ESPN Soccernet - Correspondents - Everton
soccernet blog
Everton
Posted by Jack Dowden on 04/07/2011

Camera's in football were last weekends top two talking points, unfortunately the main focus of the media's attention was on Wayne Rooney's mind-boggling lack of class and limited grasp of his native tongue. Playing second fiddle to the mouth of England's most gifted footballer was a further example for those that argue for the introduction of "Goal line technology".

Everton were the latest victim of human error, as Jermaine Beckford's thunderous drive smashed the underside of the bar to apparently nuzzle the right side of the goal line before bouncing back in the direction of a grateful Brad Friedel. Admittedly this instance did not have the shocking obviousness of Frank Lampard's plum effort against Germany at last year's World Cup nor was it as blatant at Pedro Mendes's wonder lob at Old Trafford for Spurs. The only similarity the three have is they went into that little rectangular shape behind the respective Goalkeeper, albeit briefly.

Every time this happens, there seems to be huge debate about the introduction of very intricate technology placed around the goal mouth to assist referees with these difficult decisions. FIFA, or Sepp Blatter to be more accurate, have little to no interest in pursuing this an option, citing that it would spoil the uncertainty of football, which in part I agree, however in FIFA's language you can loosely translate that as "it's going to cost too much and will not make us any money", having seen the FIFA machine in action in South Africa in person last year, I can tell you, they are about profit, not the love of the game.

As I have said, I do agree that the professional game should still embody the core values of a Sunday League match at the local park or a school playground favourite of Jumpers for Goalposts. However due to the importance and power of money in today's football I understand that advances are essential to its future and gaining interest in recently tapped markets, essentially Asia and the US.

When a "legitimate" goal is not given there could be massive financial implications to the team involved. Everton ended up drawing on Saturday against Aston Villa, if the goal had stood, that would have possibly been enough to secure a win. From where I was sitting on Saturday the officials can be forgiven for missing it such was the venom in Beckford's strike, blink and you missed it (dependent on how slowly you blink you may have missed Darren Bent's goal for the Villains moments later). An additional 2 points may not seem a lot as we try our best to salvage a disappointing season , essentially though for others, it could be the difference between winning a league title for those at the top or relegation for those at the bottom, which was the case for Bolton in 1998, ironically against Everton who survived on the last day at the Trotters expense.

Many organisations and pundits have tried to offer solutions to this problem, I believe the main problem is that it doesn't happen enough to warrant in depth research. Football doesn't require the Hawkeye system embraced in Cricket and Tennis, where the margin of error is so acute for foul serves or LBW's. Rugby's TV Referee is the simplest and most cost effective option, if I can see it on Match of the Day, someone sitting in a room with a Television screen and link to the on field officials can see it too. The main argument against this is that it would delay play, but as I stated earlier this scenario doesn't happen very often and it would be a quick yes or no from the sidelines. Much quicker than Didier Drogba, for example, rolling around on the floor after a challenge clutching his face, checking for non-existent traces of blood and waiting for a physio and stretcher to tend to him (even that sentence took longer to write than it would to get a decision).

I know this is a subject that will continue to rumble on, Sepp Blatter has recently insisted that "Goal line technology" will be closely considered for the 2014 World Cup in Brazil, but this is a man on charm offensive as he seeks a 3rd re-election as President of FIFA, I for one, shall not be holding my breath.

On June 12th I am running the 10k Mersey Tunnel Run in aid of Everton in the Community, a wonderful charity offering opportunities to all through Sport, if you would like to sponsor me and support this excellent organisation please click on the link below:
http://www.justgiving.com/Jack-Dowden

To find out more about Everton in the Community and the good work they do, please follow this link:
http://community.evertonfc.com/about-us/

Thanks for reading

Jacko

Follow me on Twitter @jackdoggydogg

Follow ESPNsoccernet's Football Correspondents on Twitter

Comments

Posted by Kyle on 04/07/2011

Goal line technology must be installed. Take baseball for example. Installing instant replay for balls and strikes would be absurd and ridiculous, and would ruin the game, and in that case you can make the "human judgement makes it better" argument fine. However, hitting home runs is a very basic thing. You look at replay, say yes or no, and play on. So they installed it.

With soccer, either its a goal or its not, and its the basis and fundamental goal (no pun intended) of each team: score goals. How can you have human error in that? It's ridiculous that they havent installed it yet. An absolute atrocity by FIFA.

Posted by PJT on 04/09/2011

Screw technology...a slight incline behind the line sloping towards the back of the net would assure that any ball that bounces behind the line would not come back out. This would solve most of the problems...the exception being when a keeper or defender manages to get the ball back out of the goal without it touching the ground (I think Roy Carroll had one of those for United against Spurs a few years back).

Posted by Jeff on 04/11/2011

Kyle, it's either a strike or a ball, just like it's either a goal or not.

  Post your comment
Name:
Email Address:
Comments:
characters left
About
Jack Dowden Jack Dowden - I was around 20 when I realised if I was to pursue my interest in the beautiful game it would probably be best for all involved that I stayed as far away from the pitch as possible. After several years searching for my niche within the game, I stumbled across Blogging, which brings together perfectly my two strengths and passions, English and Football. As the French Philosopher Rene Descartes proclaimed, "I Blog, therefore I am", or words to that effect!

RSS feed

Categories
Recent Posts
Archives