ESPN Soccernet - Correspondents - Manchester City
soccernet blog
Manchester City
Posted by Wallace Poulter on 08/06/2009

I'm sure the press will have a field day with the 3-2 loss to Rangers, but in this case I don't see it as a big deal. There should be no way that Dunne and Toure are the starting central combination for the game at Blackburn or if they are then the negative results will be inevitable. So nothing really learned that the club and the fans didn't already know.

If anything I think the result increases the chance that Joleon Lescott will join the club. What's an extra few million in fees when money is no object and the alternative is painfully obvious.

I sincerely hope that Richard Dunne can turn it around. His play for the Republic of Ireland against Bulgaria was something special but it has been 18 months since he put in a performance like that for City. The Dunne of a couple of years ago would be a huge uplift for the team; the Dunne of last season was quite terrible.

A Toure, Lescott, Onuoha, Kompany and Dunne defensive central back five is decent. And that's a relative statement. If City now aspire to the top four then that's a different requirement than a centre of defense that can maintain a mid table position.

Elsewhere... Sunderland continue a very impressive off season with the signing of Darren Bent. The Wearsiders have now rebuilt their front line with Frazier Campbell and Bent and along with the capture of Marseilles captain Lorik Cana and Paraguayan National captain Paulo Da Silva are adding some quality experience to the club.

Liverpool's pending immediate capture of Roma star Alberto Aquiliani leads credence to the theory that the Alonso move has been on the way for a couple of weeks. Aquilani is injury prone and while not as rare as Italian goal poachers, Italian playmakers are not plentiful on the ground in the Premier League either. Not as good as Alonso no matter how the spin is attempted.

And Finally... Couple of City old boys in the news ad both connected with Scotland. Nicky Weaver has signed with Dundee United while Georgios Samaras netted a late late winner for Celtic in their historic away win at Moscow in Champions League qualification. I'm surprised that Weaver hasn't been the target of bids from Championship teams. Injury has blighted a once promising career but at age 30 there still seems a lot of football left in one of the heroes of Wembley.

And speaking of heroes, Samaras will be feted as one after his goal against Dynamo Moscow. It wasn't a particularly good goal although as has been often said they all count. In this case Samaras ran across the box from left to right before hitting a weak but well placed shot back the way he had come into the left corner. What mattered was that the Moscow keeper had all his weight on his left foot and couldn't get the leverage to spring back to make the save. Fortuitous but I'm sure Celtic will not complain. I still maintain that Samaras was used correctly in only a handful of games by City and still wonder what would have happened if we'd seen some old fashioned winger play and ball supply to the Greek forward.

Comments

Posted by Martin Nazimek on 08/06/2009

It was a preseason match. That all it was. Other than the glaring weakness in central defense, I found our left back out of position in a number of situations. Maybe they are still trying to feel it out on the pitch in the preseason with the squad, which I hope is the reason. If this is to continue in the season, i dont know if WB will survive the entire season. This makes the Lescott thing even more important as he can be a left back. This is a last resort thing though imo. As I said, hope its just the kinks being worked out in preseason games and we will be ready for the start of the season. CTID

Posted by lex on 08/06/2009

4-2-3-1 would be interesting.

Back four - Zabaleta (RB), Kompany (CB), Toure (CB), Bridge (LB)

Holding midfielders - DeJong, Barry

Attacking midfielders - Robinho, Ireland, Tevez (pushed up)

Adebayor up top.

That might be their strongest starting 11. They played close to that for the start of the Rangers match, and were doing pretty well.

I think Adebayor has to start up front. He brings intelligence and composure to the attack.

Posted by chris on 08/06/2009

and Ireland continued good form, Robinho had his moments, and Petrov seems to be getting healthy... All in all not bad but the defense was shambolic, especially after Ben Haim was introduced - hopefuly he will not be seeing any time this season.

Posted by Jon on 08/07/2009

Wallace, nice thoughts as always. It seems to be a consensus amongst the City faithful that the back line needs strengthening. Any names you would like to see added in particular? What would you think about an Onuoha - Toure partnership in the absence of Vincent Kompany?

Wallace Reply I believe an Onuoha - Toure partnership is serviceable and Onuoha is growing on me more and more. As a group, and let me stress as a group, it can be argued that City have the best strikers and midfielders in the Premier League while obviously there are individuals at the top clubs which are much better. As a group our defenders are maybe top ten.

I believe that Hughes needs to go outside the Premier League to find central defending talent.

Posted by patrick on 08/07/2009

i have to agree that formation is probably the best, tho petrov is back to form and robinho looked like hes not changed and gives up almost. steve irieland tho is at the moment the best medfielder in the premiership. when he goes off the team just drops a gear he reminds me of roy keane!!!! ben haim was dreadful and just id and always will be. bridge tho had the worst game, he was attacking too much thus putting imense pressure on a new central defensive pairing, which i think played well dunne is getting back to form he just needs time to gel with kolo!

Posted by sani on 08/07/2009

city better be in top 4 finish this season with the squad that they inherit

Posted by locco on 08/10/2009

wallace i really doubt dunne can recapture his performance again..may be patnering kolo with kompany can bring stability in defence.by the way can zabaleta play as cb?i think micah can make RB as his position.

  Post your comment
Name:
Email Address:
Comments:
characters left
About
Wallace Poulter Wallace Poulter is an award winning video game producer, designer, industry consultant and writer. He has been a football fanatic since the day he moved in next door to Brian Clough. "Cloughie" being the acknowledged genius that he was promptly moved out and went to manage Derby. A serviceable senior school left-back in his youth, Poulter played one season of Sunday league football as a striker proving conclusively that he was a serviceable senior school left-back! Today Poulter remains involved with football as a licensed referee and most recently as a consultant on a Football MMO.

RSS feed

Categories
Recent Posts
Archives