Good. John Terry isn't coming. No need to repeat my reasoning from columns past, but long term I believe we will look back and consider ourselves fortunate that we didn't sign the Chelsea captain to a five year deal. The off season has seen the club, other than the Eto'o flirtation, target established Premier League stars. Fairly transparently this is because Hughes doesn't have any more time. He has to achieve the top six target of the Chairman and as such has little time for players from other leagues to find their feet.
It used to be said that it took foreign players 18 months to get up to speed in the Premier League. Players such as Torres and Elano have clouded that assertion in recent years, however they remain the exception rather than the rule. Balancing the short term verses the long term stability of the club is a huge challenge for a manager with so much pressure on him.
But that being said I think it is time for the club to look abroad in its search for new central defenders. Vidic is never going to leave United for City, Terry has finally passed and Lescott remains a dubious choice. At this point name a great central defender in the Premier League. They are very thin on the ground. Toure may be useful enough I suppose. Duran Duran's inspiration has stated he would never come to City which is great because the fans would never want such a player at the club.
There was a method to Sven's madness in putting Micah Richards in the centre of defense and getting him to learn the position. Creating a potentially very good player at the position from within the club would have been a masterstroke. Again for reasons I've discussed previously around the manager's tactics the centre of defense was no longer the right role for Richards. There are youngsters in the pipeline such as Ben Mee and Ryan McGivern but there is no indication that either is a world beater.
Time methinks for Hughes' well won reputation for spotting talent in the Bundesliga to come to the fore. Naldo at Werder Bremen for example is a player that has struck me as useful.
Elsewhere... I have been bemused by Old Purple Nose this week. He rather seems to have lost the plot when it comes to City and seems to have let them get under his skin. The quite brilliant Welcome to Manchester Carlos Tevez poster in particular seems to have rattled the United manager in a manner more befitting a Keegan or Benitez outburst.
If City were inconsequential Ferguson would not be saying anything but the fact that the club is constantly brought up tends you to believe that there is genuine concern at United that a shift is occurring. Now of course City have a long long way to go before the club is a consistent challenger for silverware. Nonetheless, it would appear a nerve has been struck.
You may consider it wishful thinking but I believe there is a good chance that United will struggle this year. The lose of Tevez and Ronaldo is going to impact the squad regardless of the reinforcements brought in. That being said I feel the Premier League will be an incredibly tight race with all four main clubs in a close battle. I do not believe that City will break into the top four, but top six is reasonable if the defense is addressed.
I'll have more when I do my season preview but Sunderland, of all teams, are one to keep an eye on. Some very good acquisitions so far this summer. If you want a surprise team to pull a Wigan/Reading/Fulham I have a sneaking suspicion that the Black Cats could be it.
Comments
 |
Posted by Jarrod on 07/27/2009
I don't even think Manchester united will hit top 2 this year, i have them finishing third. If you consider the other times they sold significant players, how did they go following seasons? all i remember was they didn't win anything for a little amount of time when they sold David Beckham. Same deal this season i reckon.
On the issue of central defenders, time better hurry up for mark hughes to pull his socks up for a central defender, heres a hint/cliche from my coaching experience!! DEFENCE WINS CHAMPIONSHIPS, OFFENCE SELLS TICKETS.
 |
Posted by AlexC83 on 07/27/2009
So you're completely ignoring the emergence of Nedum Onuoha under Hughes last season? Kompany can move into the backline too. So we only need one new centre back unless dunne wants to leave.
Naldo's a good shout though, we need an imposing centre back.
Wallace Reply Even with the emergence of Onuoha last season the club still shipped goals at an alarming rate. Kompany played mainly in central defense for Hamburg so an Onuoha-Kompany central defense partnership is not out of the question once Kompany recovers from his injury. It would be very nice if that was the solution, I agree. Just not confident it is.
 |
Posted by Stan Finger on 07/27/2009
I'm relieved Terry isn't coming to City. I'm concerned that he would be declining as a player within the next two years, and struggle to shut down opponents with pace.
I agree that Hughes needs to work some of his Blackburn magic in finding strong defenders from the Bundesliga or perhaps the Eredivisie.
 |
Posted by Justin on 07/28/2009
It now seems that Kolo is on his way...not thrilled, but an athletic player to squeeze into the mold, I feel he will be more part of the committee of center backs rather then a stalwart part of it. Another rumour that I heard was Phillip Mexes...an above-average defender at best on a team that had more holes in the defense than City did last year. I agree that Germany has produced many defenders and even someone like a Nevan Subotic could be a great fit. Still, and it has been said, why not Carvalho from Chelsea instead of Terry?
Wallace Reply I think Carvalho, if he would join, would be an inspired short term choice.
 |
Posted by Prof.wanyama wilberforce on 07/29/2009
i think man city have strenghened so much this season.the question is in defence.i dont think Toure can be a perfect person there given his decline in form.Vidic is super there, then we break into the big 4.wait for fire next year,
Posted by Om on 07/30/2009
I don't understand why Hughes spent so much on Forwards while the defence had been the major problem last season. I would advise him to try and get David Beckam in City, if possible. it would be greatest boost to the club and I am sure David would also be happy man.
Wallace Reply I'm generally a fan of Beckham, but I don't see what he would bring to the table for City other than free kicks. Stephen Ireland would keep him out of any City side at the moment.
| |
Post your comment |
 |
|