|
|
 |
|
Boos filled the air as Phil Dowd signalled the end of another disappointing showing from Hull City. Saturday's 1-0 defeat to Birmingham sent shock-waves around East Yorkshire, and gave new ammunition to a vocal minority of anti-Brown activists.
While the dissenting voices are surely premature, their sentiments are starting to have an air of reason. Brown's men started slowly, and never really found their rhythm at any stage of what was in reality a very winnable game. Like the game against Bolton, this game was one from the mini league of teams who are likely to be in the relegation mix-up at the end of the season. That City seemed to lack a real desire, more than a lack of quality, is a real cause for concern.
The stilted performance does have its mitigating circumstances. A new side takes time to gel, and City had three new partnerships down the spine of the side. The centre half pairing of Zayatte and Sonko at least looked more solid and organised than the second half shambles at Sunderland, and the partnership will surely improve further with time. Marney and Olofinjana had only played together for half an hour prior to Saturday. Both showed glimpses of potential, but lost the midfield battle as Birmingham cleverly overcrowded the central third of the pitch. A strange pairing up front saw the very raw looking Altidiore paired with Jan Vennegoor of Hesselink. Both were making their league starting debuts for the Tigers, and understandably found it difficult to link up with the other. Either of the physical front men would surely prosper from playing alongside a pacier colleague. Ghlias will surely start up front at Anfield next Saturday.
Give Birmingham their due. The Blues produced a compact, efficient performance that was very reminiscent of City's better away days from last season. It was class smash and grab raid, as the visitors frustrated the Tigers and threatened on the break through the impressive Christian Benitez, whose pace troubled the City backline constantly. The towering Gary O'Conner was thrown on late in the game, and his presence brought the winning goal from a corner, a goal that in truth had been coming as the game wore on. Had it not been for an excellent performance from Myhill, the defeat could have taken on an even more depressing look.
But the game is gone now. City can't be much worse than they were on Saturday, and Brown will surely have his troops fired up for first a potentially interesting Carling Cup clash with Everton, and then a trip to play the red half of Merseyside on the Saturday. The manager is starting to come under pressure from the Tigers fans, whom on the face of it probably should have more patience. It should not be forgotten the great strides the club has made under Brown, and this in itself means he has earned the right to be given a chance to turn the recent performances around. This new look City side needs a few games to find its feet. After the Liverpool game next week comes a run of very winnable games.
The time to judge Brown is at the end of October. By then we will have a far better idea of where our season is heading, and Duffen will have some justification in taking action if he feels it is needed. I for one am confident that such action will not be needed.
Is Brown living on borrowed time? I'd love to hear your views.
TC
Comments
 |
Posted by Garreth Ellyard on 09/20/2009
Tom collins,
You have writtern a very intresting artical.
I want to ask you a few things on brown:
(1) Do you think anyone else would keep their job after 2 wins in 28 games (mot including pre season)so why should brown.
(2) name one player that has left since Brown has been in charge of city. He even had a go at Folan.
(3) He is always keen to blame everyone apart from himself, he always says how weak the defence in so why get rid of Turner after he signed a four year contract?. I think duffen had a part in this but Brown could of said no.
(4) I think he is losing the plot for example making Sonko team captain he has no leadership in the squad because he is a new player like Maccca the week before, why is this?
(5) His tactics arnt working, the team was playing long ball and it did not work at all, Yet he does not change them.
Brown has gone as far as he can with our club it is time for him to go before its to late.
Iv been a fan for 24 yrs and want city to do well.
 |
Posted by Garreth Ellyard on 09/20/2009
I mean to say for (2) do you know any playeer that has left city while brown has been in charge and said one good thing about him (Brown).
Sorry
 |
Posted by David Troppens on 09/21/2009
He may or may not be on borrowed time. I don't suggest to know the answer to that being I am a new fan, and one that's in the U.S at that. My guess is that much of the talk about the formation or player decision issues with Hull probably aren't the reason for its struggles. My guess is that much of what Hull is dealing with has to do with the struggles of quickly growing to this level of competition. From what I've been able to learn about Hull, finding talent at this level hasn't come easy. I don't see that being their fault. It seems a tough transition, especially for an organization that has never experienced this level in its history. A strong finish, and knowing weeks in advance that relegation wasn't an issue, would've helped convince others that Hull was ready to take the next step. However, it didn't happen and it made for a tough offseason. Adjusting may be an issue. I can see that. However, it isn't a luxury this team has. I hope Hull can recover, but I see it won't be easy.
 |
Posted by David Troppens on 09/21/2009
By the way Tom, I appreciate your articles. Please keep them coming. I find them helpful in learning about my adopted team from England. And I enjoy your positive, yet still very realistic outlook. Keep up the good work.
 |
Posted by Mike on 09/21/2009
TC, one typo: Christian Benitez, not Christina. Or you can just call him "Chucho".
 |
Posted by Mike on 09/21/2009
I disagree with you that City "seemed to lack a real desire." I don't see how you can fault their effort. They were all over midfield chasing and winning balls; they applied pressure from the start and were applying pressure when the whistle blew.
I think the problem rather is that Brown is yet to start the 4-5-1 with someone other than Folan or Fagan at its top. Hull needs that fifth midfielder: without him we've been trounced by Spurs and couldn't even draw Birmingham at home.
All of our best play this year has come with the 4-5-1 formation. Witness Geo coming on for Cousin vs. Spurs, what followed was the only promising minutes for Hull. And I would argue the best half hour of football Hull has shown all year came vs. Bolton when Hull played a 4-5-1 with someone up top not named Folan.
Now that PB has 2 better strikers, just put 1 up top, but not both. Geo, Ghilas and Hunt can threaten from midfield--entering this week, Hull were one of the higher-scoring sides.
 |
Posted by Juan on 09/22/2009
I don't think Hull played a 4-5-1 when they played Bolton. If I remember correctly, Ghilas, Folan, and Jozy played in the game and all are forwards. Two of them were on the field for most of the game if not all of it. It was great when Ghilas and Jozy were together, magical. Vennegoor is quality, but either he needs to be uptop alone with midfielders who can fly and distribute, or as Tom states, put him with a speedy strike partner. Jozy isn't slow, but I don't think he is the top 10% of speedsters in the EPL. He has sweet moves though and when he wants it he can do beautiful things. I would say put Ghilas and Vennegoor up top together for the next few games with Jozy coming on as a sub.
As a fellow American, I want to see Jozy succeed. He needs to stay hungry and be put in situations to succeed. Hull is a great place for him, but they need to stay up for his loan to become permanent. Hunt and Geo are good attacking midfielders, but I think Ghilas is better for attacking.
 |
Posted by Russ on 09/22/2009
I also agree that a 4-5-1 formation could work, and I think especially with Jozy up top.
| |
Post your comment |
 |
|
|
|
|
About
Welcome to my new blog. I've been watching Hull City for over ten years now, and have seen the club rise from a lower league laughing stock, locked out of their own ground, to Premier League upstarts turning over Arsenal at the Emirates. Hopefully you'll find my views on the Tigers interesting, so feel free to join the debate. Come on you Hull! |
Categories
Recent Posts
Archives
|