brown has been sacked. © Getty Images

It could only happen to Phil Brown. Just a day or so after a battling performance against Arsenal almost netted a valuable point for Hull, he is relieved of his duties just when nobody expects it.

Battling of a different kind (between his players Jimmy Bullard and Nicky Barmby), took all the headlines as they scrapped in front of the Women’s Institute last week, but now ‘Phil Orange’, as he has become known in some press circles, will take the attention away from his side’s off-pitch misdemeanours.

It is a decision that the Hull board have put down to their hopes for Premier League survival. But perhaps there is something deeper here about his handling of his players? Certainly, if Hull were going to make a decision based on their results, then choosing the end of October would have given them a fighting chance.

Rumours persisted that Brown had actually been sacked back then, but they came to nothing as his friend and former colleague Adam Pearson was installed in the Tigers’ boardroom. Now Pearson has opted to pull the trigger, but the timing is odd.

Yes, Hull have won just five of their 29 Premier League games this season and have looked like relegation candidates all season, but that cannot be seen as much of a surprise given their dismal run at the end of last campaign.

If anything, the club had actually been on the up of late, with their vitally important home form seeing an improvement that yielded just a single defeat in their last ten games at the KC Stadium before the visit of Arsenal.

Now, a new man must come in and make an immediate impact. Having to win over the dressing-room, adapt to new surroundings and ensure that the results on the pitch are enough to keep the club in the Premier League and it may be a task too far.

Hull have missed the boat. If they wanted to affect a change at the club, then before Christmas would have been the time. In acting so late, it may be that the Tigers have just released their only chance of staying up.

Comments

Posted by Anonymous on 03/15/2010

they still stand a chance of staying up if they are able to get result in the remaining matches.

Posted by clinsman on 03/15/2010

Nice guy... Did his best for the club.

Posted by Ashok on 03/15/2010

Not nice.

Posted by Mitch on 03/15/2010

What a dumb decision, he made a club over achieve for 3 years, is'nt that what a manager is supposed to do. I hope they enjoy championship football next year.

Posted by IndianapolisArsenalFan on 03/15/2010

This is a horrible decision by Hull City. Brown was the heart and soul of that team, sometimes seeming to will his team into a draw or win. Hull will fall for sure and all of the money they have spent will be for nothing. Bad decision.

Posted by Valencia on 03/15/2010

"they still stand a chance of staying up if they are able to get result in the remaining matches."

I think you forgot to add, "On the other hand, they have the chance of getting relegated if the are not able to get result in the remaining matches..."

Posted by John Smith on 03/15/2010

It always happens that too much exuberance will always come back and bite you. He should have taken a leaf out of other managers that have thought they had one the cup from Arsenal (when they had only won a match) and have gone on to pay the price. Maybe he might approach the next team with some dignity

Posted by overmars on 03/15/2010

A boss who instructed his players to be cynical and dirty. Glad he has been sacked.

Posted by John on 03/15/2010

NOOOOOOOOOOOO!!!!!!I like Phil Brown, He's one of my favorite managers.Yes Hull is not doing well but he's kept them up in the Premier league twice, if they were ever going to sack him they should of waited for the result of Hull's finish for the season.What a sad day.

Posted by F.K on 03/15/2010

he is a good man.... he did his best for hull city.

Posted by Kerry on 03/15/2010

Phil deserves to see Hull through the end of the season.

What a cowardly decision!

Hull? you will never see Premier League Football again!

Posted by Anonymous on 03/15/2010

he dint deserve to be sacked he was really good

Posted by Anon on 03/15/2010

couldnt have happened to a nicer guy - not! good to see him get sacked after all his antics.

Posted by Anonymous on 03/15/2010

Should have given him a chance to fight on

Posted by Kasharu on 03/15/2010

Let him Go. In fact he wasn't suppose to be there in first place, he can't differentiate the Championship and Premier League.
In the other hand, he board has committed the biggest mistake they will live to regret for sacking him now not THEN. Hull is a sinking boat no one can rescue it until it touches the seabed.

Posted by George on 03/15/2010

This is the wrong decision. The fact that Hull isn't bottom of the table is a tribute to Brown's ability. The talent on the Tigers is woeful at best. Phil Brown is a good manager, he will get another chance. Sad day for the Tigers

Posted by jamie on 03/15/2010

i feel sorry for the guy.but i think its for the better of hull.would miss the on the pitch half time talks though

Posted by Danny Duberstein on 03/15/2010

Clearly there is something else going on here given the timing and recent form. Stay tuned I suppose.

Posted by z on 03/15/2010

i think its not the best time to sack him
focused on the last few games
they did play good games but results are not on their side

Posted by zack on 03/15/2010

players are to be blame for the results n not manager

Posted by Willbel on 03/15/2010

Brown had his negatives - attention hog, doughtful honesty regarding the Frabragas spitting case, poor judgement with his on-pitch half-time lecture to his players. On the other hand, he did get Hull into the PL and, while their style of play is not beautiful, your tactics are often determined by the quality of players. From that point of view he seemed to have his players motivated and trying hard.

I agree that this is an odd time to sack him, and am surprised by the news. It may be more difficult to stay up with any of the rumored replacement managers, and so little time to familiarize oneself with the players. I can only conjecture that Hull management is banking on a short-term lift that often comes with a change and garnering just enough points to stay up.

Posted by IRW on 03/15/2010

...it just doesn't make sense to change your manager in mid-march now does it?...and despite his follies, surely brown deserved better...

Posted by King Kong on 03/15/2010

Why sack the manager when you have 10 matches to go. Are you guys thinking that statistically it will help you secure more points? Of all managers who should be sacked, it's Rafa Benitez from Liverpool. Sacking Brown is really nonsense.

Posted by Rummy Dummy on 03/17/2010

The dead coach bounce won't be enough to save Hull, even if their new coach is the cadaverous Iain Dowie.

  Post your comment
Name:
Email Address:
Comments:
characters left
© ESPN Soccernet 2009
Cricinfo
Soccernet
ESPN