|
|
 |
|
A long, long European season has ended, giving us barely a couple of weeks to recharge our batteries and retune our engines for the World Cup. Mine's a pint of engine oil...
Time then to list my top players of the European season, and compare them to the rankings my selections gained from our friends at the Castrol Rankings. In true Jimmy Savile/Casey Kasem style I shall run through the toppermost of the poppermost in descending order.
Forum: John Brewin v Castrol Rankings – who is right?
10. Gerard Pique - Castrol Ranking 13
Two years ago a Manchester United reserve, now a Rolls Royce of a defender for almost-all-conquering Barcelona. Pique's smooth style and ease on the ball often sees him enter play as an auxiliary attacker, bringing back memories of the likes of Frank Rijkaard and Ruud Krol. His wonderfully-taken strike in the Champions League semi-final with Inter showed misfiring Zlatan Ibrahimovic how it was done too.
9. Wesley Sneijder - Castrol Ranking 97
Real Madrid rejects rather enjoyed themselves this season. Sneijder's playmaking skills were unwanted at the Santiago Bernabeu and Inter were able to pick up a bargain for 15 million euros. In the tightly-woven Mourinho system, Sneijder was the propeller - and sometimes finisher too - of those deadly counter-attacks in the style of Deco at Porto and Lampard at Chelsea.
8. Ivica Olic - Castrol Ranking 10 =
A free-transfer signing for Bayern Munich who was pushing 30, the Croat was perhaps expected to play second fiddle to the far-more pricey Mario Gomez. Yet Olic's enthusiastic style and hard-running endeavour, while not for the aesthetic, were hugely effective, especially in the Champions League, where with his big-match temperament he grabbed two goals against Manchester United and a hat-trick in the semi-final at Lyon.
7. Didier Drogba - Castrol Ranking 3
Once he has the manager's faith in him, he reverts to being a wrecking-ball of a striker. Carlo Ancelotti followed Guus Hiddink in placing an arm round those broad shoulders and was rewarded with 29 goals in 32 Premier League appearances. And, in a tight FA Cup final, Drogba continued his Wembley wizardry with the winner. The copy-book was only blotted by another ill-tempered exit from the Champions League.
6. Cristiano Ronaldo - Castrol Ranking – 2
The £80 million dream was achieved by a move to Real Madrid to precede a season of high achievement, yet perhaps even he will admit he has had better campaigns. Injury played its part at times, but Ronaldo clearly did not always enjoy having to carry dysfunctional Real Madrid. That familiar look of flickering rancour at team-mates often appeared, especially during the Champions League exit to Lyon in which he himself underperformed. And he finished the season potless for the first time since 2005. He will expect better. He always does.
5. Arjen Robben - Castrol Ranking 5
We'll forget those odd celebrations that look like a tribute to Albert Steptoe and remember the quality of a season in which, like Sneijder, he belied his status as a Real cast-off. On his day, those incisive runs off the flank and fierce shooting are devastating and his performances for Bayern far outshone the previously much-more vaunted Franck Ribery.
4. Wayne Rooney - Castrol Ranking 4
He can hardly be said to have been a bit-part player but this was the season that a long-expected potential looked close to being fulfilled at Manchester United. A central role granted him the chance to add goal power and aerial prowess to his armoury and he thus became indispensable to United and England before those injuries derailed what could have been a truly great season.
3. Maicon - Castrol Ranking 86
Inter Milan's treble triumphs were, of course, built on rigid defence and their supreme quartet, with deference to the excellence of midfield lord protector Esteban Cambiasso, is represented by this Brazilian. Those who wonder why Dani Alves does not play too often for Brazil need only watch Maicon, a far better defender but also an attacker of huge quality. See the example of that energetic run and finish against Barcelona. This is the age of the overlapping full back and Maicon is the best around.
2. Diego Milito - Castrol Ranking 86
The Argentine scored the goals that delivered all three of Serie A, Coppa Italia and the Champions League to Inter Milan. Not bad, really, was it? Jose Mourinho raised eyebrows when paying Genoa 25 million euros for a 30-year-old but is now - as ever - smugly proclaiming his own genius after Milito repeatedly showed true mastery of the finisher's art. He is no all-rounder but was the prime match-winner of the European season. The story that Diego Maradona had to be reminded of Milito by one of his coaches when selecting for the World Cup ought to defy belief but, as it's Maradona, it doesn't.
1. Lionel Messi - Castrol Ranking 1
Why deny the obvious child? There were times in the 2009-10 season when it looked as if Messi would surpass the annus mirabilis of his previous term. Perhaps he did. He top-scored in both Spain and the Champions League, making those slaloming runs past helpless defenders and slide-rule finishes almost look routine. Messi scored eight goals in three matches during one week in March, hitting unimpeachable heights. And his recovery from Barca's concession of their European title was to fire seven goals in three games to wrest back the Primera Liga title when his colleagues' nerve looked to be deserting them. Tina Turner had a song about his type.
This blog is brought to you in association with Castrol Rankings
Comments
 |
Posted by wasil on 05/27/2010
roone should be bhind robben and drogba...his season is way too overrated.....
 |
Posted by Eric on 05/27/2010
I can't believe you put Pique in the top 10. Unbelievable that you put him over a defender such as Vidic, Ferdinand, Kolo Toure, Zanetti, Gallas, or Chiellini - much less as the 10th best player in the world.
By your rankings, it seemed you only watched the Champions League this year. Olic, can in no way be compared to the top strikers in the world. He simply got hot in the Champions League. Ribery, his own teammate, is far and away a better player than Olic.
Please watch more than 5 games next year.
 |
Posted by Sheriff Bello on 05/27/2010
I agree more with the castrol ranking which to me is more of a refelection of the performance of these players for their respective clubs in the just concluded season than John Brewins.
 |
Posted by TommyV on 05/27/2010
This is a really stupid list. Not because I don't agree with some choices, but it's just stupid. Who in the world will put Olic in a top 10?
No Fabregas? He's a midfielder who has played 36 times, scored 19 times, and sssited 19 times as well. Had he been playing for Barca, he would easily be recognized as the best midfielder in the world.
No Vermaelen? Milito at no.2? van persie? Torres? No GK?
Really, this is so bad it's almost funny. How can anyone possibly put Olic in a European top 10? He's a good player, but top 10?
 |
Posted by Kevin_Amold on 05/27/2010
Ribery is one of the most overrated players in Europe. He doesn't belong on this list, Olic is far more deserving.
 |
Posted by Borislav Alexiev on 05/27/2010
Olic and Robben better than Frank Lampard? Milito better than Drogba? Did you guys watch the football games at all?
 |
Posted by otownballer3 on 05/27/2010
@ Eric,
John Brewin is completely justified in his inclusion of Pique. How many games have YOU watched this year? Lots? Then you would know that Vidic, Ferdinand, Kolo Toure, Gallas, and Chiellini won zero (0) trophies this year. Because you watched so many games, you are certainly also aware that none of the aforementioned defenders scored a beautiful goal in the Champions League semi-final. And you'd also know that Manchester City weren't even in this season's Champions League and hence have no standing to be on this list!
And because I'm not a complete jerk, I will agree with you that Javier Zanetti probably deserved an honorable mention.
 |
Posted by doug on 05/27/2010
Eric (and a bunch of other people), read the introduction:
"Time then to list my top players of the European season"
This is a ranking of the Champions League only. Just to take one of your examples, it's obvious that Ribery is better than Olic, but Olic scored some key goals for Bayern while Ribery got himself suspended for the final. Olic scored 1) the only goal in the must-win Maccabi Haifa game 2) the go-ahead goal in the must-win Juventus game, 3) a late winning goal in QF 1st leg that allowed them to go to Old Trafford with a lead, 4) the first Bayern goal at Old Trafford, when they were down 3-0 on the night and looked hopeless and 5) hat-trick in Lyon. Bayern certainly wouldn't have been in the final without his contributions so I don't think there's any problem putting him in the top 10. Ribery's obviously a great player, but he didn't establish himself in the CL the way Olic did.
 |
Posted by David on 05/27/2010
You missed Xavi and Fabregas but otherwise a pretty solid top 10
 |
Posted by kury on 05/27/2010
xavi is the best midfielder in the world he should be on dat list in place of olic , pique he is the best CB in the world if c.ronaldo can't get pass him in a match.
 |
Posted by Jason on 05/27/2010
@eric:
I agree with you on Zanetti, he just doesn't get noticed because of his consistency. Other than that...stop naming the players you signed to your fantasy team in FIFA 10. Pique had a far better season than any of them. And Olic was FOURTH-CHOICE at Bayern when he joined them. Now, he's first. It's true that the other forwards had poor years, but he's had a phenomenal season, and along with Robben carried Bayern to the CL final. Ribery had a poor year, was outshined by Robben, Olic, AND Schweinsteiger.
@TommyV:
You're not an Arsenal fan, are you? Grow up, RVP was crocked the whole year, Torres as well. Milito, Drogba, and Rooney were the best pure strikers in the world this year. Fabregas and MAYBE Vermaelen would be in the mix if they had even come close to winning anything. No keeper really shined this year except for Valdes, and he doesn't belong here.
 |
Posted by julee on 05/27/2010
how on earth wld Pique appear on dat list,.......
1.DIEGO MILITO
2.MESSI
3.DROGBA
4.JULIO CEASOR
5.ROONEY
6.RONALDO
7.SNEIJDER
8.ZANETTI
9.CAMBIASSO
10.ROBBEN.
 |
Posted by Anonymous on 05/27/2010
wayne rooney isn't half as good as english people want him to be.
 |
Posted by John L on 05/27/2010
anyone ever take that test in school where if you dont carefully read the instructions, your wasting your time becuz the test is bogus? and simply a lesson to READ!
 |
Posted by Winterhunt on 05/27/2010
XAVI????????!!!!!!!????????
 |
Posted by patrick on 05/27/2010
doug and otownballer - well said. Thank you.
 |
Posted by chewy on 05/27/2010
actually, its not that bad a list....
hes really considering value to team, key outlying contributions and consistency in the champs league
ribery - played poorly imo
Vidic, Ferdinand, Kolo Toure, Zanetti, Gallas, or Chiellini - maybe these are techincially better, and have a higher rating in fifa, but they didnt play better in this season than pique, though zanetti did well. But you didnt watch any game because ferdinand barely played and was poor, vidic wasnt himself. kolo toure has possibly as bad a season as dunne last year.
No Fabregas? No Vermaelen/gallas? did you watch arsenal in the champs league...easy group and 1 good game against fc porto?
Torres? did he even get one game in the europa league? yes hes a better player, but olic was better in fact
i actually think maicon was the closest to the perfect form of his position (rwb) as anyone else to their own position this year.
 |
Posted by AllanC on 05/28/2010
Hahaha, i cant believe people are actually arguing over these small little things.
Since you mentioned "Time to list MY...." see that, its "MY" in there. Of course Brewin has his own opinion to put whoever he likes! Please seriously everyone has their own list. So stop all these silly nonsense of arguing over such things!
And if you want, just write your own list down here and thats it :) Its your opinion! Everyone is entitled to their OWN opinion.
Seriously, the World Cup is coming so just enjoy it!
 |
Posted by Andres on 05/28/2010
I like this list. It's got some guts and they're backed up.
 |
Posted by Rigleys on 05/28/2010
Yo doug - European season can also just mean the best performances of players in europe this season, with obviously champions league being the most prestigious tournament. I agree Olic, should be in here if it's champions league based solely.
Yet, not taking anything away from the top ten, but why would ronaldo be at six if its only european competitions seeing that real madrid went out at the round of sixteen - he scored some important goals for them, but should not be in the list if it's only european cup. Otherwise he should be number 3/4 and certainly higher then rooney - he is rated too high on this and that's coming from a man utd fan.
Maybe more inter players should be ranked, seeing as they won the UCL and messi's brilliance aside; the potency and value of milito's strikes especially as they knocked out barcelona, Milito has to be number 1, wit messi 2/3. One more inter player deserves to be in the list cambiasso/zanetti in place of C. Ron, and Sneider has to be higher.
 |
Posted by alberto on 05/28/2010
dont get angry john, they r right too, just do it again, name top ten of England,Italy,Spain,Germany, the CL and the World and wait for some comments.
 |
Posted by julee on 05/28/2010
how on earth wld Pique appear on dat list,.......
1.DIEGO MILITO
2.MESSI
3.DROGBA
4.JULIO CEASOR
5.ROONEY
6.RONALDO
7.SNEIJDER
8.ZANETTI
9.CAMBIASSO
10.ROBBEN.
 |
Posted by gogi_dhindsa on 05/28/2010
I am not a Chelsea man and I dont want to be drawn into "Who is better:Gerrard or lampard", but seriously give the man credit he deserves. Scoring 27 goals in one season lampard surely deserves a place in top 10. How many midfielders on this list can boast of 27 goals and not to forget his 20 assists as well.
 |
Posted by kayvee on 05/28/2010
Pique is overrated, and Xavi needs to be in this list, Barca team might have faltered at some time, but he has never. Fabregas also needs a mention here perhaps against Olic
 |
Posted by Tristan on 05/28/2010
Eric,that's you who should watch more than 5 games next year. Pique has already been one of the best defenders in the world since 08/09.
 |
Posted by ifect on 05/28/2010
The writer of this post obviously only reads reviews and watches the champions lg.
 |
Posted by hessamole on 05/28/2010
1. messi 2. ronaldo 3. drogba 4. rooney 5. lampard
6. maicon 7. ibra 8. kaka 9. essien/iniesta/xavi/fabregas 10. deez nuts
 |
Posted by Sinan M on 05/28/2010
 |
Posted by Uche Clet on 05/28/2010
I. simply rearrange the list,
1. Lionel Messi
2. Arjen Robben
3. Christiano Ronaldo
4. Didier Drogba
5. Diego Milito
6. Wesley Sneider
7. Wayne Rooney
8. Douglas Maicon
9. Olic
10. Gerald Pique
 |
Posted by Omoh on 05/28/2010
Most of the people condeniog this list would probably fail exams not because they dont know the question but cos they fail to read instructions. The first statement of the second paragraph said "its time to name my top players of EUROPEAN SEASON" not la liga, serie A, PL or bundesliga. And for you to appear on the list you have to appear in the europes most glamorous competition and make your mark. The list is ok except for some things, like xavi not being on the list. To people condemning the list, you dont pick by their names but their performances. Pique's performance at the CL was outstanding and even scoring a brace to prove himself. @Doug you're right olic scored the most important goals than any other player in europe this season. Ronaldo was mentioned cos of his 7goals otherwise he shouldnt even be anywhere near the list. Zanetti deserves an honorary mention. Anyways the list is still ok.
 |
Posted by Peter Karanja _Nairobi on 05/28/2010
They're all fantastic players but I would have had Milito as my number 1 on the list. He won everything for Inter. How much has be brought to the club in his first season?
 |
Posted by Flores on 05/28/2010
Where is Lampard,after all the goals he scored from midfield,not in the top 10?
Posted by Darryl on 05/28/2010
Yeah.... this comment board proves why kids keep failing out of schools. Failure to read what's actually written and going about their own perfect world, criticizing everyone else outside of it... Very solid list in terms of each player's European campaigns.
Posted by AP on 05/28/2010
1. messi
2. milito
3. maicon
4. sneijder
5. zanetti
6. drogba
7. robben
8. xavi
9. rooney
10. cambiasso
Posted by B on 05/28/2010
Why does Ronaldo even make the list. Lampard had a far better season and meant more to his teams trophies. Yes you heard me Real fans I said trophies. Lampard is the heart of the best english team, scores, sets up goals, plays to the whistle. I would certainly put him above drogba this year. Too much emphasis on champions league results in this list. If thats the angle why not just give Mourinho the top 8 spots.
| |
Post your comment |
 |
|
|
|
|
About
| John Brewin joined Soccernet in 2000 and has been editor of the site since 2004. Hailing from the Cheshire town of Macclesfield he currently resides in East London (alone). He has covered every major international tournament since Euro 2000 and has attended six European club finals. |
Categories
Recent Posts
Archives
|