ESPN Soccernet - Correspondents - Manchester City
soccernet blog
Manchester City
Posted by Wallace Poulter on 06/16/2009

All quiet on the signing front. Lots of newspaper speculation, but nothing of substance coming out of the club. I take this as a positive and hope that the team is plotting a swift move in a similar fashion to the Gareth Barry acquisition.

Glen Johnson is apparently heading for Liverpool and I've yet to see a shred of evidence that there was ever a possibility that he might come to City. Joleon Lescott is again linked and he's another that I'm not sure about.

Such a signing would certainly have a negative impact on Everton and would in principal upgrade the position. However for a variety of reasons I took an in depth look at the England defender over the course of a number of matches these past couple of seasons. There were games where Lescott played very well and certainly in attack he was a very effective weapon. However defensively I was not impressed feeling that his positioning was suspect and there was a tendency to play an opponent onside or get the wrong side of a attacker. Frankly I think we should take a pass even if we are considering him.

Roque Santa Cruz is yet another that continues to be linked. Fair enough but I can't get excited about him until he's played another season injury free. Johnson's Portsmouth and England team mate Peter Crouch has also had his named attached to City. Yet another in a long line of players Rafa shouldn't have let leave Liverpool, Crouch isn't your stereotypical centre forward but I've always liked him.

Not a bad player in the bunch but honestly pretty underwhelming. Gareth Barry takes the club forward; so would Tevez. Would Johnson, Lescott, Santa Cruz or Crouch be a significant upgrade over who we have currently? I don't think so. Or to put it another way would any of those four start for Liverpool, Arsenal, United or Chelsea? Exactly. Barry and Tevez meet that criteria. Quality not quantity is what the club needs.

And let me throw another name into the mix. Nicholas Anelka. If Tevez were to go to Chelsea then Anelka would probably be the odd man out. Anelka had a terrible reputation as "Le Sulk" when he came to City yet there wasn't a single negative incident with him. He played well, scored goals and was a quality addition. Further he's the type of forward that is always making runs forward. That he gets called offside so much is more a function of a lack of vision from his midfield than an inherent problem with his play. And what do City do as well as anyone in the Premier League? Make intelligent passes to players running into position. Anelka... Now that would be an upgrade.

Comments

Posted by Jim on 06/16/2009

The Anelka proposition is an interesting one but I have never liked him. Maybe he is so good that it appears as if he is lazy but it often comes across like he doesn't have his head in the game. He is the EPL version of Trezeguet and often disappears in big games. Now if you're talking about upgrading the striker position, how about Zlatan Ibrahimovich? He's tired of Serie A and I have always been a fan of his since his Juve days...

Posted by Andrew Hermiz on 06/20/2009

As everyone knows, our main problem is defense. We have midfielders that are very willing to track back and defend, Ireland, SWP, De Jong all frequently defend nicely but what we really need is a solid back four. I like Richards and Bridge but we have a serious issue with the center backs and I know everyone seems to be a Richard Dunne fan but I frankly am not. He has had many good seasons with City but this past one was not at all. He had 2 red cards and 2 own goals that were not only embarrassing but disastrous for the team. We need a solid center back that will anchor the defense and give our offense confidence to push because when our offense is firing on all cylinders it is really a thing of beauty. We have a great ability to score but we just need to allow less goals. I would feel bad to lose Dunne but it must happen at this point and he would be an upgrade for many other teams in the EPL.

  Post your comment
Name:
Email Address:
Comments:
characters left
About
Wallace Poulter Wallace Poulter is an award winning video game producer, designer, industry consultant and writer. He has been a football fanatic since the day he moved in next door to Brian Clough. "Cloughie" being the acknowledged genius that he was promptly moved out and went to manage Derby. A serviceable senior school left-back in his youth, Poulter played one season of Sunday league football as a striker proving conclusively that he was a serviceable senior school left-back! Today Poulter remains involved with football as a licensed referee and most recently as a consultant on a Football MMO.

RSS feed

Categories
Recent Posts
Archives