ESPN Soccernet - Soccernet Comments
soccernet blog
Soccernet Home Soccernet Home
Soccernet  Home Blogs Home
RSS feed
Soccernet Comments
Posted by Dale Johnson on 03/17/2010

.


Dowie failed at Newcastle with Alan Shearer © Getty Images

Hull City fans have endured the most bizarre 48 hours of their brief tenure in the Premier League. No doubt about it, this is now a crisis.

• Dowie handed Hull role
• Iain Dowie manager profile

Phil Brown's sacking on Monday could have had at least a shred of sense about it, but only with a big appointment. The press linked Mark Hughes, the fans wanted Kevin Keegan. They got Ian Dowie as their ephemera.

No amount of on-pitch lambasting or fisticuffs in front of members of the Women's Institute can compare to appointing Dowie as your saviour. It's hardly a clarion call of the club's action plan, and the halcyon days of wins at Arsenal and Tottenham are now a distant memory.

There is no mistake: chairman Adam Pearson believes Dowie is the inspirational figure who can lift the Tigers from 19th place and to safety when the season comes to a close on May 9.

This momentary appointment has the fans up in arms, in despair at the direction their club is taking. It's difficult to see how he is better than Brown, who made the KC into something of a fortress of late despite Saturday's late loss to Arsenal.

This is the very same Dowie who emerged as Alan Shearer's acolyte, just under a year to the day, to perform a very similar job. Newcastle won one of their eight games, losing five, and were relegated - which coincidentally resulted in Hull escaping the drop. A similar record at the KC Stadium would leave the Tigers will no hope of booking a third season among the elite.

The counterpoint is that Dowie was once seen as one of the game's most promising managers. Dowie led Crystal Palace into the Premier League, but his career has never recovered from a defection to Charlton Athletic in the summer of 2006 that resulted in a High Court ruling that he had lied when negotiating his way out of his contract.

It's 18 months since Dowie last took charge of a team, one of the many to go through the revolving door at Queen Park Rangers. He lasted 15 matches but had an excellent win ratio of 53% before boardroom matters beat him into submission.

He would surely have jumped red lights to get to Hull and prove that he is not a spent force in the managerial game.

Pearson, who tried to appoint Dowie in December 2006 when Brown was merely Hull's caretaker, clearly hopes that his new man can do the same at Hull, as that would likely keep them up. He also had an instant impact when taking over at Palace, which led to their promotion.

And although the former Northern Ireland international may only be at the KC until the end of the season, he will surely remain if successful in his task.

The fixtures seem to give Dowie every chance. Portsmouth come first followed by Fulham, Stoke City, Burnley, Birmingham, Sunderland and Wigan Athletic before they end the season at home to Liverpool. Their home game with Aston Villa has yet to be rearranged.

At least Dowie will have with him Tim Flowers - last seen as part-time goalkeeping coach at Northampton Town - and Steve Wigley, part of the Gary Megson's backroom staff at Bolton but best known for a short and horrendous stint at the helm of Southampton.

That said, Wigley is the Football Association's National Coach, assuming responsibility for the 17-21 age groups.

You can't help but think this will end in tears, on the terraces, when the season is over.

Comments

Posted by Emilio on 03/17/2010

In my time of watching English football, since the World Cup of 1970, Hull has been on the second or lower tiers. Their elevation to the top level should have been accepted as a temporary yet surprisingly wonderful gift that would someday have to be returned because it wasn't a comfortable fit.
All these aspiring clubs should know that unless they have a history of being a well run club their days of competing with the elite are numbered. Ultimately there will be a handful of clubs, with sufficient resources, including a large fan base and player development policies, that will be "permanent" members of the elites of soccer, with the other clubs largely serving as cannon fodder. There's no way a team like Northampton Town, which holds the record for the swiftest rise to the top level and back down again, could have maintained their lofty status - they just did not have the infrastructure of fan base, player development, and liquidity to allow that to happen.

Posted by Anonymous on 03/17/2010

What a bizarre twist? Perhaps one of the most unsuccessful men in premier league history,a striker with an average of about a goal in every five, and a coaching career that is tarnished by each club he has been involved with getting relegated! The hull boardroom staff must be on something! Phil brown would've kept em up or brought em back in a year or two, relegation will serve em right!

Posted by Pegasus82nd on 03/17/2010

Have you considered what the scenarios are for next season for Hull?
1: If Hull survive in the Premier. I think it unlikely that Hull will "settle" for Dowie as the manager next season. They will go for a higher profile target.
2: If Hull are relegated. Dowie will be retained as manager as Hull won't be able to afford anyone better.
So, Dowie will be rewarded with no job for a success, but will get to keep his job if he fails. Do you think this is an unlikely situation?

Posted by Matt on 03/17/2010

I feel terrible for Hull City fans. Maybe Phil Brown wasnt perfect, but the team seemed to play hard for him. The talent level dictates that this club would always struggle to stay in the Prem. I can't see how appointing Dowie helps, he has been an uninspiring failure at almost everywhere he has been.

Posted by Anthony James on 03/17/2010

Having been on this earth for more than sixty five years,nothing surprises me in football any longer. I support a team in the second division,and we have changed managers more times over the years than most people change their socks,but the fact of the mater is that the eleven players on the pitch will keep Hull City up not the Manager. It has been a roller coaster ride, and they have given it their best shot,but changing their manager now is suicide. A.J

Posted by Simon on 03/17/2010

Hull must be desperate! How on earth could you appoint Ian Dowie. I would have taken Phil Brown any day! I hope for the board sake if Hull retain Premier League status they should go for a high profile manager like Mark Hughes or even Ian Curbishley.
Ian Dowie is not my cup of tea as manager.
Good luck to Hull Ian Dowie has a massie task ahead of him. SY

Posted by Don on 03/17/2010

My gut says Dowie will keep them up. The players will want him gone. But then, my gut said Middlesborough would be back, until GS took over and my gut wrenched.

"That parrot's dead."
"No, he's merely resting."

Posted by Leandro on 03/18/2010

It seem that the big tiger is returning back to the championship with no doubt. Chairman Adam is an ''enermy'' for Brown. Of course Brown will make the fate of the Tigers fade with no doubt. If Brown were giving the opportunity to lead Liverpool, there is no doubt that Liverpool will climb up to the top 4. It seems that Brown actually wins Morinho sometimes with his unique tactics.

Posted by Vincent Vaiano on 03/18/2010

If they (Hull Boardroom) were going to go for someone with a track record of success for not a lot of money, why wouldn't they go for Paul Jewell? He has actually kept teams up TWICE that really shouldn't have been able to stay up. He even won ON THE ROAD against the team that only needed a draw to remain in the EPL. Other than a high profile manager, how much better could Hull have done? I hope I am wrong about Dowie. I hope he gets its done this time. Perhaps his failure at Newcastle along side Mr. Sheerer will act as the impetus for improvement and success for him.

Posted by shane on 03/18/2010

what is wrong with hull city ?? why would u get rid of phil brown , who has done a decent job with hull .. and replace him with ian dowie who has practicaly done nuffin as a manager , ,, i think its crisis time for hull city

  Post your comment
Name:
Email Address:
Comments:
characters left
© ESPN Soccernet 2009
Cricinfo
Soccernet
ESPN