ESPN Soccernet - Editor's Blog
soccernet blog
Soccernet Home Soccernet Home
Soccernet  Home Blogs Home
RSS feed
Editor's Blog
Posted by John Brewin on 03/31/2009

They say the best music belongs to the devil. In considering Diego Maradona, it could be said that Satan also had a handle on the best footballer.

Saturday's destruction of Venezuela by Argentina was described by Maradona, presiding over his first competitive game as national coach, as "a perfect game". And he should know about these things. Though one could beg to differ after Lionel Messi's unbelievably skilful run in the latter stages ended with him narrowly missing the target. The chance to hail Maradona's new charges as "five star" had gone but Messi's burst past a bewildered defence could only bring back memories of one man. That man, meanwhile, was pacing along the sideline, roaring on his charges.

Of all the Maradona impressionists we've had since the great man's playing career ebbed away, Lionel Messi is undoubtedly the best. And could just be the player to make sure that Maradona doubles the membership of Franz Beckenbauer's exclusive club of captaining and coaching his country to World Cup glory. Yet Messi is no Maradona. Not even close.

He may yet match the playing achievements of his country's prodigal and most worshipped son. That argument will not be settled until a decade hence. We shall see, yet it would seem hugely unlikely that the Barcelona prodigy could ever generate a fraction of the headlines, be they of outrage, intrigue or amazement, that his mentor has provided.

Few could imagine the quiet and studious Messi ever launching as rumbustious an autobiograhy as "El Diego", a highly recommended and relentless rant. Written mid-breakdown, as potentially fatal food and cocaine addictions wracked the body and mind of the man who had won the World Cup all but single-handedly in 1986, it speaks in the guttural vernacular of a boy from the barrio. Despite over 30 years of privilege, Maradona will never shake the roots of the shantytown. Foul-mouthed and angry yet wonderfully compelling and highly amusing, it is the story of one man against the world, him winning the battle and then the world taking it away from him again - in his eyes.

This is a man who believes he was destined to the greatest from the moment his uncle rescued him from drowning in the family cesspit. A metaphor for life, a psychatrist once told him, and one that he has seized on ever since.

There is, of course, a rival for his crown and Diego is not taking the battle to be regarded as the best lying down. He and Pele have been bickering jealously for years, though they once made up on Maradona's own TV show, tearfully comparing notes on the horrors of addiction (Pele's son has had a well publicised cocaine problem) and even singing a song together.

That was in 2005, but the gloves are back off now. After Pele's reported insinuation that Maradona was no role model because of his history with drugs, the Argentine chose to say that no-one should listen to Pele since the Brazilian legend had lost his virginity to a man. Something of a break with the tradition of tedium associated with pre-match international press conferences, this makes the barbs between Ferguson and Benitez look like a mutual appreciation society.

Hilariously lacking in diversity and political correctness as it was, Maradona's outrageous claim pointed to the realisation that the responsibility of international management cannot and will not ever curb his tongue.

In England, there is still a rump of dislike for the man, the "Hand of God" remaining the main reason. Personally, I couldn't help but admire him in 1986 and only went off him at Italia '90 where, less than half fit, he put up ugly displays of gamesmanship in every game but still found the wherewithal to end the participation of Brazil, Yugoslavia and a wonderful Italian side. The Argentina team of that tournament could never be the romantic's choice, and few, apart from Argentinians and Diego himself, by the bucketload, shed tears when they were beaten in the final by West Germany's own brand of realpolitik.

Four years later, in the USA, it seemed we had the old Maradona back. A thrilling goal and maniacal celebration in Argentina's opening destruction of Greece had the world believing. So too a masterclass against the emerging Nigerians. Yet a failed dope test robbed us all of the chance of one last hurrah. Maradona, as has been so often the case, self-destructed and snatched bitter defeat from the teeth of a glorious renaissance. We would never see his like again.

It is this edge of unpredictability which draws us to him. The demons were as strong a force as his unbelievable talent and won out in the end. Yet flawed geniuses are often the ones taken to heart. A devil-may-care attitude and fear that something could go wrong at any time can be a powerful attraction.

George Best over Bobby Charlton? Gazza over Gary Lineker? When they fall flat on their face, as all the aforementioned bad boys have done, a moral "majority" may often believe that they've had it coming. To do so is to dismiss what a taste of danger can bring to the game. In short: excitement.

Maradona is to be cherished, for however long he serves. Aside from the quality of the football his team look capable of producing, we should await his World Cup pressers with baited breath. That's if, of course, he makes it that far. Let's hope he can dance on the right side of the devil.

Comments

Posted by Baaba Umar on 03/31/2009

Well you've said it all. Diego Amando Maradona was and is still the most cherished footballer ever, arguable a few may say, but undoubtable to the greater majority.
He delivered almost single handedly for all the teams, from youth to world cup, that he played for.
I read "El-Diego" a collectors item,its all about who Diego is, ghetto kid made good with his sublime God given talent,unpretentious, he was who he is without trying to change class, or being a pretentious "wannabe" its vintage Maradona.
Please tell Pele to have a "coke and a smile, and shut up on Diego" he(Pele) comes a close 2nd to the Greatest.

Posted by Anonymous on 03/31/2009

el diego they call him salute the king homies

Posted by Tony Petrillo on 04/01/2009

To me Pele' has been the most perfect soccer player ever to play soccer, on the field He could do everything so perfect a man with that name had to do.
Maradona? He has been a JEWELL, not only a soccer player, He was send to us by God for our enjoement, on the field HE was always doing what people where not expecting anyone player to do. Before HIM no one had ever touched the ball like HIM.

He is not a role model? Who cares!

I think Gazza was the best English player ever born, do I care that he turned drunk and was beating his wife? No, I don't.
The "hand of God? Even in the 'Hand" goal HE was the best, a hand goal so difficolt to spot.
Let us not forget that in 1985 there was the Faulkland war, so when He said "the hand of God" He meant tha was God punishing the English for what the Argentinian perceived a wrong done to them.
I hope that God will send us another Maradona for all of us to admire!
I immensely enjoied your writing,

My compliments
Tony

Posted by Raffael on 04/01/2009

you absolutely hit the nail on the the head. all great teams need a someone who is nutcase nowadays. Even the mentioned West German team between 1980 and 1996 had one in Mathieus. He and Maradonna were absolutely world class on the pitch and the absolute opposite off of it. The greatest players tend to have a mean streak

Posted by irawan Gani on 04/01/2009

the mark of a extremely good role model is not one who is perfect. but one who falls and gets up again and triumph against adversity. it is a lesson to all of us that we can have second/third/fourth/fifth chances to redeem ourselves and make the world a better place. if and when maradona wins the world cup as a coach, he will be an example to many.

cheers

Posted by Henry Soediarko on 04/01/2009

well written article...just a little contribution from me...when Pele won the world cup, his team mates were brilliant...and even without him (when he was injured) they won the cup too!
Look at Maradona, not to belittle his teammates capability during 1986, 1990 and 1994...they were great but once Maradona is out...the whole team lost its soul...give Pele benefit of the doubt, technically i think both of them are super gifted but when it comes to lift up the whole performance of a team...only Maradona can do that and it shows on world cup 1994...Argentina team was arguably the best ever assembled with redondo, batistuta, canniggia...but look at the result...they have lost the spirit...so...only one numero uno...El Diego

Posted by liverbird on 04/01/2009

I have never seen any player as good as Pele in every aspect, first touch, dribbling and shoot with both legs, scoring in every angle and distance, and passing vision ( remember his passing to Alberto(?) in the 1970 world cup final against Italy ). He is the youngest champion, at 17 in Sweden world cup at 1958, and then the perfect finish with the third championship in 1970 and retired from int'l game. Maradona, apart from shame, I don't know how to name him. His first world cup ended in a red card in Spain against Brazil; his last world cup ended in USA in drug using! Off-field, everyone knows how he fared. Even on the field, do you enjoy playing with him in the same team? You would not get the ball from him. He thinks that only he could do anything. Who say he is the greatest player? Idiot, the only reason for the people to say Maradona is better than Pele is that in Pele's time, TV broadcasting was not as popular as the days of Maradona so that the younger fans did not see much Pele

Posted by sasanka on 04/01/2009

With all his flaws , still he is a very decent human being.
He came to India for felicitation and you know in the stadium he hugged all the players just like they are his team mates. He does not have ego...
as for football only one thing .. If Ever there is a or will be a football GOD then it is only " EL DIEGO"

Posted by Dawud on 04/01/2009

this is really one of the best articles I have read of yours ... Thumbs up! Definately El is the best we have ever had and unfortunately the last we have seen I fear!

Pele, can give El a run for his money, but I should say the man should just settle down for the second best to EL!

Nice try P!!!!!

Posted by steve on 04/01/2009

nice write-up john, always luv ur stuff,poor poor pele guess he'll be sittin at home wishin he was born in d eighties then maybe some of we younger guys would ave aprreciated him better......Naa don't think so..D point is he is so stuffy and so boring.we indentify beta with maradona and honestly to me i think he was a gift from God.......

Posted by chii onyeocha on 04/01/2009

diego is the best that was,the best that is and the best that will ever be...

Posted by Mariano on 04/01/2009

Diego is back. I always thought he should be our coach and I knew he would call in the tough guys. His first call up was Ruggeri then Mascherano as captain Biladrdo as advisor and the tough guy himself to lead the pack. I too suffered drug problems and he has shown me the way back by example. thank you Diego for all the happiness and forgive yourself for your mistakes as you have, and as we do. There will never be another you. Diego is back..run for your lives. Pele played for Santos Mara played for Argentinos, Boca, Barcelona, Napoli, Sevilla, Newells..Pele??? google it yourself. Watch maradonas one touch game and tell me if he was selfish. Vamo Pelusa sali campeon.

Posted by Jon on 04/01/2009

Most people who think Maradona was the greatest ever only say so because others who claim to be experts say so. But when you talk to people who have played and coached at the highest level of the game, there is no contest between him and Pele. Garrincha won the worldcup in 1962 for Brazil in a more commanding way than maradonadid in 1986"singlehandedly".and please think for yourselves and stop just repeating what these socalled football writers say. Diego is noteven the best argentine ever. Have any of you ever heard of a player name alfredo DeStefano? Put maradona and pele playing stats side by side and the come back to reality.

Posted by Shima on 04/01/2009

Let us stop player hating. Diego was and is still the greatest the world ever produced. Napoli has never won a silver ware after Diego left. The only serie-A titles (2) and uefa cup winners cup was won with Maradona. Argentina has not won any world cup since the great one left. Diego was a complete entertainer and team player. Just look at his assists. Pele is just a jealous freak who cant get the attention Diego gets. Diego is a class act.

Posted by Aiah Ernest Sam on 04/01/2009

Thanks for this class article.For me little do I know about Pele but for everything in soccer, El Diego is my man.Despite his drug addiction and all, the guy was simply phenomeanl when it comes to playing football.Single-handedly El Diego will destroy opponents without mercy and will give his all for the cause of his team and team mates.
To be honest to say the guy was selfish the way he played is complete hypocrisy.Who can really sacrifice his all for others if he is selfish.....the guy was beyond compare.Pele might have scored more goals, had little or no problems on and off the field, but football wise I want to cast my lot for El Diego as my best ever footballer.Now that he is back in the world of coaching, I wish him well to prove his detractors wrong.El Diego keep the flame burning.

Posted by Herbert on 04/01/2009

The original El Loco, El Diego. The greatest player to grace a football(if I hear you say soccer at the back, I'll be right there to sort you out) pitch. Stand aside Pele, for you compete against the likes of Puskas, Eusebio and Kaiser - all great MEN - if only Best had gone to a world cup, he'd be here too.
Diego Armando Maradona is God's gift to football.

Posted by matt on 04/01/2009

I enjoyed the article, but i think its unwise to compare Pele and maradona. I never saw pele in action, and can only rely on second hand opinion, and the stats. I did grow up watching maradona, and he was inspirational. I wanted to be him in the kick abouts we had as kids.. To me, he will always be the fantasy footballer, with the ability to decide games on his own. He was the first genius i ever came across, and my entire football experience repeatedly underlined how gifted he was. Even maradona's peers were in awe of him. Pele apparently had that too, but i will regard maradona as the best player i have ever seen.

Posted by Steven S. on 04/01/2009

Maradona, to me, is one of the great tragic figures of football history.

He could have been more than he was; but he destroyed himself, cheated his teams, his sport, and his fans, and is now trying to pick up the pieces.

The one world cup he won? Tainted by cheating. The last world cup he played in? If the Argentine team "lost the spirit" when Maradona left, why is that any credit to him? He *removed* the spirit of the team when he left it.

Credit him with results at Napoli and you also have to look at what he didn't accomplish with other teams, and what he could have accomplished at Napoli had he not gotten himself suspended.

A great player, yes. Best ever? Not by a long shot. A great tragedy? Beyond a doubt.

Posted by Jasim on 04/01/2009

Maradona might have been good, but pele is PELE

Posted by ibrahim adams on 04/01/2009

good job on a very well written piece john. i'm a fan and always enjoyed your work. on the subject of pele vs diego. we should give pele some credit for being trully a great role model over the years and leave it at that. on the other hand what can you really say about diego,that hasn't been said. his name alone is synanomous with greatness and that is something that will never change.in my opinion diego was also one of the most worshiped footballers on the planet,with all his flaws right there in front of you, at times you couldn't believe what he did on the pitch and sometimes you just wanted to shake him and scream what's wrong with you. but that's what made diego who he is and there will never be another one like him......long live EL DIEGO.

Posted by Kondjeni on 04/02/2009

The man is a genius without measure, he rose from obscurity to cement his name in football history as the greatest footballer ever. His a one-man show but still managed to make others look great! I've seen the wonder of Messi, but Maradona was just something else. The magic he performed on the pitch combined with his persona off the field is like that of a movie star that produces box office hits year in year out..U simply have to admire him! If he wins the World Cup, then surely even FIFA will have to merit him with a UFC (Undisputed Football Champion) award.

Posted by jori on 04/02/2009

with due respect to Pele, the truth is he is no the best , or second best soccer/football player ever.he is the third best player after EL Diego and Zizou

Posted by Ryan on 04/02/2009

I don't see why we need to determine who the best player was because this will never be objective or unbiased. Both Maradona and Pele are in a special class who the rest all try and emulate. Di Stefano, Eusebio, Best all belong in that same category who provided inspiration for future generations of footballers.

I have no doubt who the best ever footballer is in the mind of El Diego and Pele, given their egos. But surely respect should not be lost on either of them because of the opinions of others. Both were and still are great!

Posted by Francis on 04/02/2009

It seems we spoke too soon. The results on April fools day speak differently..Argentina beaten 1-6.

Posted by reuben on 04/03/2009

luv this piece on El Diego. I agree that we can never be objective in Pele vs Diego because of generational gap. For me it's El Diego because I grew up watching him. But when I saw some Pele Clips on U tube, then u'll agree that for people of his generation Arantes Dos Nacimento is and will always be the best footballer ever.For me it will always be El Diego.

Posted by ibrahim jega on 04/03/2009

I have never been a fan of diego maradona but yet i beleive he is far better than tradiional local player who were rated the best palyer, but' of his on time ie PELE.
Yet the best among them a talent,creator and achiever that ever produce in the history of world footbal is ZINADEN ZIDENE...............................................................

Posted by Vern Gardner on 04/04/2009

Over the years I have seen many great players, Bobby Moore,Franz Beckenbauer,Johan Cruyff, Zinedine Zidane just to mention a few, Maradonna was also a great player, but I truthfully say I haven't witnessed any of the others behaving like the way Maradonna did, on or off the pitch. The greatest player ever would not have to resort to the tactics Maradonna displayed against England and then boast about it after, there was never a "Hand of God" as he claimed but a blatant display of cheating.

So when it comes to the greatest player ever then I can't go past Pele, watching him and the entire Brazilian team at the 1970 World Cup was pure magic. This man had the head and the feet of God and is a true ambassador for the game.

Posted by sammy on 04/06/2009

i think it is unfair to compare Diego and pele. naturally, no two persons are exactly alike. i dint watch pele play soccer , so i cant rate him.
but quite honestly , Diego was inspirational on the field.
as per coaching, he has the intellect to do the work but will falter somehow along the way due to his limited experience. he will succeed if he can overcome his sensitive nature so he could see that no coach in the world has a 100% record. it is all
down to your ability to see beyond current level pas or fail

Posted by dwayne on 04/07/2009

Pele Good. Maradona Better. George Best.

Posted by Jay U on 04/08/2009

Maradona Good. Pele better. Okocha best

"Jay Jay" Okocha: so good they named him twice! better than Maradona @ dribbling. watch his clips from frankfurt (ask Oliver Kahn) to PSG. Gr8 Ronaldinho acknowledged learning a lot from him. Singlehandedly saved Bolton from relegation and just had to be made captain. ur the best Jay.

Posted by garen on 07/13/2009

I have to agree with Jon. I have seen both Pele and Maradona play and they're not even close. Maradona would try 15-20 times to dribble past defences, always individualistic, and succeed maybe once. Pele's vision of the game was immense and would always attract defences to create space for his teammates. He was a lot more efficient in every aspect. We only remember Maradona because he played during a period where TV coverage became universal. But in all fairness he wasn't even considered the best player in Italy during his Napoli era where he had competition from the likes of Michel Platini. And how many European championships did he win with Napoli? 0. So please have some respect for the Argentina team of 1986.

Posted by harsh bhagat on 04/04/2010

Maradona, by far, was a dominant player even when compared across the sporting world -dominant because of the sheer natural skill that only he possesssed - imagine his accomplishments in the face of some of the fiercest physical tackles he faced in the 80s and you get a sense for the punishment he took and overcame. I respect Pele, but what I saw of Maradona, I think is the best it will ever get.

Posted by harsh bhagat on 04/04/2010

no one disputes the fact that Maradona had issues and behaved badly at times. However, watching the man balance the ball on his head at the dinner table, while holding his daughter AND being seated, balancing the ball on his heels, spinning the ball so it goes up, scoring from 0 degree angles, running at the rate of 11 s per 100 metres, and most of all, avoiding vicious tackles while never losing control of the ball - makes me wonder how on earth this man could have been so blessed

  Post your comment
Name:
Email Address:
Comments:
characters left
© ESPN Soccernet 2009
Cricinfo
Soccernet
ESPN