ESPN Soccernet - Correspondents - Arsenal
soccernet blog
Arsenal
Posted by David Young on 03/03/2011

It has been a rough week for Arsenal and their supporters. Losing any final is always hard to bear and Sunday's Carling Cup Final was a huge disappointment. It has to be said though that some of the reaction to that defeat has been ridiculous and it seems that perspective has been lost in certain quarters.

You would be forgiven for thinking that some pundits (and some Arsenal supporters) assumed that it would just be a case of the Gunners simply showing up at Wembley, coasting through 90 minutes and it would be more or less a foregone conclusion that Birmingham would roll over and we would pick up a cup at the end of the afternoon.

That was never going to be how it was. This was one of the biggest days in the Blues’ history and it was inevitable that they would be up for the game and be a far tougher prospect than they may be on a week-by-week basis. Credit and congratulations to them, they played well and with a lot of heart. However, the game was lost by Arsenal because of an accident and not because they were overwhelmed by their opponents.





Disappointment at Wembley©Getty Images


Admittedly, the Gunners’ overall performance was frustratingly below par and certain players did not rise to the occasion. However, in the last twenty minutes, as Arsene Wenger’s men laid siege to the Birmingham goal, it seemed that there would only be one winner if the match went to extra time. It was no coincidence that Ben Foster, the Brummie’s goalkeeper, was named as man of the match. Football can be a cruel game though and it was the freak mix-up between Koscielny and Szczesny that settled the tie. It was a dreadful mistake and, sadly, it happened so late in the game that there was no time for a reply.

This incident and, indeed, the defeat gave ammunition to certain sections of the media and the Arsenal fanbase to start hysterically moaning, criticising and complaining that Wenger should have bought in the window, that we need a new defender and that we need a new goalkeeper. Players have always only ever been “as good as their last game” but, these days, because of the saturation coverage that football gets in the press and on the internet, reaction is so much more extreme. One week you are a god, the following week you are an amoeba and the next match coming up is always the biggest and most season-defining game of the year.

Two weeks ago, Laurent Koscielny’s performance against Barcelona was rightly praised. That night, he was lauded the answer to Arsenal’s central defensive conundrums in the absence of Thomas Vermaelen. Following the Birmingham match though, we apparently need a new central defender again. He was culpable for the mix-up that gifted Obafemi Martins with the winner but he doesn’t become a bad player just because he makes one error. It was a gutting way to lose but let’s not lose sight of the fact that it was down to a freak mistake.

The Carling Cup Final actually reminded me a lot of the 1995 Cup Winners Cup Final when Arsenal faced Real Zaragoza in Paris. That evening, Arsenal were warm favourites to retain the trophy they had won the year before. However, they were out of sorts on the night and fell behind. John Hartson equalised reasonably quickly and, like Sunday, it was a case of “next goal wins it”. 1-1 at full-time, the match went into half-an-hour’s extra time. As the minutes ticked away a penalty shoot-out looked increasingly likely - and if it came to that, we had David Seaman who had won the penalty-shootout for Arsenal against Sampdoria in the semi-final.

But it didn’t come to that. Seaman, the man we had all assumed would be the hero of the hour, got caught off his line in the last minute of extra-time by a speculative 40-yard effort from Nayim. Again, it was a freak mishap. Again, there was no time to reply. Again, it was a gutting way to lose. However, as a fan, you just have to swallow it and move on. No one thought Arsenal needed a new goalkeeper just because Seaman had made one mistake. He got us to the final that year - just as Koscielny helped get us to the Carling Cup Final this year with his headed goal against Ipswich in the semi-final.

Arsenal were largely on a hiding to nothing on Sunday. Had they won, they would only have been doing what was expected and, after all, “it’s only the Carling Cup”. However, them losing is suddenly a big story. Whatever. It was an upsetting way to lose but players and fans alike have just got to take it on the chin, move on and focus on the other things that can still be achieved this season.

And there is plenty to still achieve this season. Last night saw the Gunners ruthlessly dispense with Orient in the FA Cup replay which now sets up a quarter-final tie with Manchester United. The victory came courtesy fine hat-trick from Nicklas Bendtner and further goals from Marouane Chamakh and Gael Clichy. In the post-Carling Cup fallout, it was positive that Bendtner and Chamakh both found the net as their confidence in front of goal will need to be on the up whilst they deputise for the injured Robin Van Persie in the coming weeks.

Saturday sees the visit of Sunderland to Ashburton Grove and, with United dropping points at Stamford Bridge in the week, this will be an opportunity for the Gunners to close the gap at the top of the table. Injuries to Van Persie, Walcott and Fabregas won’t make matters easier but it’s a squad game and it’s time for some of the second-string players to step up to the plate and show their worth.

Follow ESPNsoccernet's Football Correspondents on Twitter

Comments

Posted by thekid on 03/03/2011

Agreed. Lot of b1tching and moaning on the blogs, a few gunners fans need to stop turning on the team every time the slightest thing goes wrong. wait for the post-season to be calling for player's heads, now's not the time. having said that, i thought it was the wrong decision to leave vp on as long as aw did, he was clearly injured and we all know how fragile he is, he's the best finisher in the league but he's like the boy in the bubble when it comes to injuries. worse than that, should have replaced rosicky for marouane 5, not the russian. arshavin might have been tiring a little but rosicky just looked so blunt and imprecise on the day that he seemed the obvious one to come off. arshavin has a spark that tomas simply doesn't have.

Posted by jonnygunner'65 on 03/03/2011

I've read pot-loads of people's opinions and thoughts online since our sickening loss to Brum at the weekend,but none as well reasoned as this one.I agree with everything you've written in this article,and you've put a lot of perspective into what you've written-a rarity indeed.
Barca will be tough,but the league is a real possibility for us this year.It was only a matter of time before Man United dropped points,and now we're right on their tails.
If our lads keep the belief,then the Premiership could well be ours this year.
Before Barca we have Sunderland who are a difficult team on occasions - it kind of depends on which Sunderland team turns up-not unlike us !
Lets hope we turn up and they don't on Saturday............

Posted by Spencer on 03/03/2011

Well done. That is spot on.

Posted by godesman on 03/03/2011

i think scezeny was the cause.there should be communication within the penalty area.with fabregas playing in our next game i am confident we are going to be victorious.keep faith gunners fans.

Posted by ifeanyi udemezue on 03/03/2011

Very comforting Dave!! The struggle definitely continues. We just have to find some consistency at this run in time. The premier league championship is there for the taking.

Posted by bablo on 03/03/2011

in a nut-shell we i mean arsenal are not destined to win d league cup.d league is still on, FA cup, and d cup we dream of champions league. God help us.

Posted by Justin on 03/03/2011

Great comments on a bit of a "damned if you do..." situation.

I'd say you're spot on about the tea-cup-tempest that is the present state of sports journalism, particularly on the internet. As well there's the influence of console games on fan's sense of reality: when I can play Fifa for PlayStation and sell off all my reserves to get Messi and Casillas onto the Gunners, or take Wycombe up through the divisions to a spot at the summit of the Champions League in five undefeated seasons on the highest difficulty level, little things like the realities of uneven performances by highly talented but thoroughly human beings in actual life become that little bit easier to forget about.

For me, the great thing about watching sport is that the experience of drama, tension, highs, and lows that are (thankfully!) absent from most of our daily lives most of the time.Taking the depths along with the heights is, or should be, part of the pleasure.

Posted by lungani masuku on 03/03/2011

yah lets frget abt carling cup dn focus on sunder nd barca

Posted by Weedz on 03/03/2011

The mere fact that the Brum scored, let alone twice, is enough for me to believe that our highly payed players choked in this game.
Take away the school-boy error in the 89th min and we`re still left with poor defending, rubbish passing and a totally leaderless display that, IMO. leaves the our team open to the ridicule they deserve for this display

Posted by Jevett on 03/03/2011

Excellent post, a bit of perspective is needed. Every team in the league has games they won they probably should have lost and vice versa. Everyone wants to focus on the freak poor results while ignoring freak good results. You don't clean house because of one screw up. Sczelny (I won't bother trying to spell it) appears to be a great keeper in the making, one subpar night notwithstanding. He's basically doubled our clean sheet tally since he's been our No. 1. The doubters seem to overlook that.

We bombarded the goal the last quarter of the game, but Foster was outstanding and we didn't get a goal. It happens. Messie scores that little chip he missed in the Barca game 99 times out of 100. He missed it and we went on to win. It happens.

The Arsenal should have won and didn't. Can't wait for Saturday and Sunderland.

Posted by Stag on 03/03/2011

Too true. Too many of the games where Arsenal haven't got the result they wanted is down to the opposition goal keeper playing out of his skin and getting man of the match. However, with a little more consistency, from some players in particular, Arsenal can definitely go onto win something this year.

Posted by Mike on 03/03/2011

I think Kolscielny was going to kick it, then the goalie yelled and he tried to pull back his kick, but it was far enough along that it made the goalie hesitate. Kind of one of that "Should I shoot it or pass it? crap, I shanked it to no one"

Posted by Angela-Gunner Forever on 03/04/2011

This is awesome. I think if any fan went from loving the gunners to despising them then they do not deserve to call themselves a fan.Being part of Arsenal means being one family and you do not turn on your family in bad times. I still believe that currently there is no better defender than Laurent Koscielny and the best goal keeper is Szczesny. I believe in them and believe that we should all do the same.Faith does get you somewhere and as Fabregas said, there are still 3 more trophies!Our faith can make them or break them. It is a high time we stood by them regardless what happens or what S*** is plastered in the media.

Posted by CK on 03/04/2011

The magic of soccer is that the unexpected does happen - always have a chance to survive - that's why Arsenal can beat Barcelona, Newcastle can collect one point after 4 goals down...etc, uncertain referee decision, luck, error....etc we all have to live with.

They are painful experience. Look forward, PROFESSIONALS. Don't underestimate your opponent ( in forthcoming Sunderland game) as well, do NOT underestimate yourself ( against Barcelona) and the team manager has to keep the cool head to set the fruitful plan B, and solves the injury backup ( more resource like new hopeful from recent FA Cup games)

2 more Wembly Finals to go

Posted by JoeUSA on 03/04/2011

I agree completely. I think the fact that they have shown so much improvement and consistency made the performance and the manner of defeat all the more shocking. My Saturday league team conceded in almost exactly the same manner the day before! But as long as they can pick themselves up, there is a lot to be positive about. I am most concerned right now about the injury to Song.

Posted by Andreas on 03/04/2011

Thanks for putting this into much needed perspective. The reactions have been ridiculous - sack Wenger, sell all the players, etc...

It was unfortunate, but we could very easily have won it had a bit more luck been on our side.

So much more to play for.

Posted by David on 03/04/2011

While I appreciate the level-headed view of the match and especially the costly error late on, I agree with Weedz's post.
My frustration doesn't stem so much from the mixup between Koscielny and Szczesny as what happened in the first 87 minutes of the match against Brum leading up to the gaffe.
There is still a lack of a commanding presence at the back, still an issue defending set pieces, still nobody to win balls in the air and neutralise players such as Zigic.
It is the same problem(s) over and over, and it never seems to get corrected.

Posted by otownballer3 on 03/05/2011

Your article makes me wonder, David, how many Arsenal "fans" even remember that game? Your observations provide needed perspective but a lot of hysterical comments on this site probably come from people who were pissing in their diapers when Nayim beat Seaman.

Posted by Van Bankie on 03/06/2011

Well said,pple tend to forget that this players are human, not just some mechanical equipment that works on input and output basis. Yes, I was pained by the error,and I couldn't help but ask myself why in the 89th minute of a cup final. But hey that's life,so we've gotta move on and despite the disappointment and the irritating write-ups by some columnists, Arsenal fc is my team, and we'll all be here when "the boys"begin to win trophies.

Posted by Peter on 03/06/2011

It was amateur night that day at wembley!
everybody makes mistakes,we agree,but arsenal players make mistakes when it matters most!

Posted by Maran on 03/07/2011

Oh let us not be too critical of our players performance as it is quite possible in football to make mistakes, or lose an odd game or so. Come on, we were talking about a Cup final for goodness sake. Birmingham played the match of a lifetime and that attitude won the match for them, gifted or not. In fact that should be the attitude of any team playing a cup final. Alas, our good Arsenal fellas were playing just another game. Producing a sub-par performance in cup final is a sinful. Who else can do it. Why do we need to go to the stage where one mistake decides a match? Frustrations are normal, especially so when you support a team that doesn't show the right attitude. Family or no family, you yell if you need to. This is football. Players and managers come and go. The passion of the fans stays forever. That earns the right to criticise when they are bad. Leave the molly coddling to the biological family. And this is a blog and it should rightfully contain full range of perspectives.

Posted by Glenn Irwin on 03/07/2011

I still cant believe how we threw away the Carling Cup, Birminghams first goal should be put down to an error by wilshere, fair enuf the pass to him wasnt the greatest, but he could have made more of an effort to get the ball rather than complaining about the pass, whats going on with our passing, one match we are sublime hte next we stink, as for birminghams winner, i think the keeper should have made sure it was his, but alas panic set in, oh well thats another missed opportunity.
Sunderland well the less said the better, always a bogie team for us. we need some devine intervention against Barca.
Come on Guys lets get serious and show the world just how good we are.

Aussie Gunner for life

Posted by RebelRed on 03/08/2011

I agree that with 20 minutes to go there seemed to be only one winner. Brum had put everything into the previous 70 minutes and it was clear to see that their aged team were dropping physically. The goal was a freak and we lost.

Carling cup is not important in itself but winning would have given the team a great pyschological (whew!!) boost. What is worrying is that the players wanted to win something so badly, surely as much as Birmingham, but came out second best I feel over 90 minutes.

For me, our first choice 12/13 have what it takes to be winners. The others still have to convince me but while we wait for them we are very vulnerable as you cannot play a season with only 13 players.

Posted by Anonymous on 03/08/2011

so arsene wenger thinks he ih saving money by not buying decnt defenders, well he is going to lose the club even more money by failing to win anything for the sixth year in a row when fans start realising you dont have to spend vast amounts of money to go and watch a footbal game where your team end up trofiless season after season. i was hoping i got it wrong when i said there isnt going to be anything worth getting excited this season but sadly i was right.

Posted by John on 03/09/2011

I have supported the Arsenal for over 50 years but must admit the player buying policy over the last five or six years has made it almost impossible for them to win anything.
If they had signed three or four additional top quality players over that period it would have made a big difference to their performance, especially with the injuries they get every season.
They are currently doing much better than I thought they would do this season, I did not think they would win anything again this year, and that they would be lucky to finish higher than 4th in the Premier League.
With the other top teams not performing as well as they have done in past seasons this could be the chance for Arsenal to win the League this year, if they do not win it this year it will be much harder for them next year when the other top teams strengthen their squads.
The Arsenal method of play is great to watch but unfortunately the measure of any team is the number of cups they win at the end of the season.

Posted by chris on 03/12/2011

as an arsenal fan ssince birth it hurts me me when i feel arsene wenger and the board are destroying their own fans by ripping them of with overpriced tickets and lies about what the plans for the future. barca play miles better football then arsenal but their tickets arnt as costly. how on earth can they justify the money they are making whilst producing nothing for the fans. mr wenger, if you really love arsenal the move on and take your average injury prone palyers with you. its time to start over again cos this clearly aint working

Posted by fabian neo on 05/31/2011

Being an Arsenal support for two decades , my sentiment sours with constant failure of this "immaculately structured" team to make Arsenal Football Club proud.

Sometimes, I wonder if its the players or the manager that requires soul searching. Whoever the issue comes from, we must be aware that systemic errors only go to remind us something is really amiss.

When a person holds his/her believes and finds light at the end of the tunnel, thats a positive result. Otherwise, we need to evaluate the ability and relevance of that "vision".

Arsenal is a club with tremendous tradition and legacy. I sincerely feel its time to put the club's future ahead of the manager and players. The longer Arsenal Football Team gets mired with the reputation of "late losers", the tougher it is to emerge victorious in any competitions.
May be its time for the football club and its under-achieving manager to part ways. Even Cecs should be sold to bring some peace to Emirates stadium. Keep no unloyal.

  Post your comment
Name:
Email Address:
Comments:
characters left
About
David Young Sam Limbert: My retirement as a football player came at the age of 14 due to being rubbish, it's fair to say I was more Kaba Diawara than Thierry Henry, so I turned my focus to writing about the game. I'm a lifelong Arsenal fan and have been lucky enough to watch the team across England and Europe. My favourite Gunner of all time is Dennis Bergkamp, and the 2004 Invincibles is the greatest side I've ever seen in English football. I try to be positive about the Arsenal as it's the hope that keeps us going! Follow me on twitter @SamsMatchReport.

RSS feed

Categories
Recent Posts
Archives