ESPN Soccernet - Correspondents - Manchester City
soccernet blog
Manchester City
Posted by Wallace Poulter on 07/06/2009

The phrase lull before the storm is an over used one at the best of times, but I don't think I'm the only one who has the sense of impending madness. All indications are that Carlos Tevez will finally make his oft talked about move and the chatter continues about Samuel Eto'o and John Terry with occasional Joleon Lescott murmurings! Love the bit in The Sun that says that Mark Hughes and Terry were in the same hotel for their holidays. That will keep the conspiracy theories going for at least another week.

As we kick around the need for new defenders one question does come to mind. Just how much better will Nedum Onuoha be this year? The presumption, and I have been as guilty as anyone of this, is that we need to being in a great central defender to partner with Vincent Kompany in the middle of defense. But the more I look at the England U21 International the more I believe that one of the solutions is already at the club. Onuoha's combination of height, speed and strength is an excellent one. I've also wondered that if a Terry or someone similar joins the club, would Onuoha be tried at Left Back, a position he is capable of playing.

With Pablo Zapaleta, Micah Richards, Vincent Kompany and Onuoha I'm not sure the club is as deficient in the defensive department as we keep telling ourselves, but rather that the correct combination has not been found. The Richard Dunne who played recently against Bulgaria is well worth keeping. The Richard Dunne who has played for City for the last 18 months is not. Hence the club's search.

Last year was a lost year in many ways for Richards, but he was one of the hottest young players in the league prior to last season. Again the system of Sven had a lot to do with that when the England International made the switch to central defender. The Richards of three years ago is better than an 18 million Glen Johnson.

Felipe Caicedo, Ched Evans and Gelson Fernandes are all being discussed as players leaving the club. I've never been sold on Fernandes, while Evans strikes me as a good striker with a bright future, but one that should probably be at the Championship level for a season or two. His game can grow significantly from that first team football, but I don't think we would regret selling either player.

Caicedo on the other hand is a player that with some maturation could be a useful battering ram center forward. There is a shortage of those in the world, specifically in the English game, and there are games and situations where that is exactly the player that you want on your team or in your squad. It's one of the reasons, as bizarre as it sounds, that I've always thought that Kevin Davies should get a run out in an England shirt. Against some of the smaller international nations you need that route one brute force rather than the sophistication of a superstar. Therefore I'd prefer to see Caicedo leave on loan giving the club the option to hold onto the player if his development continues. At only age 20, he will not reach his prime for at least a half dozen years and it's better to develop our own players long term than the buy buy buy mentality which is understandable in the short term, but is realistically unsustainable.

Loyal readers will recall the suggestion I made in January that if the club really wanted RSC then they might look to offer over the odds for the Blackburn striker and his central defender colleague Christopher Samba who would provide some quality for the club. Flash forward some six months and I see that for the first time we are now being linked with the Congo international.

Elsewhere... City's former longest serving player, a certain Joey Barton, is reportedly being chased by Birmingham. Barton, who missed the turn off for the last chance saloon about 5 miles back, somehow keeps popping up. I suspect Birmingham are being lulled by their successful Lee Bowyer reclamation project, but if you want the definition of pressure that Premier League managers are under then this is it. The bottom line is that Barton is better than the players Birmingham currently have and that apparently is good enough. April 10th for those of you that are curious is when Birmingham come to visit. Even if this goes through anyone taking bets on Barton still being with them by then?

And finally... I read a fair number of articles each day. I was very surprised last September when Martin Samuel left The Times to go work for the Daily Mail. Sort of the equivalent of trading in Rachel Weisz for Jade Goody. Samuel, a previous Sports Journalist of the Year, has been an oasis of hope in an otherwise fairly dismal daily read. But check out his article today on the Federer vs. Roddick Wimbledon final. Yes, it's Tennis; doesn't matter. Sports writing at its absolute best. If you read one non football article today, read that one. Sheer class.

Comments

Posted by lex on 07/06/2009

I'm not sure what to think of Caicedo.

He wasn't too bad last season. He scored 8 goals, and he's only 20. If he improves, then I think he would be a solid player, who would probably average 15 goals a season.

But from what I've seen of him, he never seems to want to shoot. I haven't been able to watch a lot of city games, but my impression is that he seems to wait for opportunities rather than creating them. I see Santa Cruz, Bellamy, Bojinov, and Tevez all lashing shots towards goal when given half a chance. Caicedo doesn't seem to have that same appetite.

That said, I think he did enough last season to warrant a place in the squad.

I also feel the club should hang on to Bojinov. We've had precious little to judge him by, but from what we've seen I think he could be a 20 goal striker, no problem. His measured goal against Tottenham revealed a level of class which is worth exploring.

Regardless, this season promises to be really interesting.

Posted by AlexC83 on 07/06/2009

I've championed nedum's cause as much as anyone cos he will be the best centre back in the country because you miss out one huge attribute in his locker: intelligence. He will be a better defender than terry in the long run so long as he stays fit. I've even said he should be given the armband now if/when dunne leaves.

This reasoning has led me to suggest we actually only need one defender - whether that's lescott or, as is now crazily suggested, terry. We only need one though cos nedum must play and kompany (and even richards) can provide centre back cover.

I didn't initially want terry for such an outlay but I have realised that if we did somehow get him then it'd be amazing: a terry & onuoha partnership would be the best in the league...

Posted by justin on 07/06/2009

Nedum is a class player, i feel city are in that awkward stage of wanting to bring in proven talent against the up and coming talent that we have. It would be easy to say three to five years ago that we would love the wealth of young talent we have, now we can't find them games. gelson has always looked like he is chasing and frankly was questionable. losing a talent like sturridge was big, but i also don't want a kid like that demanding money right now. ched is a brilliant championship striker, i don't know if he will be more then that. if it weren't for ireland's year last year we may be talking about him the same way. i've even read articles where he is fighting for his spot.

Posted by MIchael on 07/07/2009

I couldn't agree more with the comments. Nedum and Micah are two of the best up and coming Defenders in the country and partnered with some class and experience such as Vincent Kompany i think that City have a great base to work with. my main concern is that Vincent Kompany continues to play in the holding position and that Richard Dunne keeps his place in the team. Im not sold on Wayne Bridge he still looks uncomfortable on his right and isn't a long term solution to the left back position. As for Fernandes and Caicedo i think there future lies elsewhere and i must state my disappointment that Daniel Sturridge has left the club, even with all the big name stirkers arriving shorely City could see he was one for the future. I have no doubt in my mind he will don the England shirt in the same way Theo has.

Posted by CK on 07/08/2009

City's former longest serving player, a certain Joey Barton

HAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHHAHAHAHAHAHA

  Post your comment
Name:
Email Address:
Comments:
characters left
About
Wallace Poulter Wallace Poulter is an award winning video game producer, designer, industry consultant and writer. He has been a football fanatic since the day he moved in next door to Brian Clough. "Cloughie" being the acknowledged genius that he was promptly moved out and went to manage Derby. A serviceable senior school left-back in his youth, Poulter played one season of Sunday league football as a striker proving conclusively that he was a serviceable senior school left-back! Today Poulter remains involved with football as a licensed referee and most recently as a consultant on a Football MMO.

RSS feed

Categories
Recent Posts
Archives