ESPN Soccernet - Correspondents - Aston Villa
soccernet blog
Aston Villa
Posted by Jerrad Peters on 06/09/2009

Don’t sweat the loss of Gareth Barry. Don’t shed a tear and don’t get all emotional and toss around words such as betrayal and abandonment. Sure, he’s guilty of both. But so what? What, exactly, did he do this season to provoke such a furious reaction?

The stats sheet says he scored eight goals in 48 appearances for Aston Villa. Not a bad return for a playmaking midfielder. Only two of those goals came in 2009, however, and both were penalties.

Barry’s last goal in open play in all competitions came in a 3-2 win at home to Blackburn Rovers on October 29. Villa were flying high at that point, and would do so for about another month. Then the wheels came off, and the former captain was nowhere to be found.

For much of the season’s second half, Villa’s was one of the most penetrable midfields in the Premier League. The career-ending injury to Martin Laursen was often cited as the primary reason for the sudden defensive vulnerability, and Martin O’Neill came in for a good dose of criticism after adjusting his tactics following the disastrous acquisition of Emile Heskey.

But Barry, more than anyone else in the team, was absolutely dreadful in the final five months of the campaign. Five months is a long time to be dreadful, and I doubt either O’Neill or owner Randy Lerner were all that put out by his sudden exit on June 2. Quite the contrary, I suspect. Twelve million quid is hardly a bad return for a player who was such a vital part of a monumental collapse.

But is Barry a villain? (No pun intended.) Hardly. At 28, he was overdue for a change of scenery after 12 years at Villa Park. He’s also nearly doubled his wages. Good luck to him. At City he’ll join the finest mish-mash of second-rate stars that Arab oil money can buy. That description fits him to a tee. He’ll fit in perfectly.

Barry’s exit was never about loyalty to Villa or a chance to join a Champions’ League contender. It was about getting in on the ground floor of something that, two or three years from now, might prove rather exciting. It was also about money. And no one should begrudge him that.

At the end of the day, Barry spent 12 years at a club where he was a half-decent player, but never a superstar. He put in an honest effort, but rarely delivered anything spectacular. In other words, he was not the kind of player who comes around maybe once or twice in a generation. He was very replaceable. And I, for one, won’ miss him the slightest.

Twitter.com/peterssoccer

jerradpeters@gmail.com

Comments

Posted by Jerry Stragalinos on 06/09/2009

I couldn't agree more with your comments. Maybe that explains why O'Neill let him go for 12,000,000 pounds while last year he wanted 18,000,000!!!!!

Posted by Patrick Fay on 06/09/2009

Just wanted to add general support of the first comment that Barry had not had the best of seasons and a lucrative move at this stage in his playing career is understandable. Also let’s not loose sight of the fact that as a player gets closer to the end of his contract the ability of demanding a high transfer fee is diminishing.

In addition we may not have seen the best of players like Steve Sidwell and Nigel Reo-Coker with Stiliyan Petrov perhaps in a more attacking role. Gareth Barry will be missed, but suggest he will be always remain a ‘Villain’ and is not a ‘Villain of the peace’ as currently painted

Posted by Derek Gordon on 06/09/2009

Fantastic, Jerrad. You've just echoed my feelings on the close of the "Gareth Barry Saga."

Well done.

Posted by astonslash on 06/10/2009

Amen! It's hard at first to swallow- I had to read the headline thrice to make sure it said ManC not Liverpool when it happened. Barry was solid but not spectacular and I agree he seemed to have been running in neutral for a while. Take the 12 mil plus the money Lerner was already going to spend and let's reenergize to kick some butt 09/10. One more reason to make CL next year.

Posted by Canadian Villa Boy on 06/11/2009

Excellent post, i think you put it into perfect words! I was completely shocked that it wasnt Liverpool but then not so much that it was City. I was angry at first but then found it quite hilarious, how can you say you have a desire to play Champs League football and head to City?

To quote "Good luck to him. At City he’ll join the finest mish-mash of second-rate stars that Arab oil money can buy." I'll take the 12 mil anyday, and like other villa fans have said another motivation for us to push for champs league next year!!

Posted by Nick on 06/11/2009

I can agree with you, but with Laursens injury, Barrys departure, and the rest of the holes we got at Villa Park, I think we need all the help we can get.

Madrid throwing barrells of cash around will equal the Manchesters, City's, and Liverpools of the world going after much of the same targets O'neill would like to go after, albeit with more money (Ok. maybe not Liverpool so much)

I can agree Barry is a 4 star player, not a 5 star. But its just another missile fired into a tank with alot of bumps and dents as it is.

Posted by Villain on 06/12/2009

What a crock of crap. How many Villa games did you watch this year??? He was quality week in, week out.

Posted by Oliver on 06/17/2009

RIdiculous to say he won't be missed, are you saying an english international could not be used by villa? would only steven gerrard or joe cole command a place in our formidable first XI. This is the same foolish villa arrogance that has been part of our misguided transfer policy (usually acquisitions) for years. Probably the same people moaning about 9.5m for ashley young! now that's a bargain, when before he was untried. who are we going to get instead of Barry? cast offs from newcastle and continental 'giants' like cagliari. Reality is we will always have to make do with what M O'N can scrounge up from the scraps and pray that we can get to CL. Welcome to reality of being a villa supporter- enjoy your lot, don't bag barry because we're not a big (money or trophy wise) club at the moment.

Posted by Ammo on 06/20/2009

Barry was a strong contributor all season and rated better than many others as the slide occurred.
Fact is Laursen's departure and MONs effort at covering it by playing decent players OUT OF POSITION was a major contributing factor in the slide: Reo-Coker, Shorey, Cuellar just to name 3 whose form dipped as a result. Lack of decent rotation and resting caused a tired team to limp home. Many a game in the first half of the season occurred without any substitutions being made!
How can you go buy Heskey then loan out Harewood; say we are short of midfielders then sell Routledge and Moloney, spell Sidwell and play Reo-Coker and Gardner in the backs. Milner was a good buy but we were familiar with him from the loan spell.
We can't keep treating our fringe players like they are there to make the numbers - they have to be played.
Before we buy anyone we need to work out what couple of formations we are prepared to play and buy around that.
Up the Villa!

Posted by Jim on 06/24/2009

Jerrad Peters must be looking to gain friends from those that look for any excuse to downplay the significance of the Barry transfer. His comments are quite ridiculous. Villa had a good first 2/3rds of the season. With continuity and a larger squad, it could turn to great next season. But the Barry transfer confirms that Villa does not have the financial clout to compete for the top 4. It is clear they have resigned themselves to fight for slightly better than mid-table. Very disappointing.

Posted by astonslash on 06/24/2009

I think the Barry transfer is significant but certainly is not the major deal it can be turned into. I don't think it is a sign of Villa lowering their sights. Barry has been with the club for longer than most players are even in the Premier League system period. Let him move on and try something different- he was consistent but stale this last year and except for arguing the penalty kick call on Ashley Young showed little spirit to kick the team in the butt like a captain needs to. Talking about top four- check out the under read/ under publicized articles about debt in the premier league from two weeks ago. Top four clubs correspond directly to top four clubs in debt. Do you know who was ranked 5th for debt and salary expense? Newcastle United- big buys & big salaries quarantee one thing- big debt. Time for Villa fans and players to put heads up forget all the crap about the "slide" and get ready for next year.

Posted by Anonymous on 07/02/2009

haha! it looks like talking about sour grapes, to me. barry, the club captain, a "second-rate star"? then that implkies villa is a second rate club itself! but i think it is not, and nor is barry anything but a top grade central midfielder.
and as for him being a "half-decent player", how come he was the captain for so long then? do you mean to say the other players are even less that "half-decent"?
stop this rumbling, buddy. barry's departure is a huge los, and you sure as hell know it. so cut this shite about not missing him out.

Posted by Jibak on 07/02/2009

haha! it looks like talking about sour grapes, to me. barry, the club captain, a "second-rate star"? then that implkies villa is a second rate club itself! but i think it is not, and nor is barry anything but a top grade central midfielder.
and as for him being a "half-decent player", how come he was the captain for so long then? do you mean to say the other players are even less that "half-decent"?
stop this rumbling, buddy. barry's departure is a huge los, and you sure as hell know it. so cut this shite about not missing him out.

Posted by Bill on 07/04/2009

JP is spot on with this analysis. This isn't sour grapes. Just remember the last Liverpool match. Barry makes horrible free kick, gives ball away and is lazy tracking back as his man scores goal giving the REds 2-0 lead. Happened frequently last few months. Didn't want to play after Villa squandered 4th. Barry was fabulous in years past and first few months of last season. He is very replacable in the current form he labored for Villa since February.....Laursen was the heart. Just look at Villa since he was hurt. MON has to stop dragging his feet. It's JULY now. Has to get going bringing in new players. Hate to say it, but O'Leray is right for once.

Posted by Tom on 07/05/2009

I wonder if we can sneak in on some of the excess players that Read Madrid now has in the squad. Apparently, they need to offload 10 and surely cash is not something they would be particularly concerned about. Wouldn't it be great if we can get Robben or Van de Vaart (spelling) on board?

  Post your comment
Name:
Email Address:
Comments:
characters left
About
Kevin Hughes Kevin Hughes spent the best part of ten years working and writing for the football magazine Match; once (sort of) inspiring David Beckham to copy his shaved-hair look, getting lost in Paris after the 1998 France v Croatia World Cup semi-final and other such nonsense. As Deputy Editor, he launched and established Sport, the London-based free weekly magazine, before moving on to become a consumer magazine publisher, a position he holds today. Introduced to Villa by his father and grandfather, he attended his first ever match at Villa Park as a seven-year-old in 1982… and has suffered almost constant disappointment since. You can follow him on twitter @KevHughesie

RSS feed

Categories
Recent Posts
Archives