ESPN Soccernet - Correspondents - Manchester City
soccernet blog
Manchester City
Posted by Wallace Poulter on 02/09/2010

I've been grumpy the past few days. Really grumpy. I was so disappointing in the January transfer window and the lack of movement by City. I know that I have repeatedly counseled that January is not a time for major players to move and therefore expectations were low. However in a World Cup year there are enough players that are on the fringes of a first team at the major European clubs that City could have and should have made a move.

This is the Hughes situation all over again and frustrates me no end. It's not as if City have a complete team that doesn't require any new players. The 800 pound gorilla in the room is that City need a play maker. I return to my column from August 1st of last year after Elano left the club.

Who is going to pass the ball?

This question wasn't answered by Hughes and the inability of the team to break down opponents and the resulting draws led specifically to the Welshman's downfall. I've been impressed with Mancini's tinkering in a number of matches but just like Hughes the former Inter boss has got it wrong. What is so galling, so utterly frustrating is that the issue is so flaming obvious.

This team will not qualify for the Champions League.

The decision was made, apparently, that with Bridge and Lescott injured that Garrido and Boyata could provide good enough play in the interim and therefore no reinforcements were needed in the transfer window. I disagree and believe that the decision cost the club a trip to Wembley. That Boyata is a find and a good long term prospect in certainly positive, but Garrido was tactically targeted by United in both legs as the obvious suspect link in the defense.

Wembley is gone for now. We can't change that. But the club should be able to put away a club like Hull, it must if it has top six aspirations never mind top four. Mancini has been quoted as being angry at the players when he should be looking at himself. Wrong players, wrong formation, wrong tactics.

Moreover after a turgid first half no substitutions were made at half time. The ineffective Adebayor and Barry should have been replaced by Vieira and Adam Johnson with the club switching to a 4-2-3-1 with Stephen Ireland, again played out of position on the right wing, given the opportunity in the AMC role. Instead belatedly Johnson and Vieira came on and we got to see for the first time the diamond formation with three midfielder enforcers and Adam Johnson given a free reign as the top of the formation.

Johnson did well and Vieira's booking looked more a reputation foul than a bookable offense but Hull never looked like losing. A final few minutes of onslaught brought the chance of a draw however Hull were good value for their three points.

Bottom line, no play maker. There isn't one on the squad and unlike Left Back and Centre Half the club doesn't have a player capable of playing that position returning from injury. Wretched, wretched squad building by the club.

And I take it back about Phil Brown. I said he had lost his team after the Eastland's debacle in late 2008 and I still stand by that. Jimmy Bullard's celebration in the repeat fixture this season and this battling performance show that the former Bolton assistant has well and truly resurrected the combative spirit in Humberside.

City? I like Mancini and absence a Mourinho sighting in the summer I'd like the Italian to stay. City can be a Champions League team under Mancini. Not next year though. Optimism is a good thing and shooting for lofty goals is admirable but if you can't beat Hull City it borders on the naive at best and the downright silly at worst.

Comments

Posted by Jesse on 02/09/2010

I share your frustration, but I have changed my mind about the need for a playmaker. Look at our personnel... our players are the essence of counter-attacking football. SWP, Petrov, Tevez, Weiss, Bellamy, Adam Johnson... We have two members of the first tema that would benefit from a traditional No.10 -- Adebayor and Ireland. No good having a Riquelme when two wingers and Tevez are streaking forward looking for a direct ball to run on to. We are not Arsenal or Barca.

Of course, if a playmaker just dropped into our lap... I think you play the system your players are suited for for the time being... the winter window isn't the time to switch systems or tactics that the players aren't accustomed to... In the summer though...

Posted by Bryan, VA on 02/09/2010

Yea it is frustrating sometimes I just watched our game vs Bolton...cant believe he started Vieira, De Jong and Barry??? only 2 of them need to start at most with either SWP, Petrov, Ireland, or Bellamy to add some excitement to the midfield. Adebayor and Tevez and Johnson looked good up top together but the defense is still way too shaky at times to be top 4...although I hope we end up there!

Posted by Jim Kanichirayil-Chicago on 02/10/2010

Hooray! Sir Walter returns with my Man City fix! I had almost the identical thought as I was watching the City match over the weekend. Given Mancini's pedigree I was almost sure that they would win and win big against a team like Hull. Color me supremely disappointed when they laid an egg in the match. I am at least glad they handled Bolton so hopefully it was just an aberration. This weekend's match is going to be a critical one if they want to hope for a top four finish.

Posted by micky-2-times on 02/10/2010

I think we have the talent now, so there is no excuse. What about Vieira, Ireland, Petrov as playmakers in midfield. The area I worry about is central defence and defence in general. If top 4 finish doesn't happen I think the biggest mistake was to sell Dunne. After Stoke (x2) there is Pool, Chelsea, and Spurs. The season will probably be decided on these 3 games. The Hull result was a disaster, but we have to be optimistic. Its still all to play for.

Wallace Reply Mancini's preference appears to be three ball winning enforcer types plus a creative midfielder rather than additional play makers.

  Post your comment
Name:
Email Address:
Comments:
characters left
About
Wallace Poulter Wallace Poulter is an award winning video game producer, designer, industry consultant and writer. He has been a football fanatic since the day he moved in next door to Brian Clough. "Cloughie" being the acknowledged genius that he was promptly moved out and went to manage Derby. A serviceable senior school left-back in his youth, Poulter played one season of Sunday league football as a striker proving conclusively that he was a serviceable senior school left-back! Today Poulter remains involved with football as a licensed referee and most recently as a consultant on a Football MMO.

RSS feed

Categories
Recent Posts
Archives