ESPN Soccernet - Correspondents - Manchester United
soccernet blog
Manchester United
Posted by Mark Payne on 11/28/2011

We football fans are a notoriously fickle bunch. Either we are not happy because of the quality of the show or perhaps the fortitude of the results irk us. Either way, it’s certainly a mixed bag with United at the moment.

Our rather schizophrenic football club has assumed one of its more flippant guises this past week. It has been a welcome return to see a swaggering United side pushing forward in search of goals and glory. It seems a shame that we can’t marry that style with the habit of keeping clean sheets that has been prevalent over the past month.

However, I don’t think these things will be mutually exclusive forever. As mentioned in previous posts, this is a young team, which is also dealing with a bit of an injury crisis. As far as I am concerned things are just fine. In the medium and long term view Manchester United are doing exactly the right thing. In the short term, we are second in the league to the most expensive team in history and we have just dropped two points on the back of a borderline penalty decision. These things happen.

On the plus side, Javier Hernandez is in the form of his life at the moment. It was revealing to read a recent interview in which he said he considered packing it all in before he signed for United. Thank goodness he didn’t, at the moment he is holding our season together. Incidentally, he deserves great credit for reuniting United fans with the Sombrero.
Sombrero.jpg
Maradona good, Pele better, George Best.
This week saw the sixth anniversary of George Best’s passing. It seemed fitting that it should coincide with the side returning to the kind of play the Northern Irishman’s side made the norm in the sixties.

Fergie was in a predictably excellent mood about the penalty call. “A travesty”, he said, “I don't think anyone in the ground apart from the assistant thought it was a penalty”. One wonders if the changing room for match officials at Old Trafford is bulletproof. I certainly hope so.

It seems slightly inappropriate to whinge on about the men in black in the same week that German referee Babak Rafati has revealed his struggle with depression. It is possible though, to look at this situation without making angry football managers the bogeymen.

It is equally true to say that managers are under unbearable pressure and will likely react when they see perceived injustice. It is a long road, but one day depression will be viewed by society as something we all need to be mindful of, like asthma. At the moment, the structure of the sport is such, that multi-million pound decisions are being made at the blow of a whistle.

There can be no stronger argument for the introduction of video technology than that it would reduce the pressure on individual human beings. It would also be fairer, and United would be two points better off this season. It must be said of course, few will have sympathy with United for not getting a penalty appeal for a change. What goes around, I guess…

Nonetheless, even if the results haven’t gone our way this week I have seen my club go for it in two games and not get the rub of the green. That will change and the important thing is that the philosophy of attack, attack, attack stays the same. Our erratic luck will shift soon enough and in the meantime, we have plenty of blessings to count.

Follow Mark on twitter.com/markjpayne


Follow ESPNsoccernetFC on Twitter

Comments

Posted by johnbosco obiora on 11/27/2011

that is not a penalty ref

Posted by Godfrey on 11/27/2011


We do need the rub o' the green...

And people will be on about us getting a fair share o' them dicey desicions....
One thing I dont seem to understand though is why we dont concentrate a bit more on our set pieces..
Nani's delievery leaves the best of us cringing...
I dont get it why he doesnt let carrick or young assume the role...
i no people would argue a team like us shouldn't sweat over set pieces but we shouldn't be looking shambolic either

Posted by Ray on 11/27/2011

Please do not introduce Instant Replay in to Football. I am from America, and it is PAINFULL to be watching a game of college or pro American football and them stop everytime a close play happens. Part of what I love about the beautiful game is human error.. the Intentional handballs(Henry,Maradonna,Suarez), the bad calls(Ferdinand, Rodwell) the flops and the dives. without that stuff the game isnt what it is.. the drama the suspense the joy the agony.. leave horrible replay out of it... its to great!!!!

Posted by kardajo on 11/27/2011

I actually found myself laughing out loud toward the end of this game... never have I seen a goal more charmed than that of Newcastle's... it simply defied belief that no one could get a shot on target, did our striking coach take a vacation or something? Still that being said, credit to Newcastle for defending like champs. Credit to the linesman for sticking to his decision even if it was as wrong as could be, credit to Fergie for not saying something that could get him suspended, credit to Pardew for saying it was a dodgy decision. If we play like this every week I'll be happy even if we fail to loose the league... unless City win it, then I won't be happy at all. This weekend is one of the rare occasions where I actually cheer for liverpool with every fiber of sincerity in me.

Posted by David Smith on 11/28/2011

I've been following my beloved United since 1979. In these 32 years, I've seen many a dodgy decision go our way, so I can't grumble at this one. The penalty was given, incorrectly - we move on. The attacking verve was back in that second half, although the finishing, once again, left a lot to be desired. Ashley Young could of and should of won it for us, but the lad's been out for a stretch, so he gets the benefit of the doubt. Newcastle played well though and grew in confidence as the game went on. Krul was outstanding, but De Gea also shined when called upon; his continued improvement is very encouraging. Nani, as usual, did absolutely NOTHING. Just the same old same old from the boy who fancies himself as one of the best in the world. Bollocks Nani. I thought Evra had a good game though and was surprised Fergie hauled him off. Carrick continues to steady the ship in the middle, although Rooney's lack of goals just now is a concern. Overall, better, now let's batter Palace in the Cup

Posted by Patrice-Kigali on 11/28/2011


Hi Mark and everyone on this blog.

A few things about that Match:

1. United should have won the game in the first half or at least scored a goal but the tea has grown a habit of making things hard for itself.

2. Everyone saw that that was not a penalty but that is no excuse for not wining the game. I believe if you are to be a champion, you have to overcome even bigger challenges than that.

3. Nani seems to have frustrated Rooney enough and i don't know if I am the only one noting that but Rooney seems to have given up on Nani as a supplier of quality crosses! Why not bring in Valencia for a while-SAF; think about it.

4. It seems Carrick is picking form but i will leave it here for a moment as tomorrow he may go in recess again.

5. It is never in me as a Manchester United fan to take pride from two consecutive draws but the kind of football we played against Benifica and Newcastle was encouraging only that we started late on Newctle and did not shoot well Benfca.

Posted by AARON MARK HENDRIX on 11/30/2011

Well allow me to offer an alternative view. We didnt defend well and though the pen was a "travesty" we always looked like conceeding, we lacked someone who could thread that killer pass that leads to a sure goal/cross the ball well enuff and were wastefull in front of goal.Oh and we dropped two points which we should have wrapped up as soon as fabio was thru on goal(let alone all the other misses)But in saying tht, we finally played like Manchester United,and created quite a few chances without finishing em off unfortunately.Play in general (aside from the points above) was good but nowhere near league/UCL winning form.Does that matter in November?Well,too early to say,but if this continues,we'll not be winning the league nor getting anywhere near the venue of the UCL final.In fact,sadly,I have a feeling we might not get thru Basle really.Not me talking down my team,just a rather valid concern I believe.But if we play like we did on Saturday we stand a chance...fingers crossed!!

Posted by Gbadegesin Is-haq Taiwo on 11/30/2011

i ll like SAF to sign very strong pacy skillfulcreative young players in replacing evra ferdinand. scholes and probably good sharp shooter striker.... die hard united fans...... fagie we need epl ucl cc fa tittles..... we can do it again

Posted by David Smith on 12/01/2011

What an absolutely shocking and dreadful performance. The captain, Johnny Evans, continues to cost this club - surely his days at Old Trafford are numbered now. Anderson can't kick a ball straight with his right foot, Nani couldn't put over a decent corner if his life depended on it and now, the marginal-at best Diouf, can't even take a damn throw-in properly. The Spaz twins are hurt yet again and Berbatov was so disinterested in being out there, he used a "bad ankle" as an excuse to come off at the half. Gibson, Park and Macheda were very, very poor. The South Korean has REALLY regressed this year. Smalling is class and Valencia at least tried to get forward and break the Palace defence down, but that's the extent of the positives. Morrison and Pogba breathed a bit of life into the match in the second half, but they're both a year or two away from the first team squad. We would of have had Cardiff in the semi-final, but not for the first time, the youngsters let themselves down.

Posted by AARON MARK HENDRIX on 12/01/2011

Just had to give a shout out to our boys who played last night.Terrible doesnt even begin to describe how it felt to have to sit and watch 120mins of painfull,horrible football from united.I woke up at 3.30am just to watch a bunch of players do injustice to Man United.Its not that we lost,or that we lost to Crystal Palace.It wouldnt have mattered if we had lost to a non league team in fact.It was how we played.It just goes to show that gone are the days when any team we put out would play "Man United" football.These days , even the first team blow hot and cold.You can argue all you like about how we played a "second rate" team etc,but we're Man United for cryin out loud.Not to sound arrogant,but any team we put out should be capable of givin a decent performance.Im not sure if we got a lotta rubbish players,if morale and form is down for the squad or what,but i do know that we wont be winning much(if anythin at all)with this squad.Crystal Palace though put in a wonderful perfomance..

Posted by johanzul on 12/01/2011

Just a message to my friend who has been arguing with me for past of MU CL and BPL seasons (dun get me wrong, both are MU fans who, one uses his head to think logically while the other just pure on faith)..."I told you so".

The strategy of using young boys to be grown as experience man in football shall acquire too many efforts and it is not a guarantee good end results but what is guarantee, they are less expensive. Arsenal for example, see how Arsene had dedicated his effort to build up individual skills and good team, no cups, good players shall be bought, along the way shareholders got their return for not spending too $$$ for experience and quality players + other profit which in the end, the fans not only doesn't have cups to celebrates and brag on, moreover losses $$$, time and effort defending the team they love.

Well, I'm sorry for Arsene and Arsenal and hopefully, I'll not have to say I TOLD YOU SO to my dear friend again and to the club that I had supported for so long.

Posted by Torontored on 12/02/2011

Careful there David, you're starting to sound like a certain "dopey Canadian". And while I can sometimes drag myself away from hockey and maple syrup, after matches like this I wish i wouldn't. i think we are in complete agreement that this was as insipid as it gets and while we definietely didn't field a proper side there were enough senior players on the pitch that this was inexcusable.

I thought Park was especially bad and you just knew that it was going to come down to a Cpt (?!?!)Evans mistake at the death. Always does. The one solace i can take from this? maybe after this showing, the likes Diouf, Macheda and Gibson (who wasnt terrible but was not good by any stretch) have finally shown they are not good enough to play at this club.

I too thought Morrison and Pogba looked good. While they may not be ready for primetime just yet i would like to see what they can do with the 1st team. One at a time and not surrounded by these mugs.

Tricky one away to Villa, c'mon boys!

Posted by MU fan on 12/03/2011

Listen MU squad!!! listen!!!..if you lost the title to Shitty or Loossafools this term...someone of you going die!!!

---thanks...

  Post your comment
Name:
Email Address:
Comments:
characters left