ESPN Soccernet - Correspondents - Manchester City
soccernet blog
Manchester City
Posted by Wallace Poulter on 07/12/2009

I've got a sneaking suspicion that City are going to end up with John Terry. I can't give you a specific reason, just this nagging feeling. So let me go on record before it happens. I think this is a really bad idea.

Let me also quantify this. I understand, or at least I believe I understand, what Mark Hughes is looking to accomplish with the signing. It is a statement of intent.

Terry is the England Captain. He is, when playing at his best, probably the best English defender in the Premier League and it shows that players whom are considered "world class" will come to Eastlands. John Terry would be a fundamental building block in getting from where the club is now to where it wants to be over the next four years.

And I still don't like it.

The guy strikes me as a punk. Always has. From his antics after the 9/11 attacks to the nightclub incident I've found the Chelsea captain to be boorish in the extreme. I have a good Chelsea supporting acquaintance who is thoroughly embarrassed that Terry is captain of both Chelsea and his country.

Again I understand the logic. Mark Hughes has set out with a specific agenda and the need, in his mind, to change the culture at the club. Let's not be in any doubt, if the club doesn't finish in the top six in the upcoming season then Hughes is gone as the manager. Certainly I want City to win, to make the Champions League and finally give United a run for their money. While the new found financial strength allows the club to buy the players that it identifies, this is still Manchester City.

Chief Executive Garry Cook gave an interesting interview the other day where he talked about trying to get rid of two phrases. Those are "Typical City" and "City Till I Die."

Now I like Cook, a lot. Football is a big business and his vision for City as a brand worldwide is the kind of forward thinking that is rarely seen at most clubs. There are tremendous opportunities to expand City's appeal and Cook is the man to accomplish this. In particular the new City website is said to offer free radio broadcasts of the games when the season starts which is a fabulous way to start such outreach.

However I also think Cook got it spectacularly wrong when it comes to those two phases. Here's what Cook said in the Manchester Evening News

"`Typical City' says to me `We're not very good, but it's OK.' It means you are embarrassed by mistakes - you shouldn't be, because we all make mistakes.

"It's also an excuse for when you do make a mistake - you can just say `Well, that's us.'

"And 'City `til I die' seems to mean the fans have been through the pain and the agony and were all getting on a bit.

"To build for the future you want eight-year-old kids saying 'I want to play for City' because that helps everything. He doesn't want to think about dying, because he's just got here!"

Wrong on both accounts. Typical City is an expression that conveys that things are always strange around City. This is true both positively and negatively. Typical City is City going 2-0 down to Gillingham before storming back in the last 5 minutes in one of the most amazing roller coaster moments of all time. Typical City is also going 3-0 down to Spurs in the Cup, having Joey Barton sent off and losing Nicolas Anelka to injury before storming back for a 4-3 victory in quite possibly the greatest cup reversal in history. Neither was a "mistake" nor an "excuse." Good or bad, City will find the least traveled way to get there. That's what Typical City means.

City 'til i die doesn't mean that the fans are getting on a bit. This is about passion, about history. About being proud that you have picked the club for the proper reasons not jumped on the bandwagon of popularity ala United, Chelsea and their ilk. You have 14 year olds saying CTID. Because it means a commitment to the club. There's a tendency in the UK press to be knee jerk anti American, you see this often with the Liverpool owners for example. But here is one case where coming from the US has blinded Cook to the realities of how support of a club works in England.

Go to a sporting event in the US, anything from the NFL, to Major League Baseball, NHL and even college basketball and what is missing is the intense passion that Football generates. Yes fans are into their teams, just not as deeply as English football fans. Run the tape of the Gillingham game when Dickov scored and see the reaction of fans. I defy anyone to find a tape of any fans in the US, even the Cameron Crazies at Duke University, that matches that intensity of delirium.

Many years ago my Grandfather gave me a book. It was Eric Thornton's Meredith to Mercer that charted the storied history of City and was one of the primary reasons that I became a City fan. If he hasn't already I'd suggest Garry Cook read it.

Football clubs have souls. Yes that's a quaint notion, especially in today's world of big business. I'm not naive; nor however am I so practical that I am blind to the heart of the club. Typical City and CTID are about our past, our present and our future. It is about the magic of the club, that indefinable something that binds the supporters together. It's about character, of style, of doing things the right way... the City way. We'll have ups and downs, because that is indeed Typical City, but for most of us we wouldn't want it any other way. And we'll embrace players from the newest academy arrival to the biggest superstar if they embody that spirit.

Does John Terry? I rather doubt it.

Comments

Posted by bluenosectid on 07/12/2009

Great article.

Sums up why I'm a City fan.

As for JT, I get the feeling that, more than any of the new signings, he would be the one that was least able to gel as part of a unit that were looking out for each other. I don't care how good the player is as an individual; if they don't add to the team I don't want them. Obviously, a lot of that is down to the manager and we have to trust him to chase his own identified targets, but it worries me.

Posted by Stan on 07/12/2009

Wallace,

I'm from America, and I fully understand both "Typical City" and "City Til I Die." ManCity is capable of anything - from dropping a cup tie to a team a couple of divisions down to knocking off ManUnited at OT in a match played on a historic date for the Red Devils. "They did WHAT???"

And you're right: Cook's comments on CTOD show a lack of recognition of the passion. He should know better, given the fans of American football who are buried in the jersey shirts of their favorite teams, complete with coffins showing the emblems of the Green Bay Packers or Denver Broncos.

I understand your hesitancy about Terry going to City, but you have it right when you say this scenario is about Hughes showing his intent for the future of the club. Until somebody like Terry goes, other big-name players will still consider City a second-tier destination. Robinho's a world-class talent, but he's viewed by the footballing elite as an impetuous flake - not a trend-setter.

Posted by Chris on 07/12/2009

You couldn't be more right about the phrases Wallace. I grew up going to Maine Rd before I moved to America and City Till I Die for me means no matter where I am I'll always feel a part of the club and the club a part of me. It's about a bond that will remain with me till I die it's not negative in anyway but an expression of pride and life long commitment to a club I cherish.

Been enjoying the frequent posts during the summer as well, Thanks Wallace!!!

Posted by Martin Nazimek on 07/13/2009

Great article Wallace. I truly agree with everything you say except JT. Even though he would be hard to fit in with our squad his leadership on and off the pitch would prove vital. It would also send a message to everyone in the league as well as the world as to what we are doing. He would be part of a puzzle piece. Plus not to mention that it would weaken Chelsea a lot. You are killing 2 birds with one stone here. I would be all for it. Though as I have always said, it will be about how the manager manages the team and how they play is going to take us places not who signs and how we look on paper. Here in Detroit we know what it is to look good on paper and I dont want the same for City. CTID

Posted by steve on 07/13/2009

good read

I’m from America. I don’t understand Cook’s comments because when I think of “City Till I Die” it’s a slogan of passion for the club. As for Terry I don’t understand why City is casing an older defender. Lescott from Everton would be a good fit for the club. City should focus of defense once they sign Tevez. As for your shot on America sports I do fill that some sporting events like NHL, MLB lack the intensity of EPL. But is hard to compare some NFL Teams at that level because there is a passion for their team like no other. As for Cameron Crazies remark it’s hard to compare 9,500 indoor fans to 40,000 or more screaming EPL fans. You get lost because of the numbers alone but the excitement and enthusiasm is on the same level.

Posted by justin on 07/13/2009

i work in college athletics in america and i have been to european "football" games...i sit in awe of both for different reasons, but how can one misrepresent a phrase like CTID. A fan to the core...the heart...the soul. You will carry the team with you beyond the grave. Cook missed the boat on that one, but I would not blame it on being American. Like everyoen else i'm torn on the JT issue. While a captain for Chelsea, i believe he cause more problems then he fixes. Running Scolari (even if it was needed)..he may have too much control, and view the City move as a chance to run a team. A class player that I would love to see paired up with Lescott or Upson if possible....NO MORE STIKERS PLEASE!

Posted by Jon Lock on 07/13/2009

Gareth Barry, Roque Santa Cruz and now Carlos Tevez... thre signings that highlight the sense that something big, bold and exciting is starting to manifest itself in East Manchester.

These are all highly regarded international players however none would have the same impact globally as the England captain signing his name on the sky blue dotted line.

Whilst Gary Cook may not fully understand what City means to a blue Mancunian (he is after all a Birmingham City fan) the policy that he is following, delivering what the owners and Mark Hughes want, is gradually building a team capable of challenging for honours on a consistent basis and the signing of Terry would not only stabilise the defence but would be a sit up and take notice marquee signing, a statement of intent that would reverberate across the world.

Posted by jon on 07/13/2009

I have been watching City for 6 years now, since Claudio Reyna joined the club. I've never had the chance to go to a live game for City, so I can't say I feel the same passion that the supporters do. But watch a City game on TV (and I've looked up countless old matches as well, from the 5-1 over United to the playoff match against Gills) and there's a reason that I can say I love the club. I love passion and I feel that when watching City, and I hope I can go to the CoMS and take my children there one day.

Awesome article! Thoroughly enjoyed it!

Posted by Patrick Ong on 07/14/2009

Somehow, whenever City is a goal up, I just feel that it aint enough. Many times, they end up conceding soft goals and end up dropping vital points.

They spent years trying to have a good keeper and finally found one in Shay Given.

In midfield, they have Gareth Barry and Stephen Ireland which should form a good backbone.

In attack, they have loads of options. With Santa Cruz, they should have more goals through headers and set pieces.

The only weak link seems to be the defence. I dont know what happen to Richard Dunne and Micah Richards last season. They are simply not 100% dependable. City really needs a world class defender to complete the team. John Terry's quality and commitment is undoubted and he will surely solve a huge chunk of City's defence problems. If City cant get him, they should consider Vidic, Kolo Toure, Hangeland or Matthew Upson.

Posted by Luke on 07/14/2009

Just watched clips of the games you mentioned. I can't wait for my new kit to arrive.

Luke from TX, USA

  Post your comment
Name:
Email Address:
Comments:
characters left
About
Wallace Poulter Wallace Poulter is an award winning video game producer, designer, industry consultant and writer. He has been a football fanatic since the day he moved in next door to Brian Clough. "Cloughie" being the acknowledged genius that he was promptly moved out and went to manage Derby. A serviceable senior school left-back in his youth, Poulter played one season of Sunday league football as a striker proving conclusively that he was a serviceable senior school left-back! Today Poulter remains involved with football as a licensed referee and most recently as a consultant on a Football MMO.

RSS feed

Categories
Recent Posts
Archives