ESPN Soccernet - Correspondents - Manchester City
soccernet blog
Manchester City
Posted by Wallace Poulter on 01/21/2010

City striker Jo has joined Galatasaray on loan until the end of the season. Around the net I'm seeing Jo described as a flop and while he may well end up to be less than advertised Jo is one of the symbols of the Hughes regime. It would not surprise me to see the Brazilian round in to excellent form because of the presence in the Turkish side of a certain Elano Ralph Blumer.

Jo was not, as far as one can tell, a Hughes signing. The player was targeted at the end of the Sven era and the signing dragged on until Hughes joined. Jo, Elano and Robinho are not the type of player Hughes targets. Hughes has a system and a style. It is based on a regimented hard graft approach that is typified by someone like Craig Bellamy. When these hard worker types have excellent skills, such as Bellamy and Carlos Tevez, then they excel.

It is my belief that Hughes would never have won the league, ever, regardless of the amount of money that was made available. I do believe that he could have crafted a side that qualified for the Champions League in time.

With greatness comes many times a certain level of flakiness or a desire to do things your own way. This is true in all professions. Brazilians footballers as a whole, and I'm aware this is a broad generalization, have always struck me as firmly in the camp of "mad" geniuses marching to beat of their own drummer. When they are all on the same page, which we see at most World Cups, the result is devastating football however there have also been years where Brazil have struggled as a team of individuals.

I can't think of players more the antithesis of the Hughes style.

There is one school of thought which says you treat players the same. There is another which acknowledges that players are radically different and rules change depending on the players(s) involved. The former style can lead to solid unspectacular teams who occasionally can win championships. The latter is the ultimate sink or swim with the potential to achieve heights unimagined by the first group but also with an equal opportunity to crash and burn in an epic fashion.

And in retrospect that was one of the major problems for Hughes. He had three Brazilians on his team that expect to be catered to and indulged while is entire philosophy was and is around building a team. I'm not saying one is better than the other just that the two can't exist together.

Now with Jo there was an even more fundamental problem. The former CSKA Moscow striker was never used in the way he was for his Russian club.

If we hit the rewind button to the Sven era the team was built around Elano as an attacking midfielder and Martin Petrov leading the charge down the left wing. Rolando Bianchi would usually make a run into the six yard box toward the far post while Elano, Stephen Ireland and Michael Johnson would crash the box at the last minute giving City four players in the box and, unless the oppositions midfield had tracked back, a numerical superiority at the point of attack.

Such tactics require the lead attacker, in this case Bianchi, to aggressively go to the goal taking the attention of the defenders and goalkeeper. Bianchi scored goals but he also helped create opportunities for Johnson and Ireland in particular coming into space in the box. So everything is focused through Petrov on the left and then driving the ball across the box to the right.

Enter Jo, a player who much prefers to make angled runs from right to left behind defenders looking for a through ball. The absolute worst style to play with Petrov in that Jo would be running towards the Bulgarian and not surprisingly Jo "failed" with City. Nor was the player used, in a manner that suits his skills, at Everton.

And now this "flop" goes to Galatasary where he will play with Elano, a player City desperately miss, and who just happens to excel at making accurate passes to players running into position. It would not surprised me for Jo to return to his Moscow days where he averaged a goal every two games.

Maybe I'm wrong. It has always been my belief that players have certain styles of play and the challenge is not to find the "best" players but players with complimentary styles of play that allow you to build a superior team. To use a cliche, a team that is greater than the sum of the parts. It is my contention that this is where Liverpool failed in the off season not understanding that Alonso meshed with the Brigadier and Torres allowing the latter two players to play at their full potential.

We shall see...

Comments

Posted by daz taylor on 01/21/2010

jo is far too lazy to make it as a top striker in the premier league.david moyes gets the best out of players he wouldnt of let him go if he is as good as you say.

Wallace Reply I'm not saying Jo is good. I'm saying Jo plays a certain style and neither Hughes nor Moyes have shown any history of employing the tactics that take advantage of the Brazilian striker.

Posted by Onur Coskun on 01/22/2010

Thank you for the indepth analysis...as a Galatasaray fan, it's good to get a deeper look at Jo and his time with Manchester City instead of just simply being labeled as a flop. Galatasaray has a long history of reviving careers like Gheorghe Hagi, Popescu, Taffarel, Kewell, Baros, who've achieved legendary status in Turkey, so I'm hoping Jo can join that list and like you said, relive his Moscow days for years to come. One thing's for sure though every GS fan like me is excited about the prospects of a 22 year old Brazilian International striker who's going to have players like Arda Turan, Keita, Elano, and Kewell setting him up for goals.

Posted by Evan Georgiou on 01/22/2010

Congrats on an excellent blog....Jo,Elano and alas Robinho have simply not "delivered" at City and that fact cannot be ascribed to Hughes/Svenn/Mancini...I watched in horror how Ela and Robi played their socks off for Brazil and NEVER for my beloved City...I hope that they do so at Gala and then at least the fans will not be robbed.....just don't blame the Manager,there is a thing called self respect and it is a little thin with these three.....

Posted by Adam on 01/22/2010

Any truth to robinho being sold during this transer window? It seems clear that Mancini is not in favor of playing him. I read (not sure if it was just high hopes) to swap Robinho for Yaya Toure and cash. City was linked with bringing in Yaya before the transfer window opened. Barca wants Robinho, and Yaya doesnt play there currently. Any real shot?

Wallace Reply I doubt if Robinho will be sold in this transfer window. If he is to leave in any way it would be much better if he went out on loan.

Posted by kk on 01/22/2010

go city go sign karim benzema and gonzalo higuain both from real madrid.go city gogogo

Posted by Dion on 01/22/2010

This is why I support Arsene Wenger and his Arsenal. He always look for players that suit his style of play, and along the way adjust his own tactics according to his players' style of play. Add that to the knack of his bargain hunting and I can only say how lucky The Gunners to have a manager like him.

All that aside, I can only agree with your view on how much Manchester City misses Elano. I miss him in my fantasy squad.

Wallace Reply I know I go on about Elano but honestly it isn't fixated on the player rather the skills that he brought to the team and have not been replaced. Add Elano to the current squad and I would expect City to make the Champions League, it's that specific. He isn't coming back so Mancini needs to find a similarly skilled player.

Posted by Foxy on 01/23/2010

Love the blog, Wallace. Mancini seems to love the midfield triangle, whether its with 2 wingers + a striker here, or with the diamond + 2 strikers he has employed in the past. I think they can have great success with a sort of diamond with Bellamy as a striker splitting out left, Tevez getting attention at the far post, and Ade as the attacking mid, crashing the box with Barry and Ireland/SWP. Thoughts?

Wallace Replay I've thought in the past that Adebayor might make an interesting AM as a turn of pace but Mancini at Inter used the AM as his play maker. I still don't see who at City takes that role.

  Post your comment
Name:
Email Address:
Comments:
characters left
About
Wallace Poulter Wallace Poulter is an award winning video game producer, designer, industry consultant and writer. He has been a football fanatic since the day he moved in next door to Brian Clough. "Cloughie" being the acknowledged genius that he was promptly moved out and went to manage Derby. A serviceable senior school left-back in his youth, Poulter played one season of Sunday league football as a striker proving conclusively that he was a serviceable senior school left-back! Today Poulter remains involved with football as a licensed referee and most recently as a consultant on a Football MMO.

RSS feed

Categories
Recent Posts
Archives