ESPN Soccernet - North of the Border
soccernet blog
Soccernet Home Soccernet Home
Soccernet  Home Blogs Home
RSS feed
North of the Border Blog
Posted by Derek Rae on 11/24/2009

As some of you will know, this commentator has been granted plenty of thinking time this season, much of it at 37,000 feet. En route from Scotland to the United States, after covering ESPN’s Matchday Live from Tannadice, I find myself pondering what’s next for Dundee United’s excellent manager Craig Levein.

Not without good reason, Levein is the favourite to land the vacant Scotland post. United’s remarkable 2-1 win over Celtic on Sunday certainly did plenty to bolster the argument that the 45-year-old - who played 16 times for his country - is the ideal man to succeed George Burley.

One of the Scottish game’s deeper thinkers, Levein has something all the top managers have in abundance: natural authority. Not a man to suffer fools gladly, you had better be on your game when working with the United boss, and that applies to us in the media as much as it does to players wearing tangerine.

His work since 2006 with Dundee United might appear solid, rather than spectacular, but the evidence of significant improvement is undeniable. It’s all the more laudable when you consider that no player on the club’s books makes more than £2,000 a week.

Levein has the knack of getting the very best out of players who are far from superstars. As Sunday proved with the astute use of substitutes Jon Daly, David Goodwillie and Danny Swanson, he has the ability to make positive, match-altering decisions. These are important qualities the next Scotland manager must possess.

So you might expect me to be a strong advocate of Craig Levein for the national side, and I have to say he does appear to be the outstanding candidate. But there’s part of me that hopes he remains on Tayside to build on the blocks already put in place.

During the summer, Levein thought outside the box and tore the club’s old youth system asunder, appointing the innovative Ian Cathro and Brian Grant and placing the emphasis firmly on players’ technique. Cathro has no prior experience with an SPL club but his radical methods struck a chord with the manager.

I made the point on-air before kick-off on Sunday that if one team is to push Rangers and Celtic this term, Dundee United might just be that team. A case can be made for Hibernian too, but United appear to have a little bit more tactical flexibility, again a tribute to Craig Levein.

No one can get inside his mind, and approaches haven’t been made to him or any other potential Scotland manager, but this much is clear: Levein is the hottest coaching property in the Scottish game at the moment. He has unfinished business south of the border too, having found himself in charge of Leicester City at a less than opportune time.

Does Craig Levein covet the Scotland job? Will he stay the course with Dundee United and finish the job he has started? Are both the Scotland and Dundee United positions, in his way of thinking, a stepping stone to English football?

Deep down, I’m guessing he’s rather enjoying being the king of the managerial castle in Scotland at the moment. It’s never a bad thing to be wanted in any walk of life. Even if - when all is said and down - Levein remains at Tannadice, he’ll still be a manager going places.

Comments

Posted by Scott on 11/24/2009

Derek, just wanted to say thank you for your reporting and innovative commentary, I only lived a year in Scotland, gaining a MLitt in History, I fell in love with the country of my ancestors...You sir do your country proud :)

Posted by Des on 11/24/2009

Great guy. Takes no nonsense. Would be a good choice, but a great loss to United.I think it would be a risk if he left United,based on comments that Graeme Souness made last week,that no matter who you put in the Scotland job at the moment it would not make any difference. Maybe Celtic should have sounded him out before hiring Mowbray.

Posted by Fraser Muir on 11/26/2009

Reports claiming that Levein is considered as the leading candidate for the Scotland job is unfortunate.

Hopefully, he will make the sensible decision not to accept an offer. Regardless of where he has taken Dundee Utd, this is light years away from managing a national squad. Even Burley's selection as Manager raised many an eyebrow, so his dismissal is not a surprise to many. Levein even has less experience than Burley and regardless of his "natural authority", the selection of a new Manager has to be one that already has experience at a higher-level of football, whether that be at the club or international level. There are many more Managers out there with an equally "natural authority" that will carry the respect of the current squad. That is what is needed.

Unfortunately, there is no one based in the SPL, even Smith, that can take on the challenge. We have to look beyond our borders

Yet, the sacking of the SFA board would make a decision even more palatable by a new board

Posted by The bestest on 11/29/2009

Hopefully he comes aboard. Scotland need someone to get them out of the mess Burley has left them in.

  Post your comment
Name:
Email Address:
Comments:
characters left
© ESPN Soccernet 2009
Cricinfo
Soccernet
ESPN