ESPN Soccernet - Correspondents - Arsenal
soccernet blog
Arsenal
Posted by David Young on 10/17/2010

Arsenal got back to winning ways on Saturday by beating Birmingham 2-1 at Ashburton Grove. It was a performance that was more workmanlike and pragmatic than it was stylish but, with it having been just over a month since all three points were taken in a Premier League game, the result was the most important thing.

The Gunners had the better of the early exchanges without necessarily summoning the required tempo and impetus to make a break-through. Even so, several chances were carved out, none of which were taken. Too often, the frustratingly familiar option of an extra pass was chosen instead of a shot.


Nasri Converts His Penalty Kick to Level the Match ©Getty Images

With the current ball being used in the Premier League so prone to moving around in the air, you can’t help but wonder why the players don’t chance their arm more often from longer distance. Even if the shot is not heading for the top corner, the amount of swerve in flight these balls seem to undergo would surely force saves out of opposing goalkeepers that could lead to rebounds or, at least, corners.

It was Birmingham that opened the scoring though when, just after the half-hour, they finally provided their giant of a centre forward Nikola Zigic the sort of service he needed and the towering Serb despatched his header into the corner of the net beyond the flailing hand of Lucasz Fabianski. At 6ft 7in, Zigic’s height advantage was obvious and, if given with the sort of pinpoint cross he received for his goal yesterday on a more regular basis, he is going to cause plenty of defences problems this season.

Arsenal equalised seven minutes later courtesy of a Samir Nasri penalty after Marouane Chamakh was adjudged to have been felled in the area. Seen in real-time in the stadium, it looked a dubious decision. Whatever contact there was could only have been minimal and, certainly, City’s players protested long and loud about it. Still, from an Arsenal point of view, having been awarded the decision, it was down to Nasri to take full advantage and, once again, he proved that he is shaping up to be a very reliable penalty-taker.

It was Chamakh who then scored the winner just after the interval as he latched onto a deft Jack Wilshere pass. The Moroccan twisted, turned, took the ball round Ben Foster and slotted it home. From there, Arsenal looked reasonably comfortable for the remainder of the match and looked the more likely of the two teams to score again. City did conjure up a few moments of late pressure but barely forced a save out of Fabianski.

As the game played out though, it was Jack Wilshere’s sending off in injury-time that stole many of the headlines. Both manager and player accepted and acknowledged that under present-day interpretations of the laws of the game it was a red card challenge and he had to go. There were no real complaints from Arsenal fans either.

It was one of those moments where, sitting in the stands, you could almost see what was going to happen a split second before it did. Wilshere lost control of the ball and, in trying to atone for his error, lunged in to try and win it back. You knew if he caught the man instead of the ball it would be red card. He did, and it was. Thankfully, Zigic wasn’t badly hurt and got up to finish the match. It was a shame for Wilshere as he had been the best player on the pitch up until that point. He will now be suspended for three games which will be a blow to the considerable momentum he has built up over the past three months.

Undoubtedly, there will be plenty of people rubbing their hands together and smirking at the perceived embarrassment Wilshere’s dismissal would have caused Arsene Wenger after the Frenchman’s forthright comments on reckless tackling in the Premier League over the past couple of years. However, yesterday’s red card does not undermine Wenger’s point nor should it cause him any awkwardness.

Arsene Wenger is not a stupid man. He will have known that, even after the stand he has taken, at some point it was possible that one of his players would be dismissed for a bad challenge. All along though, the central tenet of his argument has concerned the wilful use of dangerous tackling and excessive physicality as a tactic for intimidation. There is no doubt that certain teams get sent out with instructions to rough opponents up, something that Danny Murphy of Fulham was brave enough to speak up about a week or so ago. Approaching the game with that attitude is obviously going to result in injuries, accidental or otherwise.

It is clear that Wilshere was not sent out with instructions to “do” anyone. Had he been, he wouldn’t have waited until injury-time with the game seemingly in the bag to have done it. It was a rash challenge which rightly deserved a red card but there was no intent to injure and, more importantly, no directive from the manager for him to have gone in the way he did.

Still, Wenger’s critics will use Wilshere’s red card as a stick to beat the Frenchman with and he will have to live with that. I am sure he will cope. It seems that only him and Danny Murphy seem to want to have a debate about the darker side of the modern game. Still, he has never had a problem with putting his head above the parapet in the past and I doubt the events of yesterday will change his opinions or outlook one iota.

Arsenal get back to Champions League business on Tuesday night at home to Shakhtar Donetsk. A victory would see them plant one foot in the second phase of the tournament. Like the Gunners, Shakhtar have a 100% record in the group so far to protect. It is sure to be tough game made all the more interesting by the swift return of Eduardo to Ashburton Grove. He will be welcomed back by the home support before the match - but that is as far as the goodwill will hopefully extend.

Comments

Posted by Sir kendo on 10/17/2010

Jack was on top of his game, i don't know what came over.

Posted by Maran on 10/18/2010

It was at best an unconvincing victory. The frailties were once again exposed. The defensive lapses were one too many. And the failure to convert numerous opportunities in the 18 yards were just frivolous. It was so obvious no one in the team wants to take the responsibility of scoring. The training routine may have been too ingrained in the players as such no one was able to see beyong passing, even with open chances. Chamakh's goal was an aberration. They did not show the desire to score. Diaby, had twice turned his back to goal when leading excellent counter-attacks. Arshavin was in such sad state of denial with mis-passes at crucial stages. And this attitude even led to some comical mix-up involving Arshavin, Chamakh and Diaby at penalty box. I think we are very close to "Boring Boring Arsenal". It need not be the George Graham's 1-0 to Arsenal team, but the current Arsenal situation is close enough to be a broken record stuck with the same tune.

Posted by Maran on 10/18/2010

I think the only spark in the Arsenal team came in the form of Jack Wishere. He had the heart, desire to surge forward and the tenacity to chase and tackle. But alas, his only mistimed tackle marred his otherwise excellent match. He is a player the rest of the team have much to learn from. He is the only one who still showed life in the closing minutes, when many in the team got tired. The new recruit, Chamakh shamefully walked with his hands on his hips and even jogged on the field when there was a counter by his teammates. That's a shame when a 18 year old boy was still running his heart out. Wishere certainly lacks experience and I agree his recent momentum will be affected by the red card. But I see the future of Arsenal in this boy. It is very important he gets the games. Partly for his development and partly for his team mates to learn something from him. That certainly includes the drive and the spirit.

Posted by Kevin on 10/18/2010

Shades of grey hover over the evergreen pitch of Arsenal these days. A much needed win to an otherwise disappointing run of games. The loss to West Brom was one-off, but the loss at Stamford Bridge was reminiscent, it was all too familiar. Have we really improved? or are we again* just missing the key players? The defensive department is still unconvincing, and pardon me for comparing to the Invincibles because i was there when we were the pride of London, but this team just lacks the cutting edge to grind out results and win titles imo. I tell myself repeatedly, trust in Arsene, keep the faith and that's what i've been doing for years since that faithful day where Vieira lifted the Epl trophy; we looked down at all our opponents in conceit. I yearn the glory days, i really do; keep the faith, gooner forever.

Posted by Dave on 10/18/2010

So many shooting opportunities presented to Diaby and he choose to pass the instead. I am not so sure about the current mentality of the Arsenal players, are they instructucted in such way or, they just don't have the common football sense to take a shot at goal. Wenger must change the mentality of the players, it is getting to a point where it is very irritating watching Arsenal play.

Posted by Brian on 10/18/2010

Danny Murphy didn't have to be brave to criticize Stoke, Blackburn, and Wolves, considering it's the most fashionable thing to talk about in football right now.

Posted by ayo on 10/18/2010

Arsenal,did play well but we need to improve our scoring opportunities,because some chances comes back to hunt us but it is better to win in an ugly way than play well and loose badly, 3 point and a win that's the score. Arshvan is a very lazy payer i wish he goes away b4 the young lad,s learn's from his lazyness.

Posted by ifeanyi udemezue on 10/18/2010

I have absolutely nothing against Jack. He has to be a hard tackler to survive the thugs in the EPL. They will undo and intimidate him if he is not tough and strong especially given his age and size. This was the way Vieira started in the EPL. There must be a combination of brain and brawn. Jack has the brain and i am glad that he is acquiring the other attribute.

Posted by M.Wylie on 10/18/2010

Arsenal will miss Wilshere but he must take his medicine. I have to call out two players. Diaby. I don't rate him. He is not physical enough to be a holding midfielder. And he is not clever enough to play behind the striker. I lost count of the number of times he dribbled so well to attack the 18-yard box - then did nothing. Not a pass, not a shot, invariably a sideways or retreating pass, asking someone else to figure out what next to do. Diaby can't help us win titles. Arshavin. I lost count of his misplaced passes and showy flicks that surrendered possession. What was his pass completion rate that game? I bet it made shocking reading. Arshavin worries he has not "sparkled" at Arsenal like he did for his previous club. Well Andrei, I'd trade smart passes, shots on goal and more application over "sparkly" flicks and backheels anyday. Last though: Nasri our best performer so far this season? He gets my vote. If lone striker must be, then play Nasri in behind. Go Gunners!

Posted by Lim Deming on 10/18/2010

I concur that Jack will be a great player for Arsenal....without Cesc...he is really lifting the midfield admirably well for such a young player...
reminds me abit of cesc when he first started out ( lacked the goals before he stepped up)...No harm if Wilshere goes penetrates forward more and attempt to pop a shot or too at times when near on goal(i think he packs a good shot actually)...it's a pity he will now miss 3 games because he really look like he has found his rhythm and momentum and starting to repay the confidence Arsene has in him.

Posted by beejay on 10/18/2010

My concern like a million and one arsenal fans is that the new generation are jus too fanciful to be convincing.
When did taking a shot become a crime in arsenal, lookin back @ the ray parlors, the fredricks, henrys and that endless list, they played the arsenal way but was never shy in the penalty box.
These boys need to start shooting particularly in and around the box...

Posted by albert on 10/18/2010

Good result for the gunners. Chamakh is, however, gradually making a name for himself in the premiership --- as a consumate diver.

Posted by Babyface on 10/18/2010

Did anyone think the commentator were biased against Arsenal and so one sided? Both sides have supporters watching the game for Pete's sake, at least try to be impartial and don't side with one side and criticize the other. If you have nothing good to say about the other team just give us play by play and keep your opinions to yourself.

Posted by Swizzy on 10/18/2010

Good read, David. I thought the Gunners performed with a bit more urgency when they tackled and clearly didn't want to get bullied themselves. I was happy with the defensive performance and the willingness of the midfield to show some steel, though I agree, young Wilshere did deserve the card, and we were lucky that Eboue did not get sent off for his scissor tackle as well.

I wanted to ask you about your thoughts on Johann Djourou's play. I felt he was much more convincing in the back than Squillaci, in that he did what was necessary to protect the goal. Also, his height gave us a better option when facing taller more imposing opponents. Yes, one goal was conceded to a very tall player, but I felt Djourou did a good job in other instances against Zigic, and simultaneously added another aerial threat for us from set pieces. What did you think of his performance? Don't you feel he should get more chances in the first team, at least for the UCL so we can rotate/rest defenders?

Posted by anthony (Jamaica) on 10/18/2010

I agree with my fellow gooners, too oftain we play the ball to the 18yds box and then lack the interest to kick the ball in the goal.Look at the game with chelsea,their manager was quite content to have Drogba,Anelka and even Remeres waiting at the 1/2 line while Arsenal play around with the ball in and around their box. Why? All in the epl know we will not shoot the ball and so as we loose the ball the counter against us will be devastating, and that led to Alex's peach of a goal against us.The mentality of the forwards need to change where we see a hunger to dispatch the ball very oftain in the back of the oponent's net.Also the defence line need sone tightening up.All praise to Jack fighting spirit ,can you inagine if all the forwards were like him, the glory days would surely be back.The fans in Jamaica are crying(bawling) out for silverware, players, hear the thunderous sound from the caribbean and show us that you intend to remedy the drought of silverware.To the world.

Posted by thierry on 10/18/2010

God help the gunners,i think we need to start praying bekos our current squad needs to do much to reach the level of being chhampions.

Posted by CK on 10/19/2010


Unable to turn the possession into goal still Arsenal weakness, especially under no buffer goal situation, and easily turn the win to a draw, like the example against Sunderland. ( lucky this time due to weak powerforce from the blue) Style soccer need to furnish with goal to be perfect. Blackpool attitude against Man City is a good guide

Posted by David Fitch on 10/19/2010

A win and three points is just what was required the worrying part is that Birmingham tactics were in the main correct and only a referee decision separated the teams. They defended well they gave Arsenal the mid-field and the only way forward was to go sideways enabling them to get plenty of players back to defend, Arsenal failure to convert chances will come back to haunt them. The next game against Manchester city is where they will come up against a good defense and players that can counter attack, team that Arsenal do poor against so could drop more points unless they find ways to convert there chances.As for Mr Wenger it is always easier to attack the person rather than engage in the merits of the opinion.

Posted by Omundu_Arsenal on 10/19/2010

We need to change our strategy and shoot. we had over 20 shooting chances with Diaby the main culprit but am sure if we tried shooting atleast 3 would have ended in the net and maybe 8 would have been rebounds

Posted by tapiwa batsirai on 10/19/2010

They really miss the likes of Theo...The kid is not afraid to take the shot.I really see it in the way diaby looks for the extra pass and Nasri for the extra dribble but they dont look for the shot the way Walcott does.Am looking forward to see him back in the squad..He is a match winner. Give Jack a little more time and the rash challenges will disapear...Gooners for life.

Posted by godfrey lukwago on 10/19/2010

i really enjoy asernal the gunners but me am of the view that this bussines of rollling the ball in the eighteen yard box is not good though at times it helps , but also looping can help.as wise asernal is my team.

Posted by Sir Moses on 10/19/2010

This is gonna be replicated on sunday against Manchester United. Gooners we are back with a bhang!

Posted by Dave Pack on 10/19/2010

We had to listen to that bleeding Birmingham Blue prat Trevor Francis provide colour for the match, broadcast in the USA on FSC, and I finally had to turn the sound down because of the incessant, one-sided rubbish spewing from his blue-lipped cake hole. Gawd, I can't bloody stand him and his anti-Arsenal rhetoric. Give me Gary O'Reilly for color any day.

Posted by JoeUSA on 10/19/2010

I think this whole issue about tackling is overblown after a couple of controversial incidents. What premier league season doesn't involve some reckless and dangerous tackles that result in sometimes justified (as in this case) and sometimes questionable sending offs?

Wilshere hasn't been asked to contribute for the entirety of a premier league season before, so 3 matches on the sidelines might do his legs a lot of good in the long run, especially if Cesc returns in his stead.

Posted by JAYCEE on 10/19/2010

Hi, to all gooners fans. I think a plyer like diaby should not be an arsenal player.

Posted by deng jima bior. on 10/20/2010

Its well done by the gunners stars to the world that got some talent to come from behind to beat Birmingham.thanks to all the players and my manager Arsene Wenger.

Posted by Peter on 10/20/2010

We labour so much for games we should win easily,the next test (man city)is a good one,anything less than a draw means we are not serious contenders,Period!

Posted by kkb on 10/21/2010

Arsenal will increase their chances if AW buys Rooney. Possesion doesn't guarantee 3 points as we have seen many times. Arsenal is always 1 pass too many. We need strike like Rooney.
Practise shooting gonners!

Posted by Velk on 10/21/2010

I have just finished reading the diatribe posted by the Stoke correspondent and though I hate to dignify articles like that with a response, I was interested in what sort of response you would give him.

DY replies:

I think he has enough responses to deal with already!

I hadn't read what he wrote until you pointed it out. He is entitled to his opinion and I have given mine in the piece I wrote above.

However, I would suggest that if Arsene Wenger is managing to invoke so much annoyance and bile amongst opposing supporters, he is probably doing something right.

DY

Posted by kacak on 10/21/2010

do you know among arsenal player for 12 matches (nasri have 75% with 8 matches out of 12), rosicky have best end result? 5 starts resulting 100% win (at least 2 goals), but when used as subs, best was won by 1 goal margin. wilshere had 100% involvement but from 10 starts had 2 draws and 1 lost. same as arshavin and chamakh (100% involvement), they had 2 draws and 2 losts when started. the captain, fabregas involve just 50% (6 matches with 5 starts and 1 sub) and he had 1 draw in match where he started. i think arsenal can get better result if use a better midfielder (work rate and creativity) and finisher

Posted by skarz on 10/21/2010

kudos to the boys for their wondrful performance but i think charmak still need to work harder for him to be able to convert his chances.for mancity we need to prove ourself to be a contender for the league.i wish u guys best of luck.

Posted by Don on 10/21/2010

3 points is the most important thing no matter how boring.

On the performance unfortunately two player are suffering with confidence. Arshavin and Diaby. I still think Arshavin has never been comfortable playing on the wing. He just does not have the work rate. I would try him behind the striker in a central forward midfield role.
Diaby has flashes of excellence but not consistent enough. I remember a couple of goals from him from distance, he needs to start shooting again. He is definitely not a forward mid fielder. Nasri is a better option.
Fabregas and Walcott should be back for Man City, that is great news. Also Bentner. All three are quality players that make this team better. I wish Vermaelen would come back, we really miss his leadership at the back. Fabianski has been solid, he is getting his confidence back. Please no more Almunia.

Posted by lalok_gunners on 10/22/2010

arsenal played OK again birmingham....

arshavin dissapointing again...
he looks like didnt fit for the match...
so do diaby..
he's too slow, overdribbled and always turn back from opponent's goal when in counter attack...
chamakh wins the penalty and scored the winner...
i believe he'll score more...
and his work rate incredible as always..
but the spotlight goes to wilshere...
great display from him but the red coz him to be suspended for 3 matches...
i always like to watch him play alongside cesc like in against shakhtar...
he has been impressive so far this season...
but hope he improve in tackling.....
he still have much time ahead of him....
promising future prospect...

live on gunners!!!!

Posted by steve louis on 10/22/2010

Stoke's guy a lot more convincing than you, mate. Arsenal still a few years from any type of trophy, and that is if Cesc stays, if he goes, oh dear god.

Posted by Chris on 10/23/2010

I have been on about the lack of shooting for a long while now. When RVP is out of the team, there seems to be a confusion as to who will shoot. I never thought Arsenal's defense was that bad, they just always had to deal with the frustration of consistently wasting chances to score. Put away a couple of the early chances we create and the defense can concentrate on their job. AW needs to do something about this.

Posted by ifeanyi ochonogor on 10/24/2010

I think the problem with arsenal is too many young legs..take a look at chelsea and man utd they use marchure boys and they are succeeding. Though our young stars play well they should concentrate on how to use goal opportunity.

Posted by willy on 10/24/2010

wonderful boys

Posted by ESPN Stoke Correspondent on 10/28/2010

If I could just add to this, albeit belatedly...
The reason my piece was so driven at Wenger was that he behaved differently with his own players than he does when sinned against. If you look at Wilshere's tackle, by Wenger's standards, he should have been publically flogged as that's what he does when any other team does what Wilshere did.

In terms of the 'bile', I can tell you that I enjoy the football Arsenal play and until we got to the Prem, I liked AW. However, I think his behaviour since we beat you at The Brit (where he told Pulis we were deserved winners then went running to the Press in the safety of London) is inexcusable. His constant sniping at the team and players is alarming and this vendetta he has with Shawcross unhealthy and obsessive. The tipping point was the lie he made up about him kicking Gomes, I'm not sure what he was seeking to do with that other than discredit the player and I find that unacceptable. In this case he is far from 'doing something right'...

Posted by wong on 01/04/2011

1) I would like challenge AW to convert these 4 players into WORLD CLASS PLAYERS to add to his own list of success stories...

2) Why denied them playing time when they have so much potential...Wojciech Szczesny & Manoe (young Italian GK). You might just unearth THE RAW DIAMOND.

3) Central defender Johan Djourou has been proving himself ROCK SOLID & match savior in so many occasions,would definitely like to see him move into more visible role in Gunner central defence role week in & week out...

4) Also can't wait to see Nicklas Bendtner converted to WORLD CLASS central back.(He is the only player that have the physical strength not to bully by Dragba or rough team like Blackburn & Stoke.

AW, are you ready to write new success story by developing younger players again??? You have lot of success for midfielders & strikers; I would love to see WORLD CLASS GOALKEEPER & CENTRAL DEFENDER IN YOUR LIST TOO... Thank you.

Fabianski is more decent now..Pls give other GK a chance too

  Post your comment
Name:
Email Address:
Comments:
characters left
About
David Young Sam Limbert: My retirement as a football player came at the age of 14 due to being rubbish, it's fair to say I was more Kaba Diawara than Thierry Henry, so I turned my focus to writing about the game. I'm a lifelong Arsenal fan and have been lucky enough to watch the team across England and Europe. My favourite Gunner of all time is Dennis Bergkamp, and the 2004 Invincibles is the greatest side I've ever seen in English football. I try to be positive about the Arsenal as it's the hope that keeps us going! Follow me on twitter @SamsMatchReport.

RSS feed

Categories
Recent Posts
Archives