ESPN Soccernet - Correspondents - FC Bayern Munich
soccernet blog
FC Bayern Munich
Posted by Susie Schaaf on 02/10/2012

The 1 - 1 draw with Hamburger SV and the 0 - 2 DFB Pokal match win at Stuttgart are showing that Bayern, once again, are on the up-swing after a wholly disappointing start to this season's Rueckrunde. It was never a matter of having quality personnel, but rather having said personnel in the right positions. A lot of people are saying Bayern plays better without Arjen Robben, but I don't find that necessarily to be the case. After all, most of those same people were clamoring for Arjen's return from groin injury and Thomas Mueller to be benched.

The draw at HSV taught us a few lessons: Antoily Tymoshchuk was largely (if not, completely) ineffectual as a wing back. I think Jupp Heynckes considered that a lesson learned after 61 minutes when the Ukrainian was subbed for David Alaba.

What we've all been trying not to believe this season is the cold fact that Philipp Lahm is fallible. He was drawn off Sala, who he was supposed to be marking, leaving the Italian wide open to score his first Bundesliga goal. I'm wondering if his captaining of both Bayern and the Nationalelf is a bit too much. He already looks tired and we just came off winter break.

The Toni Kroos and Bastian Schweinsteiger pairing at DM doesn't work. Our regular 4-2-3-1 formation ends up looking much more like a 4-1-4-1, with Kroos slotted in further up-field behind the attacking midfielders, leaving Schweini to be the sole boss in front of the back line. And while everyone thinks he's the s**t (myself definitely included), it's a little too much to ask.

Jerome Boateng and Holger Badstuber keep their rightful places as central defenders. This is the correct partnership, and what Heynckes should have been using all along. While I don't dislike Daniel van Buyten, Boateng's athleticism much more than makes up for whatever advantage DvB adds on set pieces. (I mean, really! We have offensive weapons for weeks!) And coupled with Badstuber's passing and positional instinct, this pair is a force to be reckoned with.

Against a well-positioned Hamburg defense, and a goal-keeper, in Drobny, who had the match of his life, Arjen Robben still managed to get his shots in, even with no help from Tymo. Lest us forget, on the other side of the pitch, Ribery was guilty of over-dribbling. A lot.

Four days later, FCB faces VfB Stuttgart in the DFB Pokal quarter-final; naturally disappointed with the draw against Hamburg, but optimistic that things are falling in to place, despite losing the position at the top of the Bundesliga table. And, falling in to place is exactly what happened.

With Rafinha back on the wing, the Bayern defense looked as it should have been all along. I can only hope that Jupp is done fiddling with the back four. Only Cacau could muster up enough... errr... mustard to give Neuer his lone save on the day.

David Alaba has rather quietly been putting together a nifty season. Coming in for the lamentably injured Bastian after only 17 minutes, he handled his DM duties admirably. In fact, he's done well in every situation that Jupp has placed him in this year's campaigns.

Thomas Mueller's hand in both goals is no surprise to me, although I wish he would've scored himself. He is as good on the wing (perhaps better, even) as he is in the 10 slot. But, with Kroos much better lining up behind Gomez, Thomas won't be in the playmaker's spot very often.

Arjen Robben can put away his bitchface, as Holger does it better anyway. The Dutch international will not be relegated to the bench for the forseeable future. Given that he and Rafinha get a few quality matches in together, and get in sync, he will be starting. Just maybe not tomorrow.

So, a comfortable win against a hard-nosed VfB puts us in to the Pokal semi-finals. A draw against 'Gladbach, Dortmund or Gruether Fuerth lurks on Sunday. And we've got a shot at making up some points this weekend, as Leverkusen travels to BvB. (A draw isn't too much to ask, is it?) Also, Schalke 04 travels to 'Gladbach, while we face lowly Kasierslautern at home. I can't see us not kicking some serious Roten Teufel butt on Saturday, as they have only scored 15 goals in 20 Bundesliga matches. A comprehensive win at the Allianz would be a huge step in the right direction.

Auf gehts, Bayern!

You can (and should) follow Susie on Twitter at: www.twitter.com/fussballsusie

Follow ESPNsoccernetFC on Twitter


Comments

Posted by Ryan on 02/10/2012

How do you feel about the Shaqiri signing?

Posted by Tony on 02/10/2012

Roten Teufel? LOL

Posted by dan on 02/10/2012

I really feel for Bastian, lets hope he can get back as soon as possible. Regarding this season, I believe in my opinion that we are getting much better with every game.

Posted by Susie on 02/11/2012

Ryan---

He's a talent, that's for sure. But, does he fit in to FCB's starting XI straight off the bat? Not so sure. Personally, I'd like to see a Robben extension and Shaq being loaned out for a year or so...

Tony---

That is their nickname. As much as it doesn't fit... :)

Dan---

I sincerely hope so.

Posted by oem software on 02/11/2012

mTRhPB Cool:) I would say say it exploded my brain..!!

Posted by Peter on 02/11/2012

Shaqiri loaned? Are you nuts? He was one of the main reasons why Basel knocked out United in the CL and was very impressive in his national game against England, including scoring a stunner. He might not be a starter on paper but he will get more than enough games because Robbery are often injured and we have no flair or spark without them. Muller is a great player but he doesn't have any real dribbling ability, so we finally bought a like for like replacement for Robben ( and to lesser extent for Ribery), now all we need is a good young striker ( Petersen should be loaned) that can be a decent replacement for Gomez and a high quality CB - Breno is done and DVB is old and maybe a RB ( unless Boateng is willing to play there or if Rafinha impresses Jupp).

Posted by BayernMunchen01 on 02/11/2012

Honestly, I'm a little disappointed with the Shaqiri signing if Robben stays. I'd really like to see Alaba getting more playing time. He shows great effort every match, can play virtually anywhere, and... he won Austrian player of the year this
year... at 19!

Posted by BayernMunchen01 on 02/11/2012

Oh, and this is a question I've been dying to ask. Who do you think will replace Butt? Will Bayern go with young Sattelmaier? Susie, have you heard of Alexander Manninger? He's not a well-known player, but he currently plays for Juve and his contract expires in the summer. He's Austrian, so he would speak German well, he's had some experience with bigger clubs in his early years, and he's currently the 3rd choice keeper behind Buffon and Storari. He in my opinion would be the perfect replacement for Butt. Although he's 34, his entire career he's usually been a backup for bigger clubs and he's a good keep. Oh ya, and he's cheap.

Posted by oem software on 02/11/2012

pNtpUG Thanks for the news! Just was thinking about it! By the way Happy New Year to all of you:DD

Posted by Stevavo on 02/12/2012

I think some of you haven't seen Shaqiri play, hecnce the comments like we shd loan him. He is exceptional, everyone goes on about Hazard as the next big thing on the wing but actually its Shaqiri. Why? Well he is a big reason why the Swiss u21s reached the euro final, why basel have done so well in ucl and has been phenomenal for the swiss senior squad; quick, strong, dribbles well has a monstrous shot and plays in great crosses. This youngster will possibly exceed both Ribery and Robben in terms of ability if he is handled correctly. Im proud Bayern swatted off the likes of man united to sign him, trust me watch him play before you judge.

Posted by BayernMunchen01 on 02/13/2012

Most definitely, Stevavo. I want to think that in the next few years we will be seeing a Muller-Kroos-Shaqiri lineup up front. I'm just saying I would like to see Alaba getting a bit more playing time wherever on the pitch for Bayern this year and next. However, with Muller, Kroos, Ribery, (potentially) Robben, and Shaqiri, I don't see Alaba getting too much playing time.

Posted by latibaba on 02/13/2012

@Susie,

I have very little to say on this topic,cos you've spoken my mind,except for the fact that you said Shaqiri should be loan for a year.

Shaqiri is a natural brilliant Chap watch out for him in the match against us in UCL,u will be suprise with whom we are talking about.

He is not new,he's being exposed to international game,european just mention,and has proven a developing star.

I can bet you,his introduction to Bayern current team will provide immediate dividend.

Lastly,please go an extra mile to make sure decision makers in Bayern are reading this feedback,it will certainly improve the cub.

Mia san mia

Posted by Dan Lee on 02/13/2012

Shaqiri of course is a growing-talent player guys, that's why Bayern bought him and I am glad, but champions league is a diferent story; however, we have to be careful and keep a man or maybe two on him in the next two games against Basel, don't you guys think? Well anyway, lets hope he can become the next star to be watched for the next years.

Posted by Ruud on 02/16/2012

Hey Susie, great posts as usual...

I'm really concerned about out forward options, especially if we're looking to play the final at the Allianz. Gomez has been great, and with all due respect to Olic, i don't think he can make as much an impact as Gomez should he get injured (god forbid), and Petersen, meh..

Regarding Shaqiri, well, he's awesome and i'm glad we've signed him, Utd must be P I S S E D :), and i do agree with the guys that he shouldn't be loaned out, especially with the Robbery history of injuries.

In my humble opinion, this is how the lineup should be:
Nueur
Rafinha Boateng BadASSstuber Lahm
Schweini Goos
Robben/Mueller Kroos Ribery
Super Mario

Posted by grudnik on 02/16/2012

How soon people forget.

Olic, when in form, is a beast. I would have no issues at all with having him replace Gomez, in case of injury.

The only problem Olic has right now is that he was injured for a long time, and is not getting any significant playing time to be able to get back into a rhythm.

Posted by BayernMunchen01 on 02/16/2012

Who Bayern should let go of in the summer (in my opinion):

Van Buyten
(possibly) Robben

Loan:
Usami
Petersen

Bayern have brought in Shaqiri and I've heard they're looking at ManCity's John Guidetti, who's a great talent.

With Olic looking more and more like he will leave this summer, I've heard 3 targets for Gomez's backup:

John Guidetti, Olivier Giroud, and Dimitar Berbatov.

I would prefer for them to go for Berbatov. He's a good finisher, experienced, and looking likely to leave ManU in the summer.

Although they're both good players, I feel Guidetti's too young, and Giroud is big at 6'4", but he's not very quick.

Posted by Ruud on 02/16/2012

Grudnik, chill dude!

I didn't curse Olic. All i was saying is that Olic will not be as efficient as Gomez, he has a tremendous work rate and pace, but...

I think Bayern should look at players like Llorente and Giroud (maybe), and give Gomez a rest every now and then, we're wearing him out. Olic is not likely to stay past this season, i would have preferred if he stays and get an extra established striker.

PS. i am a dedicated Bayern fan (for over 25 years actually), and i don't like to be treated as an outsider, nor to be labeled as someone who does not appreciate what players like Olic have done to the Team.

Posted by grudnik on 02/17/2012

@ BayernMunchen01:
They can't loan out Usami, as Bayern has him on loan from his Japanese club, which is set to expire at the end of this season. They had an option to buy him, but declined it, instead, unsuccessfully trying to get him on loan for another year.

@ Ruud:
I am about as chilly as you can get. I didn't say you cursed Olic, I was just disagreeing with you on Olic's potential impact, should he have to start in Gomez' spot.

If someone disagreeing with you makes you feel like you're being treated like an outsider, I would suggest that you are overly sensitive, as that was not my intention.

Posted by Ruud on 02/17/2012

@ Grudnik

I suggest you re-read my post, Olic is not at the same level as Gomez, thus will not make the same impact, and that goes without saying... I feel a club as big as Bayern, should have more options for every position, especially if they are fighting on three fronts. And right now, their forward options are not sufficient!

If you are suggesting Gomez and Olic are at the same level, then i respect YOUR opinion.

I'm not overly sensitive, but "How soon people forget" is a bit judgmental don't you think? as my initial post did not suggest so. Therefore, you DID label me as someone who does not appreciate what players like Olic have done to the Club.

Peace!

Posted by grudnik on 02/20/2012

But Olic made plenty of impact when he was healthy.

Of course he's not on Gomez's level, but who is? Who are you suggesting that Bayern should buy, who is at Gomez's level, but will sit on the bench, waiting for a chance?

You said that you were concerned about the talent behind Mario. That made me think that you have already forgotten about Olic's contributions a mere two seasons ago (when he was fully healthy and in rhythm).

Posted by Ruud on 02/20/2012

If you want my honest opinion, i think if Super Mario is out (god forbid), you will need two strikers to fill the void left by him... but i understand what you are saying; i think of Llorente, but then again would he accept a bench role?! Giroud looks very talented (from what i've seen), and has a similar body build if i'm not mistaken, he would be a good addition.

If you knew how much i hate Manchester United, you would have known how much i love Olic ;)

Seriously, the team needs another striker and a CD.

Posted by grudni on 02/21/2012

If Olic actually leaves in the summer (which seems likely, despite Rummenigge's latest statements), I totally agree with you that Bayern needs to sign another quality striker. Going into next season with just Gomez and Petersen would be crazy.

But getting another striker of the caliber of Gomez is just not realistic, as there are very few available, and none of them want to sit on the bench.

I've heard lately about Giroud, but I have never seen him play, so I can't comment.

Posted by Katsuyuki on 02/25/2012

Pagi Ariiiii tenyrata postingnya tentang bola ya!Saya bisa merasakan kehebohan penggemar bola yang nungguin laga tadi malem berhubung cuma tau MU dan Christiano Ronaldo, hehehe, saya nggak bisa bikin komen yang nyambung dengan isi posting ini

  Post your comment
Name:
Email Address:
Comments:
characters left