ESPN Soccernet - Correspondents - Newcastle United
soccernet blog
Newcastle United
Posted by Marc Duffy on 11/25/2010

It is less than a month since the Halloween slaughter of the folks from the Village of the Damned. Even less since we turned over Arsenal at The Emirates. How circumstances can change quickly in football.

After the sunderland game there was a clamour from many fans of NUFC to get Chris Hughton tied up to a long term contract ASAP. After the Arsenal game more people joined in on that show of support and some areas of the national press piled in behind the likeable English/ Irish/ Ghanaian.

Then came a run of 3 games in 10 days that yielded only 1 point and all of a sudden we have a few callers to the regular local radio football phone in's suggesting that a 'more experienced' manager would be preferable. Yes, these voices are (quite rightly) in the minority but there was an obvious increase after the thrashing we received at Bolton.

A few cracks have been exposed in and around the football club in recent weeks - most notably in terms of player discipline on and off the field.

Off the field we had Andy Carroll's court case and then his car being torched on the drive of Kevin Nolan (if you have been on Mars for a while the fact that Andy is living at Nolan's as part of his bail conditions may have passed you by.) Then there was the disgraceful non-story published by one of the Sunday nationals.

On the field the players discipline has been even worse. First off Joey Barton received a 3 match ban for 'punching' Pedersen when we played Blackburn. Pedersen went down as if Iron Mike Tyson had caught him off guard, but it was stupid from Barton and he has been a big miss. Then Tiote collected his 5th booking picking up a ban - a booking for Tiote is almost as inevitable as us conceding. At Bolton on Saturday Colo was sent off for an elbow aimed at Elmander and will also miss 3 games. After the match Mike Williamson was also charged with an off the ball incident again with Elmander, and he will also miss 3. That is 10 games of suspension amongst some of our key players within a matter of weeks - this is not acceptable.

It is also hugely frustrating that Nigel de Jong walked away without punishment after smashing HBA's leg. And didn't Fellaini hit Williamson when we beat Everton at Goodison? Did he get 3 games? No, of course he didn't. Football's ridiculous rules made sure of that. These inconsistencies are spoiling football.

The result at Bolton is also unacceptable. I am not saying that we should be heading to the Reebok and strolling away with 3 points, but 1 v 5? Bolton did not even play particularly well - nowhere near as well as they did when they beat Spurs recently and that brings me on to another issue of the moment, basic errors.

We are gifting teams goals - see Tiote's ridiculous dribbling in his own box v Blackburn or Williamson's pathetic attempted shoulder challenge before Roberts goal in the same game. At Bolton we gave away 2 penalties, 1 harsh and 1 stupid. Jose continued his 'why take 1 touch when you can take 30?' routine and Colo continues to take mad risks in his own third.

In the past few games Coloccini looks more like the player that he was in the relegation season. He has been weak, slow to react and far too easy to wind up. This is disappointing as for the majority of this season he has been one of our best players. Let us hope it is a temporary blip - he now has 3 games to go away and think about it.

This leads me on to yet another issue that I have with Hughton of late. Why is he so reluctant to take poorly performing players out of the starting line-up? Perch played a few games too many before injury and the return of Danny Simpson saw him dropped. Williamson and Coloccini have looked very poor lately and despite having Campbell and S. Taylor waiting in the wings they have played week in, week out and it has taken this suspension to see the defence shaken up. Other peculiar team selections include drafting in Lovenkrands to play against Blackburn whilst continuing to ignore Ranger. Guthrie on the right has also been an experiment that failed.

Our reliance on the Joey Barton diagonal ball has been badly exposed and Guthrie has demonstrated that he does not have those same attributes. To be fair to Guthrie though he is not a wide player. I am not really sure what he is! Against Fulham he was awful out right and it was bemusing as to why it took so long to get Routledge on to the park to go up against the out of position Damien Duff.

However, and this is my main point, let's get all of the above into perspective.

Chris Hughton is absolutely the right man for the job. At the start of this season most people who contacted me on here about realistic expectations said that they would be more than happy with 15th come May. We are presently in the top half of the Premier League having pulled off some great results - so what has changed people's expectations?

All of the above will help Chris to develop as a coach. He is a novice manager and his achievements as a novice have been incredible. Some people overlook the fact that we were seen by many 'experts' as likely to 'do a Leeds' when we hit the Championship. Quite the opposite.

He achieved this all on a shoestring budget, his most expensive signing being the excellent Cheik Tiote - he came in at about £10m less than Bruce spent on Gyan alone.
The question that I ask the people (on Twitter/ Facebook/ Soccernet or in the pub) is who would you want to replace him? Would you trust Ashley to make the right decision? Joe Kinnear? I think not.

Stick with Chris and give him a contract. And lets beat Chelsea on Sunday (if it stops snowing!)

Follow me on Twitter @MarcSDuffy

Comments

Posted by William Smith on 11/26/2010

It's not really a case of who you would want to replace him but who would want to...

No manager in their right mind would manage Newcastle on a shoestring with huge and unrealistic expectations and the likelyhood of being sacked or having the club sold from under you.

No Thanks

[Define 'huge and unrealistic ecpectations' please. 45-50,000 average crowd each week having won nothing domestically in over 50 years is pretty unrealistic]

Posted by Subbeo on 11/26/2010

Im not a newcastle fan but surprised the some wants him too go. Afterall they got promoted last season so you can hardly think they going to fight for a champions league place. I think if they end up between 10-15th place it would have been a good season for them

[But then I have heard of Arsenal fans asking for Wenger out, Liverpool fans wanting Hodgson out after SIX GAMES and even some Spurs fans who wouldn't be upset if Redknapp went]

Posted by Subbeo on 11/26/2010

True but Arsenal should be winning trophys and Liverpool is having a very average season.
Realisticly newcastle should be happy if they dont get relegated

[why should Arsenal be winning trophies?]

Posted by Azino Odhomi (NUFC) on 11/28/2010

This article conveys all that I've been feeling about our team. I made a comment on the youtube video of NUFC receiving their Coca-Cola Championship trophy saying something along the lines of, "Next up,Europa League contention". I honestly believe now, especially after watching them stall Chelsea, that it is possible with a few changes. Hughton needs to tell the fellas in the back that clearing the ball does not make you less of a man. You do not have to dribble out of every situation. I think Andy Carroll has been great this season on the pitch but he needs a strike partner. I know they pair him up with Ameobi from time to time, but they just don't have a Drogba/Anelka pairing quality. I would suggest Carroll/Ranger or crazily enough Ameobi/Lovenkrandz. Carroll and Ameobi are too alike striking wise to mesh well. Anyway, I just wanted to end with saying that if there are really Spurs fans out there who want Redknapp fired, they need to find a bridge and jump off it. He's been amazing.

Posted by twm on 12/02/2010

Saw the game v. Chelsea and am getting a little worried about the state of the team. Upfront, Ameobi looked ineffectual again (what happened to the Shola who took 2 wonderful goals to the Mackems?) and Carroll had to track back so many times to be the target man for ... Shola. Totally agree with you that Hughton should just put Ranger on the starting line-up already.

At the back, Campbell looked extremely dodgy (not to mention unfit) even though we didn't concede more than once - for which we were very lucky. Thankfully, Taylor was reliable as ever.

In midfield we had little in the way of creativity. Jose and Jonas seemed to be losing their chemistry a bit. Tiote continues to do remarkably well in the middle of the park as an anchorman (while picking up yellows for fun) but Guthrie was just ... the less said the better.

We badly need reinforcements - esp. at the back and in centre mid. Hughton's got to be bold now and pick Ranger upfront.

Posted by Michael O'Connor on 12/05/2010

As far as I'm concerned, Chris Hughton is a great manager. I'm really surprised at the call to remove him though. He did wonders for us in the Championship and now we want him gone cause we hit a rough streak? No, I think Hughton should stay.

Posted by significance on 12/05/2010

all i can say is leave hughton to stay but nufc needs stability, for the past 5-6 yrs we needed, don't expect much this season, next season will be the right time for that. look at david moyes and everton it took years, be patient, he is trying 2 build a disciplined and spirited team

  Post your comment
Name:
Email Address:
Comments:
characters left
About
Marc Duffy Marc Duffy is a National Account Manager in the alcoholic drinks industry - a career in alcohol was obviously the natural step after following Newcastle United for all of his 32 years. Marc blames his father for his obsession with Newcastle United - since attending his first game at the age of 4 Marc has endured many ups and downs, and despite the lack of silverware remains positive that a trophy will be won at some point in his lifetime! (Wait, does the Intertoto cup not count?) Follow Marc on Twitter @MarcSDuffy

RSS feed

Categories
Recent Posts
Archives