ESPN Soccernet - Correspondents - Manchester City
soccernet blog
Manchester City
Posted by Wallace Poulter on 11/28/2010

The difference between winning, and in this case drawing, can be thin. It's a cliche often rolled out that good teams know how to win even when not playing their best. And for a few minutes on Saturday it looked like City might just do that. Alas, a Matthew Etherington goal got Stoke a point in the dying minutes and fair is fair, no more than Stoke deserved.

However City continue to pick up points, while their rivals for the 4th place generally stumble. City are not contenders for the title, such talk was nonsense, but remain right in the thick of things. Yes wins against United, Birmingham and Stoke rather than draws would see City top, however the focus has to be on the Champions League place.

A tight defense, second only to Chelsea in fewest goals allowed, remains the foundation on which this club will build. Certainly more goals must come, both Blackpool and Newcastle have scored a greater number, but this is a work in progress and a very young team. Patience, in the face of the huge sums spent, needs to be the over riding factor.

Speaking of Blackpool I suspect Ian Holloway will be adjudged "naive" after his club lost a two goal advantage at Bolton. The flip side of course is that in going for a third goal while 2-0 up, Holloway would have well and truly killed the game off should the Seasiders have scored. Based on all the interviews I've seen of Holloway this season it seems to me that he's decided that Blackpool just don't have the defensive ability to defend against quality Premier League sides and therefore the only way to stand a chance of staying up is to constantly attack. The other team can't score if you have the ball and are attacking. He'll get caught out more than a few times doing this, but Blackpool will be, and are, a blast to watch.

That being said you do wonder how long Owen Coyle stays at Bolton. If the Arsenal or Liverpool job were to open, I'd tab him as the favourite for either opening. No, I'm not suggesting that Wenger should leave Arsenal, but you have to wonder at what point the lack of success necessitates a change for a club that demands winning.

Down towards the bottom you do have to wonder if David Moyes has reached his sell by date at Everton. I've always thought he was a good manager, but this early season slow start is becoming more than a habit for the Toffees. Three years ago I would have pegged Moyes as Old Purple Noses successor at United. Now I think it's even money whether the Everton manager is still at the club this time next year. There's also a very vocal and significant part of the Everton faithful who can't stand Moyes and his tactics. It's not going to take much to have them persuade the more silent majority.

Over at United... well what can you say? Berbatov is a good player, always has been. He just doesn't conform to the perceived ideal of running around constantly to show that you are making an effort. Probably not the best result for Sam Allardyce with new Indian owners at Rovers. New owners usually want their own man at a club, something Roy Hodgson is no doubt aware over at Liverpool, and therefore I doubt Big Sam will last long at the club.

The question of course is where does Allardyce go after this? Bolton was perfect, an unfancied side whose supporters would accept the long ball tactics because they were winning. And in some ways Allardyce is unfairly tagged with that. His Bolton sides could play good football when he had the right players added to the base squad. But how many fans will give the Blackburn manager time to get to that point? We all saw what happened at Newcastle where the style of play is as important as the result. It's hard to find clubs out there with the base resources that would be needed along with the patience. Wolves maybe, but such locations are few and far between.

Mark Hughes and Fulham find themselves one place above the relegation zone. This should not be a surprise. Hughes at Blackburn and City had the exact same start and given time he'll have them in the top ten next season.

It's a funny old Premier League when Sunderland can destroy Chelsea, and it wasn't even close, and then lose to Wolves. I suspect these kind of results will continue all the way until the end of the season.

At Upton Park probably the worst possible result for West Ham as they won, so Avram Grant keeps his job. At some point the owners are going to have to bite the bullet and replace Grant. To do otherwise is to see a team that talent wise should be mid table go down.

The Sunday games almost went perfectly for City. A draw at White Hart Lane would have been perfect, however Aaron Lennon continued the Spurs magic. Not the first time old 'Arry has done it to Liverpool at the death of course. Tottenham turned their season around and beat undefeated Liverpool via a last second Pavlyuchenko just after Redknapp joined the club.

Chelsea continued their troubled few weeks with a draw at Newcastle. A fully fit Chelsea squad is awfully good, but to a certain extent this was what I was alluding to at the start of the year when I suggested Chelsea could struggle. The depth has gone and while Deco, Ballack and Carvalho had each lost a step their ability to step into the side for a couple of games was invaluable.

Comments

Posted by Trojan on 11/28/2010

Manchester City should have gotten Redknapp! Mancini plays negative football and thats why man city is struggling. Even westbrom and blackpool and better attacking sides than man city and they dont have the same budget! Man city will not be get anywhere till they get rid of mancini period.

Posted by Chinmay on 11/29/2010

I think Owen Coyle would have done much better job at City than Mancini. You said blackburn supporters getting agitated by Big Sam's negative tactics. What about City fans? They have been showing their frustrations in recent draws that City have "achieved". If you target premier league, you can be at 2nd or 3rd end of the season - that is fine but if you target only 4th place, and continue hanging there with a thin rope, I wonder if City will again miss 4th place by a point or two come May 2011. What you think?

Posted by durk on 11/29/2010

The team that wins the Premier League this season will have well and truly earned it.

Every game is a difficult one, and some are very rugged affairs.
The problem for me is the inconsistancy of the officials. Some tackles bring an immediate Yellow or Red card, while some don't even get a foul called.

I do think Mancini gets some of his selections and subs so wrong, and while a local manager could do his job as well, Mancini's advantage is he can lure some of the best in the business to Eastlands. local managers would find that difficult.

Posted by Mick on 11/29/2010

Wallace,
Agreed defensively we are much stronger. However, I agree with Chinmay we are in danger of missing out on fourth. What we need is more goals, we need speed and guile to unlock defences that will park the proverbial bus. The Prem. has never been so tight between relegation and Europe. There will be no easy games and with all the Europa fixtures our squad will be stretched at the seams. There is lots of talk of all the players we are selling/unhappy. However this may be our most important transfer window for bringing in real quality to ensure we will get in the Champions League and achieve silverware.

Posted by Noah Wexler on 11/29/2010

Good post. I am happy with City's progress so far. I love the solid back four especially with Kolarov back in the lineup. Zableta has been a great utility man for us so far as well and expect his role to expand throughout the season with the likely fluctuation in form from the younger players like Richards and Boateng. The consistancy is a lot better than under Hughes in my opinion. I watched every game last year under hughes and was constantly waiting for us to get scored on. Now I feel comfortable that we will not break down absent a major individual mistake or a spectacular buildup and execution by the opponant which is fine. I will give Mancini time to get the offense clicking we have the players they just need to step up. I think at time Barry needs to be out of the lineup to allow both Johnson, Milner and Silva to play with Tevez supported by De Jong and Yaya. After we get a lead then we can sub off Milner or Johnson for Barry and revert to the more defenses approach.

Posted by Martin Nazimek on 11/30/2010

I dont understand all this talk about Mancini and how all these other managers would have done so well IF they came to city. Think about what you are saying her people. Owen Coyle? Really? He is a fine manager, but at city you have to manage a squad filled with stars. Mancini does have experience with that. And yes the result over the weekend was hard to digest, but we played not well and were still in the drivers seat till the last 2 minutes. We have a young squad that are still trying to gel together. Before you go and crown Rednapp or Coyle as better managers that Mancini look at the position we are in right now. Think back a couple of short seasons ago when we were scraping together wins to stay in the top flight. Its not so bad. CTID

Posted by Schwallacus on 12/01/2010

quick question- where has yaya been these past few games? I don't remember seeing anything of an injury or bust up with mancini... unless i missed something?

Posted by harry on 01/06/2011

What gives with the refs? TV gets Bowyer a 3 game vacation but nothing for Ferdinand with his boot in Sangas chest. Soccer is a tough game, let them play hard.

  Post your comment
Name:
Email Address:
Comments:
characters left
About
Wallace Poulter Wallace Poulter is an award winning video game producer, designer, industry consultant and writer. He has been a football fanatic since the day he moved in next door to Brian Clough. "Cloughie" being the acknowledged genius that he was promptly moved out and went to manage Derby. A serviceable senior school left-back in his youth, Poulter played one season of Sunday league football as a striker proving conclusively that he was a serviceable senior school left-back! Today Poulter remains involved with football as a licensed referee and most recently as a consultant on a Football MMO.

RSS feed

Categories
Recent Posts
Archives