|
|
 |
|
Continuing my recent series of posts, I'm going to continue to assess the season for each Arsenal player. Fans at the moment have a lot of opinions on who should leave the club given the acrimonious finish to the campaign, so I'm going to give my view on everyone's season and say if they have a future at the club.
As always, I'm sure some will disagree with my thoughts and ratings so please comment and give your views at the bottom of the blog.
Moving up the pitch, I'm going to look at the midfield.
2. Abou Diaby
After being at the club since 2006, it wouldn't be unreasonable to think Abou Diaby could now hold down a regular place in the starting XI. After his big improvements in 2009/10, he looked set to become a first choice in the centre alongside Song and Fabregas. However, once again injuries and inconsistency has meant he hasn't deserved to hold down a regular place.
Obviously the emergence of Jack Wilshere hasn't helped Diaby, however when given the chance, the Frenchman just hasn't delivered despite his undoubted talent and potential. Now he's 25, we should be beginning to see him begin to peak as a box-to-box midfielder, although that just isn't happening.
His goals at home and away against Blackpool showed how good he could be arriving late into the box, however that sight was all too uncommon in the season.
The Tottenham away match in the Premier League summed Diaby up. He looked good when on the ball, but then the final pass would be lacking. Tracking back, he was at fault for van der Vaart's first goal of the game and then he went off injured.
It's hard to know whether to persevere with Diaby as there is a quality player in there, but he misses too many games and doesn't perform well enough in a large number of those he does appear in. One of the fans' over-riding memories of him for this season will be the needless red card at Newcastle. That, combined with his inconsistency, puts his place in the squad at risk.
Verdict: Frustrating. A shame that his talent and potential are going to waste at the moment: 5/10.
4. Cesc Fabregas
By his own high standards, Cesc didn't have a great season. Niggling hamstring and thigh injuries meant he missed significant spells of the season, including big games such as the Carling Cup final.
Obviously, a lot of the media focus at the moment is once again on whether he'll join Barcelona this summer. Although he's coming off the back of an average season, he's undoubtedly a world class player, so Arsenal shouldn't feel bullied into selling him. With four years left on his contract, Arsene Wenger can virtually name his price to Barcelona.
This on-going saga does raise the question of whether his heart is really in Arsenal Football Club. Everyone has known for years that Cesc Fabregas is a Barcelona boy and grew up supporting the Catalans. However, the bulk of his professional football education was done at Arsenal, and he doesn't ignore that fact. He knows how much the club has given him, and to be honest, he wouldn't necessarily get into the starting XI at Barcelona. At Arsenal, he has more responsibility on the pitch and knows that when fit, he is almost guaranteed to play. Although no-one should be surprised if Cesc does leave, but Arsene Wenger has to make sure we get the right amount of money in return.
Fabregas' commitment couldn't be doubted last season. On many of the occasions where he suffered recurrences of injuries, it was because he was so desperate to play that he aggravated injuries when rushing his comeback.
His highlights of the season would probably be his goal against Ipswich in the Carling Cup semi-final and the pass to Nasri in the build up to the second goal against Barcelona. Notable mentions must also go to the way he orchestrated the defeats of Bolton and Braga early on in the season.
Verdict: A world class player who has had a disrupted season. The Arsenal squad is definitely better with Cesc Fabregas in it: 6/10
7. Tomas Rosicky
The case of Tomas Rosicky is a sad one. On arriving at the club in 2006, everyone had high hopes for the Czech international. He had a good first season and was beginning to settle into the Premier League during his second season before his mysterious injury, which robbed him of 18 months of his Arsenal career. In a similar way to Eduardo, Rosicky really hasn't been the same since.
He appears to have lost most of his confidence as a player as he never seems to run past players like he used to. His general attacking instinct has also decreased rapidly. One goal all season for an attacking midfielder is a poor return.
Whereas in the past, you'd think that with Rosicky in the team there'd always be a chance of him creating or scoring a goal, there's now a sense that everything slows down when he's on the ball.
His effort is better than most in the squad, but unfortunately his footballing ability has declined.
Verdict: A real shame that he hasn't got anywhere near his pre-injury abilities. Time to move on: 4/10.
8. Samir Nasri
Like Cesc Fabregas, Samir Nasri is a player making headlines about potentially leaving Arsenal. Again, like Cesc Fabregas, Samir Nasri is a player with outstanding quality that would be sorely missed should he leave the club.
Although his form tailed off towards the end of the campaign, there'd no doubting the Frenchman had a good season. There were a number of goal of the season contenders, mixed in with the sort of exciting attacking wing play we arguably haven't seen since the likes of Freddie Ljungberg and Robert Pires.
There does seem to be a number of people who believe Nasri is better in the middle of the pitch, in the ‘Fabregas role'. However I'm slightly dubious about that. He has great pace that he can be extremely dangerous when running in the less congested wide areas. From the left, there's also the option for him to cut inside onto his right foot with his quick feet. Ideally, I'd like to see Fabregas or van Persie looking for a Bergkamp style pass for Nasri making the Ljungberg-esque diagonal run into the box.
We've got to hope Nasri doesn't follow the path of Emmanuel Adebayor; have a good season, get rewarded with a massive pay increase before putting in lazy performances and being sold. However we don't want to see him run down his contract and leave on a free transfer with his stock being high at the moment.
I think Arsene Wenger does need to be relatively accepting of Nasri's wage demands as the club need to make statements to the fans that they're really serious about improving the squad and not weakening it, and clearly keeping the Frenchman would be part of that. Nasri would then need to actually show he's worth the money he and his agent seem to be holding out for.
Verdict: A good season, his contract needs to be sorted sooner rather than later: 8/10.
15. Denilson
As was heard said at the Emirates Stadium by one frustrated supporter, “a traffic cone would be more useful than Denilson”. It's hard to disagree.
He's become the king of the sideways pass and the lazy attempts to track back. He only seems to have one gear and doesn't offer the midfield drive that even the likes of Abou Diaby give. Compared to how dynamic Jack Wilshere has been, Denilson looks laboured and slow in the midfield.
What I found ironic about his statements in the media about wanting to leave was that if he was so desperate to win trophies, maybe he should have worked harder on the pitch by occasionally tracking back and lifting his head up to pass the ball forward. I doubt many fans shed a tear on hearing news of him wanting out.
Verdict: Form an orderly queue to drive him to his next destination: 3/10.
16. Aaron Ramsey
After a long rehabilitation and a couple of loan spells, we finally saw Aaron Ramsey back in first team action in March. He didn't have many games to make his mark, but showed enough promise that he can regain the form he had before his horrific injury.
The highlight of his season was his excellent finish to score the only goal against Manchester United. Although most Arsenal fans don't want to have to cope with life without Cesc Fabregas just yet, eventually he'll go back to Barcelona, and in Ramsey we could have his replacement. Whilst we want Arsene Wenger to sign experienced players, it could be detrimental to the club if any experience that comes in slows the development and growth of players like Ramsey.
The Welshman played as well as we could have hoped on return from injury. Unlike Tomas Rosicky and Eduardo, the injury doesn't seem like it'll have a lasting effect on the rest of his career.
Verdict: Was just good to see him back in action, next season will be crucial to his development: 5/10.
17. Alex Song
It wasn't a spectacular season from the Cameroonian, but it wasn't a bad one. Song is definitely the best holding midfielder in the squad, however early in the season it seemed he'd forgotten his duties as defensive player as he frequently got caught out of position.
His attacking did add some valuable goals to his game, notably against Manchester City, West Ham and Chelsea, but that meant players like Jack Wilshere had to sit further back to cover for Song, when realistically we'd prefer to see Wilshere in more advanced positions. Song has also developed an annoying habit of regularly getting booked for needless fouls in the midfield. I don't mind players taking the occasional card for the team if it stops a flowing attack, but Song seems to attract them all too easily.
He's a good player, and a good holding midfielder when he sticks to his task, however I think there are many that think Song's position is one where the club could improve. Being really critical, it could be argued that Song isn't the world class holding midfielder we need to make the next step to regularly winning trophies. He's definitely deserving of a place in the squad though.
Verdict: A decent season with room for improvement: 6/10.
19. Jack Wilshere
As much as Arsenal fans have little love or appreciation for Bolton Wanderers, there is no doubt a regular place in their team did wonders for Jack Wilshere. He came back from his loan spell in 2009/10 ready to play regular Premier League football, and offer Arsenal a huge improvement on the likes of Denilson and Diaby in midfield.
The fact it's hard to think of a game where Wilshere didn't play well this season tells its own story. His fitness and commitment was admirable for a player of his age, and should be used as an example to the rest of the squad. It's refreshing to see an Englishman come through in the mould of a modern Arsenal player, but have the tenacity to stand up to clubs who take the physical approach against Arsenal. It means Arsene Wenger and the fans have no worries in putting Wilshere up against any opponent, be it Barcelona or Stoke.
He does have to watch his temper, but if he eradicates it from his game completely, he'll risk losing some of the passion he plays the game with. It's difficult to pick out a standout match, but Barcelona at home does stick in my mind. Although Wilshere didn't see as much of the ball as other games, he was sensational. He didn't look out of place against the like of Xavi and Iniesta.
We can all be glad that sense prevailed and Wilshere hasn't gone to the under 21 European Championships with England. From an Arsenal point of view, it means we could see him develop further next season.
Verdict: Fantastic breakthrough season, has the potential to be the mainstay of this Arsenal team for years to come: 9/10.
40. Craig Eastmond
He spent most of the season out on loan, but did play a couple of Carling Cup games and a Champions League game in the season for Arsenal.
I think it'll be hard to Eastmond to become a regular in the club's first team squad, especially if a new midfielder is signed. He did well in the Carling Cup, but in his European debut away to Shakhtar Donetsk, he did look horribly out of his depth, capping his performance with an own goal.
It's too early to judge him at Arsenal. Having been on loan at Millwall, hopefully he'll be loaned out to a club higher up the footballing ladder to see if he'll cut it at Arsenal.
Verdict: Didn't appear much and was mixed when he did: 4/10.
46. Henri Lansbury
Lansbury only made one start for Arsenal this season, but I'd surprised if he didn't make more next season.
That one start was in the Carling Cup at White Hart Lane, where he scored against Tottenham. He made a few other good substitute appearances in the competition before going to Norwich City on loan. He wasn't always a starter for the Canaries, but played well and contributed heavily to their promotion to the Premier League.
Pre-season will be a key time for Lansbury as he'll want to make an impression so as to stay in the first team squad, otherwise he could end up out on loan again. He won't want to go the same way as Mark Randall, a similar player who went on loan to numerous clubs before finally being released in his early twenties.
Verdict: A good goal at the Lane before a productive loan spell: 5/10.
type="text/javascript">
Follow ESPNsoccernet's Football Correspondents on Twitter
Comments
 |
Posted by Gary on 06/15/2011
You've made some excellent points Sam. In terms of the Midfield let's start with the positives Jack Wilshire is only gonna get better and he's already sensational, and providing he gets a good number of games I think Aaron Ramsey could have a big impact next season.
If Fabragas and Nasri stay I hope both show plenty of heart for the club, meanwhile Abou Diaby is simply a poor-man's Patrick Vieira he has had numerous opportunities but he isn't good enough.
Hopefully Alex Song uses his brain a bit more and good riddance to Denilson. Arsenal need a bit of steel in midfield (Scott Parker) and maybe someone like Eden Hazzard as well.
Get the cheque book out Arsene! Up the Gunners for next season.
 |
Posted by Cliff Holdorff on 06/16/2011
I think its worth mentioning that we need a spare holding midfielder as well. Song might not be our most sparkly in midfield but is arguably the most missed when injured.
 |
Posted by Andy on 06/16/2011
Song. I'm never quite sure why people rate him so highly. I agree he as improved...a lot. The reason why he gets regularly booked, its because he can't tackle and finds himself out of position. He needs competition and someone to learn from
 |
Posted by Anwar on 06/16/2011
I do not believe that Abou Diaby's primary attribute is defending. he's more of an attacking midfielder. Injuries have stalled his development but every time I see him playing in a more advanced role he always performs well. His eye for defense splitting passes can only be bettered by Fabregas.
I also have to disagree with you on Alex Song's grade. He was one of our star performers. He is a tactician of the highest degree and chipped in on attack when needed. He also, like Diaby, can pick out a good pass. I would like to see him stay in his deeper position but Jack is also good in that position and he can handle the work pretty good.
Rosicky on the other hand needs a run of games to boost his confidence. His movements resemble Modric's and has the vision of fabregas. But at the moment, it would be best if he was an impact sub.
 |
Posted by izuchukwu ben on 06/16/2011
i tink jack haz wat it taks 2 even become Arsnal captain coz of his developmental level kudos 2 him buh people lyk Denilson shuld stop being escorts n find a way out of d club
 |
Posted by Dave C on 06/16/2011
Great assessment Sam, I think you got it spot on. However, here's a few points I like to add :-
- Need to let Fabregas go, althought he is a good player, but he is a very poor captain. We need someone to urge the team to chase the ball and do the necessary shouting and organizing. If Fabregas stays, there is the issue of whether we will have an ego problem that will divide the team in a wrong way.
- We certainly need to buy an additional defensive mid-fielder like Tiote from Newcastle United. We can always have an option to play either Song and this new comer, or, may be both depending who we play against. Let's get Tiote over from Newcastle !
- We probably need to make sure we can hang on to Nasri as he will provide the necessary flare in the middle together with Jack up supporting the stikers in attacks.
 |
Posted by Chiedozie on 06/16/2011
I agree with most of your points, so my comments will be restricted to the few points I disagree with. Ist is Diaby, he gets 4/10 bc he was awful last season. I agree it is difficult to decide wether to keep or offload him bc of the potential that is so glaring, but considering he is already 25, we shouldn't be talking of potential anymore. Second is about Cesc, most commentators seem not to have noticed that our season crashed after his injury against Stoke at home. We practically stopped creating chances from the point he left the pitch. Our attackers are not the same when he is not in the pitch. So even with an injury disrupted season, I will give him 8/10. For me I am scared of Cesc leaving Arsenal. Thirdly, Jack was fantastic last season but he must work on his shooting ability. He frequently gets himself in positions to shoot and score but it seems he never practice scoring in training.So even though he had a season we would want other upcoming players to emulate, he still has room for improvement, 8/10 .
 |
Posted by ignatius on 06/16/2011
Couldn't agree less! Sammy your totally spot on.
Denilson and Diaby don't deserve to don the Arsenal shirt any more. For the latter claim to have a spurs shirt! Total rubbish.
For next season we need a cover for Song. The lad has played too many games. It bound to take its toll on his overall performance and form. He needs some help.I think Melo would be an ideal candidate.
 |
Posted by ISACXON on 06/16/2011
Sam,
I think you are spot on most players. Denilson, Diaby and Rosicky (feel bad i have to say this abt the Czech)have to go. Song got exhausted as the season grew older, thank God there was Wilshere to help out. Guess Song can still be good, you may not have as many options on the Market.We may need to get Soctt Parker, he is the only good option available, but his English and wud thus cost a tooth and a nail. Nasri is at times so laxed, he needs to put in more passion. CESC, only God knows.. i feel we should Cash in, let the Boy find his dreams and then have a player whose heart is in London. Eden Hazard, Scott Parker in, Diaby, Denilson, Rosicky out. And i thought THEO WALCOTT was also a midfielder,I wouldnt want him judged as a striker, he will be even more pathetic then. Sam clarify.
You could also give suggestions of replacements. We all know who deserves to go, we may not know who deserves to come in as replacement.
Sam Limbert: Many thanks for your comments. With Theo Walcott, I'm going to include him in the 'forwards' assessment in my next post. Due to our formation, it can be hard to judge who is a striker and who isn't, so I'm going to write it about forward players and include Walcott and Arshavin in that category as attacking wingers.
For replacements, I think there will be promotion from within the squad with the likes of Ramsey and Lansbury getting more matches. I'd like to see someone like Scott Parker signed for the midfield to compliment Jack and the creativity of Cesc. Even though he'd be available after West Ham's relegation, I'd be surprised if Wenger bought him.
 |
Posted by naz on 06/16/2011
denilson,diaby..out...get back seb larsson..he's good 4 us..
 |
Posted by Philip on 06/16/2011
Agree with most of your comments, but:
1. Song's rating is too negative. His value to the team is witnessed by how poorly they did in games he sat out due to injuries. Also, he pickts up too many cards in part because too often the team views him as the only midfielder to do dirty work. Everyone must defend! If everyone pitched in, Song would have fewer cards.
2. Diaby ain't great, but he's not as bad depicted, especially when healthy. I'd give him another year, play him only when healthy (goes for Cesc, too) and expect a strong bounce-back season.
 |
Posted by Hicks on 06/16/2011
Hicks.It was a good assessment,sell Diaby,Denilson,
Rosicky,Squilacci,Almunia,Clichy,Bendtner.And then
recruit 2 to 3 from side B.also buy Gary Cahill,Samba C.,Scott Parker and Gervihno.I'm sure this will bring competition amongst players and it will benefit the club as players will be putting in
much more.
 |
Posted by David Chow on 06/16/2011
Fully agree with Dave C's remarks about the poor leadership qualities displayed by Fabregas as a captain despite he is one of the mvp as a player. One of the bad shows was the 4-4 match with Newcastle. Fabregas virtually did little as a decent captain to stall the comeback of Newcastle in the second half of the game.
On the other hand, I find van Persie when acting captain during the absence of Fabregas was far more impressive in leading and inspiring his team members to give their best.
 |
Posted by Jimmy on 06/16/2011
Hahaha...
Denilson - Verdict: Form an orderly queue to drive him to his next destination: 3/10.
Good work Sam!
Have to agree with your assesments. Just hope Rambo can get back to the form he was in before that horrific assault by Sh*wcr*ss - if he can then thats adding an extra good 'un to a good midfield (also if we can sign an extra CB Djourou was being primed for a DM role 2 seasons ago before his big injury, maybe he or the verminator can take on the mantle of boss man in the centre)
 |
Posted by Calchas on 06/16/2011
Sam, I believe you were right on with your assessments. However, I think you rated Diaby to high. His impact was minimal. Every positive he brings to the the table is tempered by too many negatives. Jack Wilshere has great potential, but I wish everyone would stop anointing him as the "next great"..... He has a lot of postive qualities, but does not yet bring enough tangible results to the game. He was not a high assist or goal contributor this season. To be considered great in my mind, you need to score or be directly involved in creating chances for your side if you are an attacking player. He is not there yet. In terms of Cesc, yes this was a down year for someone of his quality, but the numbers don't lie... If you look at the squads goal scoring numbers when he plays versus when he does not, there is a decided difference. Currently he is the only one in the midfield who generates consistent results in the final third.
 |
Posted by Sam R on 06/16/2011
Great comments Sam. I agree almost completely with you and everyone else who has commented thus far. The very first piece of business that must be taken care of is Nasri's contract. He has become more vital than cesc, plus he doesn't weigh us down with the dread of having to listen to barca cry about him every day.
I still believe in Rosicky unlike Denilson and Diaby. I'd like to get Parker and see Frimpong and Lansbury promoted in their place. I believe Frimpong will be the CDM cover we have been looking for.
As for fabregas...I don't know any more. He is so often irreplaceable. But that being said we are always bigger than 1 player. Henry was a million times more important to us but we are still alive w/o him. I want him to go at this point because Van Persie should be captain for he utterly loves Arsenal and his passion is contagious. The fact that we have a barca lover as captain is only more reason to let him go. At least that would shut Xavi and Puyol up for a couple seconds.
 |
Posted by JoeUSA on 06/16/2011
Good review overall, but I think more credit needs to be given to Song. Their season took a downturn around the time when he missed a few matches, and barring the emergence of Frimpong, they don't have anyone who can replace him.
Song improved his passing and technical ability as well this season, as evidenced by his occasional effectiveness going forward. I think he is actually one of the better holding midfielders in the premier league, although he could improve his positioning even further.
 |
Posted by David Fitch on 06/16/2011
A good assessment cannot disagree with it but the missing factor is there fragility in fact the same could be said for the whole team this was best demonstrated against Newcastle how much you change personnel is only one part the other is more complicated and harder to solve.
 |
Posted by bola on 06/17/2011
Fair comments Sam.Can't fault you too much.However, after much patience, I think Diaby and Rosicky should ship out.Chidozie was spot on.Tiote of Newcastle is the boy/man we need.He is Gattuso/Parker/Seedorf all wrapped into one.
 |
Posted by Kamal Zharif on 06/17/2011
Great comments Sam, but in your opinion, would moving up Koscielny into the holding midfield role would be a step back? Koscielny have proven to be very good ball control, as well as a good defender when the ball is on the ground. He could be a la Petit.
Sam Limbert: Thanks for the comment. Koscielny as a defensive midfielder is an interesting thought. I could see him doing well in that position as he's quick and good in one-on-one situations, however his passing and distribution of the ball would require some work.
 |
Posted by thomas on 06/17/2011
Out: Denilson, Diaby, Rosicky, Clichy, Fabregas, Almunia, Squillaci.
In: Hazard, Defour, Gervinho, Samba, Christian Ericksen, Gourcuff, Scott Parker
 |
Posted by titansgunners12thman on 06/17/2011
I pretty much agree. However, much of these criticism (sp) should be directed at Wenger. It's pretty clear Diaby is not defensive mid. He has always shown he has better dribble and attacking skils than defensive knowhow. Why Wenger plays him in a withdrawn role is beyond me. He would be much better in the role RVP plays. Fabregas is simply not captain material.
Rosicky and Denilson's time is up. Everyone, including them, knows this.
Song has been excellent in his role. Wilshere as well. Nasri was our best player, has improved each year he has been here, and deserves a newer, richer contract. Ramsey I still hold judgement on, let's see how he blossoms when he returns to full fitness.
My ideal midfield for the Arsenal: Song and Wilshere Holding, Nasri and Fabregas Attacking. With Walcott and RVP as forwards.
 |
Posted by Dan on 06/17/2011
You are right, there will be some comments you made which many will disagree. I am one of them. I believe, you have made error in rating Diaby. 5/10? Are you sure? He deserves a 2 or a 3 for me. Take a look at every game Diaby plays in. I find it really hard to think that Mr Wenger rates this guy highly. I am not sure if many of you noticed that he is clumsy. Makes clumsy tackles, makes clumsy passes, doesn't track back when we are being attacked, doesn't challenge for loose balls. These are all the ingredients of a clumsy, lousy player. One of you mentioned that his potential is glaring. Seriously? What potential does he have? One of you also said that no one player is bigger than the club. I totally agree! Which means, Samir Nasri can go. Before Nasri came, who was he? Patrick Vieira, Petit, Henry were not household names. These players were struggling for their previous clubs. If Nasri goes, so be it. I am sure we can unearth talents still undiscovered, be it in England or elsewhere
 |
Posted by Tom on 06/17/2011
Dude, learn how to spell and edit. "How good he good could be" and "site" instead of "sight". I'm in middle school, now I think I could hold down this job.
Sam Limbert: Thanks for the comment, good spot, it's been ammended.
 |
Posted by francis chidozie on 06/17/2011
I believe the idea of letting Nasri move from Arsenal this summer should be rebuffed,knowing fully well that Fab is nolonger in the Club with all his mind.I want to encourage all Arsenal Fans that this coming season will be great with trophies.I would like Wenger to stick to Cahill and Samba as the duo are the calibre of people needed by the club in that defence.Wenger should also intensify his search for Goal Keeper,it seems much attention has not been given in that area.Scezzney can be injure at any point(as in the case of Bacelona in the champions league).Let us remember that his injury caused us all the trophies we rely on after a disgraceful display by Almunia.Pls our cover up keepers should not be any how keepers.
 |
Posted by alex kramsky on 06/17/2011
yes its right time to sell few player who didnt made any progress like Denilson,about the rosicky i am sure to keep him because of his creativity and experiences even only like substitute player he ist still high rated for czech national team and play very well for them,song is clever use his head,to sell Bentner will be big mistake i think,to buy some experienced players will be competition at all the corners.
 |
Posted by Brian on 06/18/2011
Great break down of the midfield...agree across the board. Would like to see Wenger get rid of Rocesky, Diaby, Squillaci, Bentdner, Clichy, Almunia. I also wouldn't mind seeing him cut his loses on Fabregas, if Barca is willing to part with a couple of their star yougnsters as well, I think Ramsey, Wilshire and Song/Nasri is a strong midfield and if they can bring in a veteran like Parker and a up and comer like Rodwell I think they would be solid for the next several years. The additions of Cahill and Samba in the back and possibly the return of Upson on a free would really solidify the center of the defense and possibly stealing Given away from Man City to start until Szcezny has fully seasoned would be fantastic. Also Oxlade-Chamberlin and Eto, if he is truely available would really get me excited for next season.
 |
Posted by Brian on 06/18/2011
Would like to see Wenger end the Squillaci debaucle and save him anymore pain. He's just not up to Premiership standards. I would also like to see him cash in on Clichy while he still has value. I don;t think he has improved since he became Cole's replacement and I think it is time to give Gibbs or Traore a shot.
Wenger also needs to add some strength, heart and consistancy in the middle, Samba seemed to almost be trying out for Wenger when Blackburn met Arsenal late in the season and Cahill is a must addition. I would also like to see Wenger add some experince by bringing Upson back on a free transfer, I think those three additions in the middle and possibly an outside back would really solidify the back line.
Also go save Given from the bench at Man City. Let him start until Szcezny is fully ready.
 |
Posted by mark on 06/18/2011
first let me make it clair that i am not an arsenal fan but i like they style of play .what i think that is missing from the squad is a good centre back a good holding midfielder and a topclass goalkeeper.If those three areas can be sorted arsenal would be a power side next season .
 |
Posted by dass04 on 06/18/2011
Let CESC go now rather than later, he is good but also a failed captain who stays quite when his ship is about to sink. In captaincy he is nowhere near the charisma of Patrick Vieira when negligent displays from fellow players were not tolarated. I believe CESC replacements are out there waiting for the opportunity.give the armband to RVP. The dutch has arsenal in his heart and always fight for the club
 |
Posted by moustapha yakub on 06/18/2011
as an arsenal fan all my credits go to wilshere, song, nasri, szsesny
 |
Posted by johnny on 06/18/2011
pls fans let Fab go altough he is a good player but all this go and no go makin problem for the club if u want to win smtin perform there is someone like Messi he perform and they ar winning but for Nasri he should go if he want to who no him before he came to the club now he is talkin bla bla who is he he was the one complaning about Galas does he forget or not, Nasri u ar a good player not a great player notin specially the club should buy 2 or 3 energetic players it will be good we have many skillful players we just need some distroyers it doest mean they ar good or not just to run arround we will win sometin big, we ar too perfect thts our problems we need to mix with unskill players like brimgram kind of, Diady, Rocky, Asrvin should stay and tell wockt to take it easy not to run before ball he can be a great player and for Van p.s i love u ucan be a great captain for the club after Fab, Song u ar the best keep it up
 |
Posted by mike on 06/18/2011
i really appreciate you for the well done job on the current information about the transfer of my loving club. i am Nigerian and i started supporting arsenal in the year 1999 till today. what you said about the players are real but where i want changes or supports are the striking forces, midfielders and defenders. in the likes of vermaleen, he needs a good experienced helper. then at the midfield, i want Arsen wenger to to sell or offload Denilson,chamark,and vela and the worst player there is Diaby which i have told Professor wenger to sell that french man and use his money to by good player.D worst people i want to be offloaded frm arsenal are diaby, Denison and chamark.i love arsenal and always crying when ever we loose matches against small clubs like westbrom, newcastle and hospur especially when we loose at home. i love this club and will never disappoint them to join other clubs.please Arsen wenger remove shame from us and buy good and experience player.long live arsenal.
 |
Posted by Maran on 06/20/2011
Overall fair comments. But it was interesting to read your thoughts on Diaby. It was like reading Arsene. Diaby is actually good; Diaby has potential but he was injured; give the boy some time.."It's hard to know whether to persevere with Diaby as there is a quality player in there". This conuindrum of Arsene had led to wasteful matches where Diaby was featured. And this was somewhat reflective of the entire midfield story of Arsenal in the last season. Too many players fielded for their "potential" or past performances and not based on their current form. A lot of time had been wasted. The likes of Denilson, Diaby and Rosicky had been given too many games. Cut it out. Way too often we had performed badly due to the midfield. Midfield is the heart to the team but unfortunately it lacked the heart to perform regularly. The midfield lacked the teeth it should have. My assessment for our failure is that we had many players with only potential, with no heart given their places in the team.
 |
Posted by Maran on 06/20/2011
The story of Nasri is a little unbelievable but justifiable. Although the nature of his response may be unpalatable to us, but I can agree in the context that any good player with the right frame of mind will question Arsenal's ambitions. Buying second class players and not addressing the obvious weaknesses of the team does not exactly reflect ambitions. It can be very frustrating. Nasri worked his socks off on many occassions, only to see the hard work spoiled by horrific defending. And his performances at the end of campaign was telling of his emotions. What's the point? I agree that he is needed in the team, and so is Fabregas and the key is ambition. DO the necessary for this ambition, they will regain their will. As for Fab, my head tells me sell and make the money, but, my heart want him to stay. With or without the injuries, he is the best player, although he was a pale shadow of himself last season. The decision this time will be the key for his future and Arsenal's future.
 |
Posted by ifeanyi udemezue on 06/20/2011
I agree with your assessment of each of the players though i am of the view that the midfield should be overhauled. Players like Rosicky, Diaby and Denilson should be allowed to go as they contribute little or nothing on the pitch. Also, we should start preparing forlife without Fabregas as i suspect that he may leave for Barcelona this summer. In which case the correct price should be placed on his head.It will be a shame though if he goes there and starts warming the bench. In addition, we need a back up for Song.
 |
Posted by jaykun on 06/20/2011
I agree with your thoughts. I personally think we should let Fab go, no point keeping a player whose heart is thinking of what would have been. I also believe we need a natural DM (not a converted player) to give song competition/substitution. I dont know how ready Frimpong his but i think Tiote or Melo would fit in. Changes needs to be made. I thnk we should let Almunia, Squillaci, Denilson, Diaby, Rosicky and Bendtner go and bring in experinced/quality in 2 CB, a DM, and a CF while also ensuring we keep Nasri.
 |
Posted by emma on 06/20/2011
 |
Posted by Jesse on 06/20/2011
Well done Sam, this midfield assessment reflected my sentiments on most of the players and you're not bad with the humorous jibes -- think we can all agree to volunteer our time in showing Mr. Denilson the door!
I'll join the growing chorus in making the difficult but necessary decision to let Cesc go. His lack of full commitment to the club is palpable on the pitch, and he strikes me as the sort of immensely talented player that yearns to play second or third fiddle -- not only is Barca his hometown club, but he'll shine without the glare of the spotlight that will focus much more on the likes of Messi, Xavi, et al. (for you NBA fans, Cesc has the deferring spirit/freak talent combo of LeBron James, methinks). In complete contrast, RvP has the mind and soul of a captain and an Arsenal heart through and through.
Lastly, are you planning on doing a Wenger assessment Sam? I hope you will, not just for your input but to hear other fan comments. I just hope he reads this blog . . . .
Sam Limbert: Thanks for the your comments. My next post will be the ratings of the strikers, and after that I'll focus on Arsene Wenger and transfers we have or haven't completed.
 |
Posted by youngGun15 on 06/21/2011
As much as we all know that Cesc wants to go to Barca, the complicated piece of evidence is that he says that he wants to be at Arsenal. Look at Modric, he says that he wants to leave spurs to go to Chelsea etc. and has almost done everything, but put in a transfer request.
However, in Cesc case, he says that he's happy at Arsenal and wants to stay (but would be happy at Barca, and to be honest who wouldn't). As, much as I think we should cash in on him, if he stays it only proves how much he loves Arsenal and how large his loyalty to both Wenger and the club.
 |
Posted by Raymond on 06/21/2011
I agree with you. First of all
DENILSON, shouldn't be in the squad for this 2011/12 season
DIABY? His first touch with the ball, his passing skill and temprament is questionable. His only + point is his height. Can't relay on him, better sell him.
NASRI,WILSHERE and WALCOTT have a really good season and we hope they will be the crucial parts of the team for many years to come.
Song, since there is no one better then him for def mid position, should stay at the starting XI.
RAMSEY is young and promising, hopefully he will become better and better.
CESC is always a good player. Just the barca fever problem is always there. Arsenal will miss him if go to Barca but Nasri can cover it. Arsenal is good with him but also ok without him.
ROSICKY is a back up. He can play at he right, left or centre jut in case injury probleam appear.
ARSHAVIN hopefully he can reach his best form again.
PLEASE SIGN 1 or 2 GOOD CENTRE BACK. VERM NEED CAPABLE PARTNERS.
 |
Posted by Black Hei on 06/21/2011
Fair comments especially regarding Diaby and Denilson. And I think they are bad because Wenger screwed up their development.
Diaby made his full debut long time ago as a defensive midfielder against BOLTON with a MOM performance! We all thought "Viera with pace" but Wenger saw a left winger?!?!!! And played Diaby in that position. Nowadays, Diaby is confused as to what he is supposed to do, and I don't blame him.
When Denilson made his EPL bow, everyone was like "WOW mini Cesc!" As if Cesc wasn't mini enough back then. And what did Wenger saw? Gilberto.
Nowadays they are both washed up. Good thing Wenger did not screw Wilshire up and play him as a winger or something.
Just want to be fair to those 2 since everyone is hitting on them. They play like nonsense nowadays but they had potential long time ago.
 |
Posted by Jen on 06/22/2011
I don't agree with your ratings for Alex Song. I think he was an extremely important player for us especially last season. He didn't just defend well, he also scored many goals. A top-class player in my eyes.
 |
Posted by martin on 06/22/2011
Yes, Diaby may have had a bad season but we should not over look the fact that a player is not always 100% fit throughout the season. Some seasons players do perfom well but some when affected by countless injuries they may not do as expected.I think Arsenal needs a player like Diaby on specific matches since he has the ability to make good decisions at the right time.
I think keeping Nasri a Cesc is a selfish act from Wenger. He must just let the youngsters play where they wish and make sure that they enjoy life as they want to. Lets not forget that these guys have put in so much for arsenal and its not their fault that they did so at a time when they have won nothing. They probably feel that they still have a chance to fill their cabinets with silver ware playing for a team with a winning thirst. Frankly, looking at the clubs that are after them, one would not doubt what these guys can achieve at these clubs. Wenger must just let them go then we can build up from there.
 |
Posted by Izuchi Enyinnaya on 06/22/2011
I will not agree any less with most of your comments,however,I wish to mention that Diaby is not such a bad player,yes his football has been stalled in recent years because of injury,yet on the day he turns up on pitch,no mid fielder will be better than him. I think we should keep him as a squad member.
I have a little problem with nasri i think he should be more ruthless in front of goal he s got all the qualities but can he replace Fabregas succesfully ? i say NO
so he needs to improve his game.
I will ignore comments on Arsharvin cos I feel he performed below his own standard this season but stats will show that he gave the highest assists along with Van persie.
 |
Posted by John Swaray on 06/23/2011
I will prefer Fabrigas to go to Barca because he has more interest in Barca presently than Arsenal. I want to surgest that let Wenger agree on a reasonable fees to let Fabrigas go. He has not been inform since he declared his intention go and I believe he not prove well if he stay with Arsenal coming season. He made alot of mistakes in some of the game. It is hard for Wengar to buy but he knows good player to buy. Finally, I will like Arshelvin, Charmah, Bednerd, Diaby, Rosicky, Alumonia, Fabiansky to leave the club.
 |
Posted by fabian on 06/29/2011
Football is a team affair, not just one person.
Cesc's injury has exposed a major observation. (1)over reliance on an individual !!!
This is a major risk to Arsenal Football Club.
It is unthinkable that Arsene Wenger is so obsessed by Cesc's talent that he is blind to the fact that our beloved football team can't function without one person.
If this is the manner of which Wenger runs a football team, all of us Arsenal fans have to suffer another long period of drought.
The club will still reward him for his incredible gift of finding young and cheap players. Then sell them for decent profits for the shareholders. Question we as fans should pose.. whats the motivation and priority of Arsenal Football Club ? I am not against having a financial healthy footbal club, but if Wenger is that great as we think he is, a balance of resources should be dedicated to building a winning team.
I believe for the sake of Arsenal, Cesc and Wenger, only one should stay !
 |
Posted by stuartray on 06/30/2011
Honestly, I don't know why all the fuss about Fiberglass? I'll admit the team plays better with him, but maybe they practice with him as the engine and don't have a plan B. IMO he is slow, loses posession too frequently while taking too long to decide what to do, then makes a bad tackle. His instances of "genius" are far too infrequent and not that genius. Add to that the fact that he is a useless captain, and the result is he is grossly overrated. Nasri has much more skill and talent, and I think would revel in that central midfield.
Apart from the obvious needs in defense and too many mediocre gutless individuals, Arsenal needs a dead ball specialist. Most of RVP's free kicks are up in the sky, Fab's are weak like a child. Nasri has some potential and maybe Vermalen too. A consistent hard bullet shooter like Drogba is needed badly.
As for Wenger, I wonder at times if he is going senile, or if he is a puppet of the board. I don't believe that he believes his own crap about quality.
 |
Posted by Obiora Okechukwu on 07/02/2011
what I know is that Wenger is a good coach that knows the right thing to do to stop this trophiless seasons. LET ARSENAL GO FOR WHAT THEY KNOW FOR IN HENRY THEM TIME
 |
Posted by Seye on 07/13/2011
I like Abou Diaby but I hate his inconsistencies. 5 bad matches, 2 good ones. dribbles 8 opponents, makes a faulty pass that lands at the feet of the 9th one. that sums him up for now but like Wenger, I wanna give hime the benefit of the doubt because if he stays injury free, he fits into certian matches effortlessly. Denilson was touted to be a regular starter the season after Arsenal's last league win at OT (rmbr, RvP's lovely equalizer and Manu Eboue's 92nd minute cross for Titi). Where did it go wrong?
If ARsenal must be great again, let there be competition. Alex SOng is good but he strolls into the team. He needs competition and back-up. Should Cesc and Nasri go? I want them both to stay but if they cannot be convinced, then they better leave. Mr. Wenger is a very patient person, as evidenced in one Mr. Senderos who despite 'sending errors' for years, stayed and even had the audacity to complain that he wasn't reg
Let Wenger ring the changes, and we'll see where we are next May
 |
 |
| |
Post your comment |
 |
|
|
|
|
About
Sam Limbert: My retirement as a football player came at the age of 14 due to being rubbish, it's fair to say I was more Kaba Diawara than Thierry Henry, so I turned my focus to writing about the game. I'm a lifelong Arsenal fan and have been lucky enough to watch the team across England and Europe. My favourite Gunner of all time is Dennis Bergkamp, and the 2004 Invincibles is the greatest side I've ever seen in English football. I try to be positive about the Arsenal as it's the hope that keeps us going! Follow me on twitter @SamsMatchReport.
|
Categories
Recent Posts
Archives
|