|
|
 |
|
A Carlos Tevez hat trick, 4th place, four goals scored and the first Roberto Mancini era tactical mistake. What a fabulous night for City with so much to talk about. But first I'm going to call out Benjani. I roasted the Zimbabwean striker, rightly so, for a terrible performance against Middlesbrough. Tonight in the first ten minutes Benjani showed more hustle, passion and commitment than he did in the entire Boro match.
The Portsmouth fans loved Benjani because of the total commitment that the player made in a game. The run out against Boro was quite shockingly bad. Here, frankly, quite the opposite. Benjani tracked back, closed down opponents and generally made a nuisance of himself on the defensive end. Up front he worked hard and found himself in the right place at the right time, particularly in the first half to be part of the City goals. Essentially City just found an additional striker tonight.
It was Benjani's shot within 6 minutes of the start of the game that Tevez turned in for the first goal.
City started with the back four of Zabaleta, Richards, Kompany and Garrido. Once more with solid defensive midfielders, Barry and de Jong, in front of him, Richards is starting to show the form he did under Sven. With 5 minutes to go until half time, Richards picked up the ball in front of his own box and started a run forward that reminds everyone why there were comparisons with, ironically, Patrick Vieira earlier in his career. Finally after running the length of the pitch a pass was slipped to Bejani who was unlucky to hit the inside of the post only for the rebound to come to Richards. The England defender made no mistake with a chance that was not particularly easy and City were cruising at 2-0
Out on the wings were Bellamy and Petrov with the Welshman on the left. Now as good as Petrov is one thing that the Bulgarian doesn't do is track back consistently. It's especially noticeable when you compare him with Bellamy. Blackburn were making most of their effective moves down the centre and out to the left and after 28 minutes Mancini countered this by swapping Bellamy and Petrov on the wings. This nullified the Blackburn attack.
After the half Tevez scored his third, improbably from yet another Benjani assist, and City were threatening to run away with the game.
And then for the first time in four matches Mancini made a tactical error. And it is noticeable because until this point he has been pitch perfect particularly on defense. Whenever City do not have possession there are two lines of four defenders across the field. As noted Petrov has issues with this, but the team was playing solid football.
Enter Robinho for Bellamy. Oops! Now City were defending with only 6 players when Blackburn had the ball as the Brazilian was worse than Petrov in this regard. Predictably Blackburn pulled one back and for 5 minutes or so had City on the back foot. A more ruthless attack would have made the game more interesting. It was a mistake, plain and simple. Robinho and Petrov cannot be on the pitch at the same time in those positions the way Mancini plays.
Fortunately Blackburn didn't take advantage and a couple of late substitutions allowed City to play three at the back with the two full backs then tucked in tight which stifled any final push. The icing on the cake was Tevez's third, City's fourth, a lovely shot from the top of the box.
Bottom line, City are in fourth and Mancini's assertion that the title is a possibility is, for the first time, not looking Alice in Wonderland.
Comments
 |
Posted by Martin Nazimek on 01/12/2010
Sounds like you're saying that robo is a liability on the pitch. Well, are you? If you are I totally agree with you. I just don't see him getting it done. Its safe to say that bellers is a LOT better in that position offensively AND defensively. That being said, what happens to robo now? Does he sit the bench or do we get rid of him? Once SWP comes back, is he ever going to play? CTID
Wallace Reply There is some debate as to what in Mancini's preferred formation. I've seen tight diamond with 3 midfield enforcers and an attacking midfielder while some other blogs have said he likes wingers - it's either one or the other (and I'm looking into further.) If indeed he prefers the former then I'd like to see Robinho given the opportunity to play the attacking midfielder role in such a formation. That leads to numerous other questions about who doesn't play, but just focusing on Robinho, that would be interesting to see. At his best, against Arsenal last year, guy is special...
 |
Posted by mark Brewer on 01/12/2010
do you think its clear now that sacking hughes was the right move and mancini will deliver and make city the powerhouse their board and owners want it to be
Wallace Reply Mancini is off to a great start, certainly. I'm truly fascinated by Mancini in a way I haven't been with a manager at any club in a long time and look forward to each match to see what he is doing with the team.
My position with the Hughes departure is that it was handled poorly and at a minimum the impression was given that the "goalposts" were moved mid season on the former manager. I was not a fan, as regular readers know.
 |
Posted by City Laxer on 01/12/2010
Another good article wallace, tho I'm not sure if we should be blaming the tactics or robbie for rovers' only goal... i would put the majority of the blame on Given for handcuffing Kompany(tho it was a poor first touch from him as well) with that terrible rainbow pass, instead of booting the ball upfield... true we did go back on our heels for a few minutes, but after that we were attacking again and i thought robinho definitely made in impact in that regard... he had a nice strike on goal that forced robinson into a good save, as well as having a goal called back due to him drifting a bit offside... still he was dangerous and did assist on tevez's hat trick goal... i'm not ready to give up on him yet, i just think he needs a manager that will get the consistent best out of him... hughes couldn't, but still as you mentioned (ex. arsenal game last year) that when he is on he is among the world's best
 |
Posted by blumoon22 on 01/12/2010
The comfort at which citeh won the match was encouraging (given the number of players missing). The amount of time they had on the ball without contest was shocking! The fact that Mancini continues to get the best from players that have been in limbo for some time (Benjani, Garrido, Petrov) is impressive. I am looking forward to Everton on Saturday! Things look promising. Big fan Wallace.
 |
Posted by matt on 01/12/2010
A good read, and fairly apposite analysis, although my reading is that the problems following robinho's introduction arose when we had possesion, not when we were defending.
Bellamy is uber-direct, robinho is uber-intricate. robinho's style is to take touches and bring others closer to him, whereas bellamy, as we start to counter, takes a position where he can run at full pelt as soon as he is released. this pushes the opponents back. as such, on the left of the 4-4-2, robinho allows the opposition to win the ball back and move forward. when he contributed the final third, he was wonderful, but out on the left, near the halfway line, from a tactical perspective, he was a problem for us.
I'm now a fan of your blog, Wallace.
Keep it up chap!
 |
Posted by matt on 01/12/2010
can i just add....allowing the opposition to move forward and compress the play, as happened post-robinho, is a problem for us in and out of possession... sure, their midfielders are close enough to support the striker, and run deep into our third, but in this case, the problem appeared to be that their defence and midfielders were able to move closer together, denied us the time and space we crave in midfield.
anyway, this is a minor gripe on a very enjoyable night. surely you have more to say on Tevez's wonderful performance!
Wallace Reply re Tevez: Uh no, lol. Honestly I spent so much time watching what the entire team was doing and seeing the strings that Mancini was pulling that I, alas, didn't get to sit back and just enjoy the hat trick.
 |
Posted by micky-2-times on 01/12/2010
4 wins, 10 goals,3 clean sheets. Mancini is off to a great start, although you could say the first real test is at Everton on Sat. Robinho doesn't have the passion for the club and should be unloaded asap.
Posted by Kenny on 01/14/2010
I believe Mancini has brought stability to the back 4 at the moment. We don't see those pinball strike in the box anymore. However if anyone analyse the overall contribution of each player closely, you will discover De Jong walking lazily without much contribution to the midfield. The ball just past by the City midfield easily and always burdened the fullback. However he can hide his laziness from the close eyes of both Hugh and Mancini. He got the starting 11 line up every time. I has observed that he was good only in one match against Chealsea. Wake up Mancini!
| |
Post your comment |
 |
|
|
|
|
About
Wallace Poulter is an award winning video game producer, designer, industry consultant and writer. He has been a football fanatic since the day he moved in next door to Brian Clough. "Cloughie" being the acknowledged genius that he was promptly moved out and went to manage Derby. A serviceable senior school left-back in his youth, Poulter played one season of Sunday league football as a striker proving conclusively that he was a serviceable senior school left-back! Today Poulter remains involved with football as a licensed referee and most recently as a consultant on a Football MMO.
|
Categories
Recent Posts
Archives
|